Association of Professional Rental Organizations (APRO)

Era of Expansion: From Experiment to Industry

Skip to endnotes

By 1980, the rent-to-own (RTO) model had crossed an important threshold. What began in the 1960s as scattered experiments — Ernie Talley’s Mr. T’s in Wichita, Tom Devlin and W. Frank Barton’s first Rent-A-Center stores, and Charlie Loudermilk’s early Aaron’s showrooms — had matured into a recognizable industry. The founding of the Association of Progressive Rental Organizations (APRO) that year signaled this shift, but APRO’s creation was only a mile marker. The real engine of change in the 1980s and 90s was the consumer revolution unfolding inside American living rooms and the entrepreneurs who scaled RTO to meet that demand.

The 1980s launched a wave of new household technologies. Videocassette recorders (VCRs) arrived first, followed by camcorders, stereo systems, and increasingly larger televisions. By the mid-80s, personal computers were moving from offices and universities into family homes. Each device carried the same sort of cultural weight that televisions and microwaves had in the 1970s: having them meant belonging in the present — and indicating readiness for the future — while giving children the tools they would need to compete for better opportunities. To go without was to feel, and often to be, excluded.

Entertainment illustrates this point most clearly. In 1980, fewer than 2% of American households owned a VCR. By 1990, more than 75% owned one. This increase in ownership redefined evenings at home. Families no longer had to depend upon broadcast schedules or movie theaters; they could rent tapes from Blockbuster or local video stores — or record their favorite TV shows — and watch at their leisure. The VCR was not just a machine; it was a ticket into a new cultural rhythm.

Computers carried a similar urgency. The IBM PC in 1981 and Apple’s Macintosh in 1984 signaled that computing power was no longer confined to corporations or laboratories. Parents began to view home computers as tools for their children’s education and as preparation for the future of work. By the end of the decade, a family without a computer risked being left behind as employers and schools increasingly assumed familiarity with digital technology and possession of that technology at home.

Those emerging technologies were expensive. A VCR cost several hundred dollars at launch, and a personal computer cost well over a thousand dollars. For households with irregular income or weak credit histories, those prices represented an insurmountable barrier to ownership. Credit cards expanded rapidly in the 1980s, but they served prime borrowers first. Double-digit interest rates and punitive fees made them dangerous tools for families already living paycheck to paycheck. Department-store layaway programs were still common, but the structure had not changed. A family could make payments toward a television as their circumstances allowed, but the product stayed at the store until the last payment was made. By then, the technology might be outdated, and the family might have missed the cultural moment entirely.

Rent-to-own’s entrance into this retail landscape was perfectly timed. Its formula was perfected in the 1970s: small weekly or monthly payments, no credit checks, immediate access, and the option to return without penalty. In the 1980s, this formula aligned with a consumer revolution. Families wanted to watch movies at home now, not in six months. They wanted their children typing school reports on computers now, not after saving for years. They wanted to record birthdays and weddings on camcorders now, not after the moments had passed.

For these households, RTO was not an alternative to credit. It was the only practical way to participate in the cultural mainstream. By structuring rental agreements as renewable leases, rent-to-own allowed families to enjoy the benefits of new technology on day one, without the debt trap that had plagued installment credit for decades.

Entrepreneurs saw the alignment and moved aggressively. Rent-A-Center expanded rapidly beyond Kansas. The first wave of expansion was fueled by Devlin and Barton’s vision and was followed by Thorn EMI’s acquisition in 1987, which brought international capital and the discipline of corporate retailing.1 Aaron’s, already the largest furniture rental company in the South, expanded into new regions by combining operational efficiency with the deep community trust that had defined the industry since its inception.2 And Willie Talley’s ColorTyme, founded in 1979, pioneered franchising as a way for individual entrepreneurs to enter RTO with the support of a national brand.

The dual expansion — chains and franchises — produced explosive industrywide growth. Thousands of rent-to-own stores opened across the country in the 1980s and 90s, turning rent-to-own into a visible fixture of the American retail landscape. Buying groups such as The Rental Industry Buying (TRIB) Group emerged, allowing independent retailers to pool purchasing power and secure better deals from major vendors. Manufacturers like Whirlpool, RCA, and Sony developed dedicated programs for the RTO channel, recognizing it as a legitimate path to market. Storefronts themselves evolved, moving away from pawn-shop stereotypes toward bright, clean showrooms stocked with name-brand products.

For consumers, the rent-to-own experience became increasingly indistinguishable from mainstream retail — with one key difference. Department stores required credit, banks demanded applications, and credit cards punished missed payments with interest rates that could double the cost of goods. RTO simply asked for a paycheck and a willingness to keep making payments. Delivery, service, and repairs were included, lending to the sense that the rent-to-own experience was comparable to traditional retailers. Ownership in the future was available, but inclusion in the cultural moment was immediate.

Critics told a different story. As the industry grew, scrutiny from journalists, regulators, and consumer advocates grew with it. Reports calculated the total cost of ownership if customers made every payment to term and concluded that RTO was too expensive. They compared sticker prices at Sears to the cumulative cost at Rent-A-Center and labeled the difference exploitative. What those analyses missed — and what customers clearly understood — was that rent-to-own was always structured as a lease, not a loan. There was no penalty for stopping payments, no deficiency balance after return, and no damage to customer credit. The choice was never between Sears and Rent-A-Center. For many households, the real choice was between inclusion through RTO or exclusion altogether.

By the end of the 1980s, the outlines of the modern industry were unmistakable. Rent-to-own was no longer a set of regional experiments. It was a national business model with chains, franchises, and buying groups. It was an industry that had learned to market itself with the same polish as department stores while continuing to serve households excluded from credit. The foundation for expansion had been laid, and the 1990s would only accelerate this trajectory.

APRO’s creation in 1980 provided an important layer of stability during this period. While entrepreneurs drove growth on the ground, APRO helped policymakers and the public understand RTO as something distinct from pawn shops or installment sellers. In reality, the story of the 1980s and 90s rested on three pillars: 1) families demanding access to the technologies defining modern life; 2) entrepreneurs building businesses to meet that demand; and 3) APRO giving the industry the structure and legitimacy it needed to expand without collapsing under outside pressure. Together, these pillars turned rent-to-own from a movement into a marketplace, demonstrating once again that access was the real product rental dealers were selling.

From Movement to Marketplace

When the 1980s began, rent-to-own was still best described as a fledgling movement. While RTO had spread widely, it still lacked the coherence and polish of established retail industries. Stores were often small local operations created by entrepreneurs who had seen demand in their communities and moved to meet it. The common thread was a customer base excluded from mainstream credit but eager to adopt the technologies defining modern life. What the rent-to-own industry did not yet have was the sense of being a fully realized marketplace with national reach, vendor partnerships, and brand power. The transition to a more traditional marketplace began in the 1980s and gathered speed in the 1990s.

The founding of APRO marked the beginning of that evolution, but not as a result of the association creating more demand — American families had already shown that demand was enormous. Instead, APRO put a spotlight on what was happening across the country. Dozens of independent operators had built thriving businesses that were fulfilling a need, and with APRO, they now shared a forum to compare practices, trade ideas, and defend themselves against critics. This spotlight was enough to give the RTO industry a new base of stability, and it opened the door for the next phase of development.

The real transformation came from the entrepreneurs who were willing to think bigger. Rent-to-own was no longer about simply proving the concept, as Ernie Talley had done with Mr. T’s in Wichita. By the 1980s, it was about scaling. Rent-A-Center, Aaron’s, and later ColorTyme all drove in this direction, and independent operators were not far behind. These operators understood that RTO was not a niche service, but a repeatable business model with mass-market potential.

Tradeshows helped accelerate the shift toward scalability. Furniture and appliance markets in places like High Point, North Carolina, and Tupelo, Mississippi, became unofficial gathering places for rental dealers. What had once been quiet conversations between small operators began to coalesce into shared knowledge about how to run the business more efficiently, how to source products, and how to manage customers effectively. Buying groups emerged from these conversations, most notably TRIB Group, which gave independent stores access to pricing and terms that once had been reserved only for national chains. These developments gave rental dealers something that looked increasingly like a marketplace: not just isolated stores, but a connected network with supply chains, shared services, and an emerging professional identity.

Vendors also began to take notice. By the mid-1980s, major brands like Whirlpool and RCA were developing programs tailored specifically for rent-to-own dealers — a significant milestone. Until then, manufacturers had often viewed RTO operators as marginal buyers, far less important than department stores, regional chains, or emerging big-box retailers like Best Buy and Circuit City. But as rent-to-own store counts multiplied, vendors recognized a valuable sales channel that could reach customers that traditional retailers were failing to serve. Whirlpool refrigerators and RCA televisions became mainstays of RTO showrooms, and Sony electronics and Compaq computers soon followed. When brand-name products filled the sales floor, the customer experience changed dramatically. Rent-to-own no longer meant hand-me-down goods or refurbished leftovers. It meant the same products advertised in glossy magazines and on national television were now available to households that other retailers excluded.

This perception shift was crucial. Throughout the 1970s, RTO stores had often battled the stereotype of being glorified pawn shops or purveyors of secondhand goods. By the 1980s, that image was fading. Customers could now walk into brightly lit stores with organized displays of brand-new merchandise, well arranged in living room and bedroom sets, or connected to stereo systems and VCRs. The polish was intentional. Operators like Tom Devlin understood the future of the industry depended on presentation. If stores looked professional, if products were brand-new, and if marketing matched the sophistication of mainstream retail, then rent-to-own would be seen as a legitimate option rather than a fringe practice.

Advertising played a key role in this evolution. Campaigns featuring slogans like “No Credit Needed” or “Everyone’s Approved” captured the essence of what made RTO attractive while differentiating it from banks and department stores. Rent-A-Center popularized the “$1 Pays Your First Week” promotion, which lowered the psychological barrier for first-time customers and conveyed the promise of immediate access. Aaron’s leaned heavily on community connections and customer trust, building a reputation as a reliable neighborhood store while slowly expanding its footprint across the South. These approaches varied, but together, they built a public image of rent-to-own as an industry that was here to stay.

At the same time, franchising created a parallel pathway for expansion. Willie Talley’s founding of ColorTyme in 1979 was just the beginning. By the mid-1980s, dozens of entrepreneurs who had never worked in RTO before were buying into the franchise system. For them, the appeal was obvious: a proven business model, brand recognition, vendor access, and training programs that lessened the learning curve. Franchising multiplied the industry’s reach into towns and mid-sized cities where national chains had not yet arrived, accelerating the spread of the model and reinforcing its legitimacy.

This was the moment when rent-to-own truly shifted from a movement to a marketplace. A movement is driven by energy and conviction, but often lacks structure. A marketplace is defined by repeatability, systems, and competition. By the late 1980s, RTO had all of those qualities. Competition among chains, franchises, and independent retailers intensified, creating pressure to operate more efficiently, advertise more effectively, and offer more products. Supply chains became more formalized as vendors recognized the strength of the category. Trade groups and buying groups gave independent operators the leverage they needed to compete. Customers now had a choice between multiple RTO stores in their communities, which meant that service quality and store presentation mattered more than ever. Just as importantly, the industry now offered a far wider range of national brands, making it possible for households to acquire almost any mainstream product through RTO. What began as scattered experiments had become a fully functioning marketplace.

The transition carried cultural significance as well. Families who once might have felt hesitant to walk into a small, dimly lit rent-to-own shop could now confidently enter a professional storefront, be greeted by trained staff, and choose from name-brand products. The experience mirrored what they would find in any other retail store, but without worry about the humiliation of being turned away for bad credit. For millions of households, this was about much more than convenience. It was about inclusion, and it came at a moment when access to the technologies of modern life was becoming inseparable from dignity itself.

By the time the 1990s began, the change was unmistakable. Rent-to-own was no longer an emerging movement defined by scattered operators and pioneering entrepreneurs. It was a national marketplace, complete with chains, franchises, buying groups, vendor programs, advertising campaigns, and recognizable brands. It had moved from proving the model worked to demonstrating that it could scale, compete, and endure. The groundwork was set for the explosive growth that would follow over the next decade, when store counts multiplied and RTO became a fixture of American consumer life.

Scaling Chains: Rent-A-Center’s National Model

Rent-A-Center’s rise in the 1980s defined what it meant to scale rent-to-own. The company did not invent the model — Ernie Talley had proven the lease-to-own idea in Wichita, Kansas, two decades earlier — but it perfected the formula for national growth.

Tom Devlin, who began as a manager at Mr. T’s Rental, carried forward Talley’s insight that at the start, access mattered more than ownership. Where Devlin differed was in presentation. He believed that, for rent-to-own to reach its full potential, storefronts had to look like mainstream retailers. Customers needed to see bright showrooms, organized displays, and name-brand products. They had to feel they were part of the same consumer culture as their neighbors — not settling for a second-tier shopping experience.

Devlin found the right partner in W. Frank Barton. Barton was an established businessman with capital, vendor connections, and experience in distribution. In 1973, the two men opened the first Rent-A-Center in Wichita. The model was simple but powerful: short agreements, renewal flexibility, new merchandise, and professional presentation. The formula worked immediately, and expansion followed.

Through the 1970s, Rent-A-Center opened stores beyond Kansas, spreading into surrounding states. By the 1980s, the company had become a known regional chain, and the timing could not have been better. VCRs, larger televisions, stereo systems, and computers were entering American homes at a fast pace, and millions of families lacked the credit to buy them outright. Rent-A-Center became their bridge.

Advertising gave the chain a distinctive voice. Promotions like “$1 Pays Your First Week” removed the fear of commitment and invited customers to try the product. “No Credit Needed” spoke directly to households excluded from banks and credit-card issuers. These slogans captured the essence of rent-to-own, while making the offer simple and clear. Customers understood immediately what the company promised: inclusion without the barriers of traditional finance.

Rent-A-Center’s growth also reflected operational discipline. Stores followed a standardized layout, with furniture grouped into living room and bedroom sets, televisions displayed prominently, and appliances arranged to highlight utility. The goal was consistency. A customer walking into a Rent-A-Center in Kansas should have the same experience as one in Texas or Oklahoma. This consistency was essential in transforming what had once been a dispersed model into a brand that felt stable and trustworthy.

In 1987, the company attracted international attention when Thorn EMI, a British conglomerate with interests in music, film, and electronics, acquired Rent-A-Center. The deal brought more credibility, fresh capital, and the resources to accelerate expansion. For Thorn, the appeal was clear. RTO offered a way to place televisions, stereos, and other electronics — many of which Thorn produced or distributed — into households that mainstream retail wasn’t reaching. For Rent-A-Center, the acquisition validated what Devlin and Barton had believed all along: RTO could be scaled nationally and attract global investment.

The years that followed saw rapid growth. Rent-A-Center moved aggressively into new markets, establishing a footprint in multiple states and positioning itself as the national leader in RTO. Store counts climbed into the hundreds, and by the early 1990s, Rent-A-Center was a household name. Its advertising was seen on television, its stores became common in mid-sized cities, and its message — no credit, immediate access — resonated across income levels.

Yet growth brought challenges. Critics argued that customers were paying two or three times the sticker price if they carried agreements to full term. Consumer media outlets portrayed Rent-A-Center as emblematic of predatory retail, echoing earlier debates over installment sales. But the criticism missed the reality of customer choice. For households without savings or credit, the comparison was not between Sears and Rent-A-Center. It was between exclusion and participation. Rent-A-Center’s customers were not duped; they were making rational decisions within the limits of their circumstances.

Rent-A-Center’s scale also created a cultural shift inside the industry. Independent operators could no longer think of themselves as isolated pioneers. They were now competing against a national chain with advertising muscle, vendor leverage, and standardized practices. This competition pushed independents to professionalize. Stores became cleaner, more organized, and more service-focused. The presence of a giant like Rent-A-Center set the standard that others had to meet to survive.

Technology supported the expansion. Early point-of-sale (POS) systems and inventory-management tools gave Rent-A-Center tighter control over operations. These systems tracked payments, monitored product movement, and reduced risk of loss. For an industry often criticized as chaotic, the introduction of consistent data systems mattered. Rent-A-Center was not just scaling in store count; it was scaling in operational sophistication.

The company’s growth also highlighted a paradox. The same features that made rent-to-own attractive to customers — flexibility, no credit checks, easy returns — made the business model vulnerable to volatility. Economic downturns could drive higher returns and lower revenues. To manage that risk, Rent-A-Center emphasized scale. A large national footprint allowed losses in one region to be offset by gains in another. Standardization across stores gave management better tools to adjust to local conditions.

By the early 1990s, Rent-A-Center had established itself as the industry’s flagship chain. It proved that RTO could shed its small-store image and operate as a professional retail model with national presence. It also proved that the logic of access without debt resonated across demographics, not just within isolated communities. The company’s rise validated the claim that RTO was not a fringe alternative, but a structural element of American retail.

A Southern Cousin: Aaron’s Expansion

While Rent-A-Center was building a national chain from Wichita, another RTO story was unfolding in Atlanta, Georgia. Charles Loudermilk, known to most as Charlie, founded Aaron Rents in 1955 with little more than a $500 loan and an idea that equipment could be rented as easily as it could be sold. His first business was modest: he rented folding chairs to local auction houses and civic events. The concept worked, and it gave Loudermilk the seed capital to begin thinking bigger.

By the 1960s, Loudermilk had expanded into furniture. His approach was simple but disciplined. Instead of chasing rapid growth, he reinvested profits carefully and avoided heavy debt. He opened furniture rental showrooms that catered to working families who wanted living room sets, beds, or appliances, but could not afford to buy them upfront. By 1964, Aaron Rents had its first dedicated furniture rental store, and over the next decade, the business grew steadily.

Loudermilk was more than a businessman. He was a community figure in Atlanta, and his business reflected his values. In 1965, he famously provided tents to Martin Luther King, Jr.’s team for the Selma to Montgomery civil rights march. The gesture symbolized what would become a hallmark of Aaron’s: connection to community. Customers did not see just a storefront; they saw a company that understood its place in local neighborhoods and was willing to invest in them.

By the mid-1970s, Aaron Rents had nearly 20 showrooms, was generating close to $10 million in annual revenue, and had become the largest furniture rental company in the country. Loudermilk had built the business carefully, but the scale was undeniable. While Rent-A-Center was still proving its model in Kansas and neighboring states, Aaron’s had already shown in the South that rental could be a serious, sustainable business.

Part of Aaron’s success came from its hybrid structure. Unlike Rent-A-Center, which moved decisively into short-term renewable leases, Aaron’s blended traditional furniture rental with a purchase option. Some customers rented indefinitely, while others transitioned into ownership after steady payments. Loudermilk also invested in vertical integration. In 1971, he created an in-house manufacturing division to supply his stores with furniture, ensuring that Aaron’s could control costs and maintain quality. This gave the company an edge in meeting demand while preserving margins.

Aaron’s also emphasized service. Delivery, setup, and repairs were bundled into agreements, reinforcing the idea that customers were not just acquiring furniture, but gaining peace of mind. This service focus became an essential part of the Aaron’s brand. Families who could not risk the expense of a broken refrigerator or a faulty washing machine knew that Aaron’s would handle problems without surprise costs.

By 1980, Aaron Rents was positioned for even greater expansion. In addition to furniture, Loudermilk’s stores carried appliances, televisions, and other household staples. His company had proven that rental was not a side business, but a major consumer channel. The next decade saw Aaron’s expand further across the South and into new regions, gradually building the infrastructure that would make it a national competitor to Rent-A-Center.

Where Rent-A-Center emphasized mass advertising and aggressive growth, Aaron’s leaned on solid reputation and community presence. Loudermilk often said the company succeeded because it built trust. Customers returned, not only because of flexible agreements, but also because they felt respected. This approach resonated well in Southern markets, where word-of-mouth reputation carried significant weight.

Aaron’s expansion also highlighted a broader truth about the rent-to-own industry: there was no single path to success. Rent-A-Center’s formula of standardized showrooms and national advertising worked in one context. Aaron’s method of careful reinvestment, vertical integration, and community trust worked in another. Both approaches underscored the same consumer reality. Families needed access to goods, and they valued flexibility and dignity more than the lowest possible price.

By the late 1980s, Aaron Rents was no longer just a Southern chain. It was preparing for national expansion, competing directly with Rent-A-Center in some markets, and carving out its own reputation as the most trusted name in furniture and appliance rental. Loudermilk had demonstrated that RTO could be scaled not only through aggressive growth, but also through disciplined management and deep community connection. His company provided the industry with a second anchor: if Rent-A-Center demonstrated how RTO could become a national chain, then Aaron’s showed how it could grow into a national institution rooted in service and trust.

Franchising Takes Hold: ColorTyme and Other

If Rent-A-Center exemplified how a chain could scale through capital and standardization, and Aaron’s illustrated how a regional company could grow through trust and discipline, ColorTyme proved something different: how rent-to-own could be franchised. Willie Talley, brother of Ernie Talley, recognized by the late 1970s that interest in the rent-to-own model was spreading beyond Wichita and Atlanta. Furniture dealers, appliance retailers, and entrepreneurs from other industries were watching the success of Mr. T’s and Rent-A-Center and asking how they could replicate it. The challenge was that few had a playbook. Rent-to-own agreements were still new, operational practices varied widely, and no standardized system existed for running stores. Willie saw an opportunity to solve this by offering a turnkey business — a ready-made brand, operational framework, and experienced guidance — for independent operators who wanted to enter the RTO market but needed a proven system to follow.

In 1979, Talley founded ColorTyme in Texas with the goal of creating the first rent-to-own franchise system.3 His timing was deliberate. The model had already been proven, and consumer demand was surging with the arrival of VCRs and home electronics. What the industry still lacked was a way for aspiring rental dealers to enter the market quickly and facing less risk of failure.

Franchising offered exactly that. A ColorTyme franchisee received branding, standardized agreements, vendor relationships, and operating manuals. Instead of building a business from scratch, a local entrepreneur could open a store under a recognized name and benefit from collective purchasing power. For vendors, franchising created consistency as well. Whirlpool or RCA could work with ColorTyme headquarters and know their products would flow into stores following uniform standards.

The model caught on quickly. By the mid-1980s, ColorTyme had hundreds of franchise locations across the country. Many were in towns and mid-sized cities that national chains had not yet reached, giving the company a footprint that far exceeded what a single corporate operator could create. Independent entrepreneurs who wanted to enter the business now had a way to do so with reduced uncertainty.

Franchising also changed the character of rent-to-own. With a recognizable brand and standardized practices, ColorTyme gave the industry a level of polish that smaller independent retailers often struggled to achieve. Advertising was coordinated across regions, training programs improved customer service, and store layouts and product offerings became more uniform. In short, franchising helped advance the professionalization of RTO.

ColorTyme was not the only franchise model to appear, but it was the most influential. It demonstrated that RTO was not limited to those with deep pockets or insider knowledge. With the right structure, anyone with moderate capital and entrepreneurial drive could enter the industry. This broadened the base of operators and accelerated the spread of the model in communities nationwide.

The tradeoff was independence. Franchisees sacrificed some control in exchange for the benefits of brand power and vendor leverage. For many, it was worth it. Competing against Rent-A-Center and Aaron’s as a lone operator was daunting. Under the ColorTyme banner, small operators had the tools and the recognition to make them competitive.

By the late 1980s, franchising had become a major force in rent-to-own. It filled the space between the national chains and the truly independent operators. Together, these three forms — chains, franchises, and independents — created a layered industry structure. Each had different strengths and weaknesses, but all were united by the same fundamental mission: to give households immediate access to the technologies and goods that defined modern life.

Franchising also foreshadowed a broader truth about the industry’s future: rent-to-own was inherently adaptable. It could grow as a large corporate chain, as a regional company built on community ties, or as a franchise system open to smaller entrepreneurs. This adaptability would help sustain the industry through the scrutiny and regulatory battles of the 1990s. But at the time it emerged, franchising’s impact was straightforward. It expanded the reach of RTO faster than any other innovation since the model’s inception.

Independent Operators & the Spread of Local Stores

Chains and franchises shaped the public image of rent-to-own in the 1980s, but the lifeblood of the industry remained with independent operators. These were the furniture dealers who pivoted to rentals after watching customers default on installment plans. They were the appliance-store owners who saw families walking away in frustration after being denied credit. They were entrepreneurs with no connection to the big players, who simply saw a local need and built a business to fill it.

Independent operators were everywhere. By the mid-1980s, mom-and-pop operators dotted towns across the Midwest, South, and Northeast. Some had one store; others had a handful. Many operated in isolation, unaware their peers elsewhere were building almost identical businesses. Yet, collectively, they represented a powerful force: hundreds, eventually thousands, of storefronts that brought the RTO model to the communities that chains and franchises had not yet reached.

Part of the appeal of independence was flexibility. Unlike a franchisee tied to a brand’s rules or a corporate store beholden to distant executives, independent owners could adapt rapidly to local conditions. If a town demanded more stereos and fewer sofas, an independent could shift inventory overnight. If a community responded to a certain type of promotion, the owner could run it without waiting for approval. This agility helped independents thrive in small and mid-sized markets, where personal relationships and community reputation mattered more than national advertising.

Rise of the Regional Titans

As the industry matured, a new breed of independent operator began to emerge: the “Regional Titan.” These were entrepreneurs who refused to stay small. Instead of remaining single-store shops, they created multi-state empires that rivaled the sophistication of the chains while retaining the heart of a family business.

In Ohio, a state that became a surprising hub for RTO innovation, Gary Ferriman built Showplace Rent To Own on a philosophy of “servant leadership.” Ferriman, who started in the trenches literally carrying appliances himself, understood the physical toll of the business. “In the early days, you did it all,” Ferriman recalled. “I remember carrying refrigerators up three flights of stairs by myself because we couldn’t afford a helper … You’d get to the top, sweating, and the customer would look at you and say, ‘Thank you.’ That ‘thank you’ meant everything.”4 Ferriman scaled Showplace by professionalizing this servant heart, turning delivery drivers into regional vice presidents.

Nearby in Youngstown, Ohio, Wayland Russell founded Rainbow Rentals. A former banker and law-enforcement officer, Russell brought a financial rigor that was rare in the early days of RTO. “I came from a banking background,” Russell explained. “I looked at the numbers, and I realized that if you controlled your inventory and you treated the customer with dignity, the math was undeniable.”5 Russell eventually took Rainbow public, proving that an independent operator could achieve Wall Street discipline. Darrell Tissot, another key figure on the Ohio scene as the founder of Rent-2-Own, helped cement the region’s reputation for operational excellence.

In the South, Baber’s Lease to Own Furniture & Appliances became a dynasty across Mississippi and Louisiana, building a “moat” of customer loyalty that national chains struggled to breach. Further south, in Florida, Larry Sutton brought a marketing flair to the industry, proving RTO could go beyond being a necessity and become aspirational.

In the Midwest, Ace Rent-To-Own, led by Lyn Leach and his father Jean, exemplified the family business model. Leach noted that their competitive advantage was intimacy: “It wasn’t just a job. We were in people’s homes. We knew when they got a raise, we knew when they lost a job, we knew when they had a baby.”6

Operationalizing the Hustle

Independent operators also helped prove the universality of the rent-to-own model. Their stores showed up in farming towns, industrial cities, and rural counties. They served customers of different backgrounds and regions, but the pattern was the same: families wanted access to the technologies defining modern life, but traditional credit excluded them. By responding to that demand, independents demonstrated that RTO was not confined to a single geography or demographic. It was a national need, expressed locally.

However, scaling these independent businesses required a painful transition. In the early 1980s, the industry ran on manual “pegboard” systems. Dennis Shields, an industry pioneer and longtime executive director of TRIB Group, described the reality: “We didn’t have computers. Everything was done on a pegboard system …. You knew your customers because you physically handled their card every week.” But as operators like Russell and Ferriman grew to 20 or 50 stores, they could no longer rely on physical cards. The shift to computerized Point-of-Sale (POS) systems in the 1990s was crucial. “The computer allowed us to trust the numbers without being in the room,”7 Shields noted. This technology allowed independent families to build regional empires without losing control.

The 1980s and 90s also brought more structure to independent operators. Buying groups like TRIB let them band together, gaining vendor leverage and sharing best practices. Tradeshows created opportunities for owners who once operated in isolation to meet, compare notes, and see themselves as part of a larger industry. These connections gave independent operators the confidence to invest more in their businesses, improve store design, and expand to additional locations.

Despite their smaller size, independents faced the same criticisms as larger chains. Consumer advocates argued that the effective cost of ownership was too high if customers carried agreements to term. Local media sometimes portrayed rent-to-own as exploitative, focusing on repossessions without acknowledging the flexibility of returns. Independent operators often had an advantage in countering these narratives, because they were well-rooted in their communities. They could point to relationships with customers who returned year after year, families who eventually owned their products, or households that counted on RTO during difficult times. Their reputations were built face-to-face, not through national advertising campaigns, and that credibility carried real weight.

The proliferation of independent operators also had a cultural effect. In many small towns, the local RTO store became as familiar as the grocery store or the post office. Customers often knew the owner personally, and deals were sometimes struck with a handshake rather than a contract. Delivery drivers doubled as repairmen, and service was handled on the spot. This intimacy made the model accessible even to customers who might have been skeptical of a national chain. It also reinforced the idea that RTO was not just about goods; it was about relationships, trust, and inclusion in the rhythms of local life.

By the 1990s, independent operators accounted for a substantial share of the industry’s total store count. Many independents never became household names beyond their own towns, yet collectively, they were invaluable in making rent-to-own a national phenomenon. Without them, the industry’s footprint would have been far smaller, and its claim to represent a broad consumer need far weaker.

The success of independent operators also complicated the competitive landscape. Customers in many communities had choices between a local RTO store, a ColorTyme franchise, and perhaps a nearby Rent-A-Center. This competition drove the entire industry forward. Independents had to improve presentation and service to keep pace with the professionalism of franchises and chains. In turn, franchises and chains had to work harder to win loyalty in places where customers already knew and trusted their local rental dealers. The result was a rising standard across the board.

Independent operators rarely grew into national chains, but some expanded into regional players with multiple locations. These rental dealers often developed reputations as innovators, trying new promotions, experimenting with inventory, or introducing early computer systems to manage accounts. Because they were not constrained by corporate policies, they could take risks that larger companies avoided. In some cases, these experiments grew to influence broader industry practices.

Ultimately, the story of independent operators in the 1980s and 90s is one of scale through proliferation. No single independent changed the course of the industry, but together, they gave rent-to-own a national footprint. They filled the gaps between corporate stores and franchises, ensuring families in small towns and rural counties had the same access to modern technology as those in big cities. Their presence proved the model worked everywhere — not just in urban centers or under national brands.

By the end of the 1990s, the independent operator was firmly established as one of the three pillars of rent-to-own, alongside chains and franchises. The industry’s blend of corporate giants, franchise systems, and locally owned independents gave it both reach and resilience. Each brought something different to the table, but all shared the same purpose: to deliver access to households excluded from traditional credit in ways that fit the cultural and economic fabric of their communities.

Consumer Technology as Growth Engine

Rent-to-own has always grown in-step with the march of consumer technology, even if the industry was sometimes a step or two behind, working to catch up. Each new product entering American households created fresh demand, and every wave of innovation carried RTO further into the mainstream. The 1980s and 90s were especially powerful decades in this regard.

The VCR was the first spark. In 1980, fewer than 2% of households owned one. By 1990, more than 75% did. Few products in history spread as quickly. VCRs transformed how families consumed entertainment. No longer were they bound to broadcast schedules or movie theaters; they could watch films at home, record television shows, and control when and how they experienced media. For families without cash or credit, the only way to participate in this revolution was through RTO. A weekly payment secured the same VCR their neighbors had, and it meant inclusion in the conversations, routines, and cultural moments of the decade.

Stereo systems followed a similar trajectory. By the mid-1980s, component stereos with multiple speakers, cassette decks, and eventually CD players became status symbols in many homes. The ability to host friends, fill a living room with sound, or record mixtapes carried real social currency. For teenagers and young adults, owning a stereo was part of belonging to a generation. RTO stores stocked these systems and offered the same equipment featured in national advertisements — but without the hurdles of credit applications.

Camcorders were another defining product. Families wanted to record birthdays, school plays, graduations, and weddings on video. A camcorder allowed them to create a visual archive of family life that could be replayed and shared. But camcorders were expensive. In the mid-1980s, a typical unit could cost well over $1,000. RTO stores became the place where ordinary families could access this technology at a cost aligned with weekly or monthly paychecks. For many, their first family videos were recorded on a camcorder obtained through a rental agreement.

Personal computers may have been the most transformative product of all. IBM released their first PC in 1981, followed by Apple’s Macintosh in 1984, making household computing a reality. By the 1990s, schools were assigning homework that required typed reports, and businesses expected employees to be computer-literate. A family without a computer risked leaving children unprepared and falling behind themselves. Once again, cost was the barrier and RTO provided a solution. Leasing computers gave families immediate access, and many eventually exercised purchase options, making PCs a permanent part of their homes. The key role of RTO in spreading digital literacy cannot be overstated.

Televisions grew in both size and capability during this period as well. The late 1980s and 90s saw the arrival of big-screen models, which redefined the living room. Hosting a Super Bowl party or watching a movie at home on a screen larger than 30 inches was a new cultural experience. These televisions were expensive, heavy, and risky to buy on credit. RTO stores delivered them, set them up, and bundled service into the agreement. For working families, this was the only way to keep pace with a fast-changing entertainment landscape.

Video gaming systems added another layer. Nintendo, Sega, and later Sony’s PlayStation became household names. For children and teenagers, having a gaming system was more than fun; it was a marker of participation in peer culture. By the 1990s, video games had become as central to youth culture as television had been for earlier generations. RTO stores recognized the demand and stocked gaming consoles alongside televisions and stereos, ensuring families excluded from credit could still give their children access to the same experiences as their peers.

These technology waves explain much of rent-to-own’s growth in the 1980s and 90s. The industry did not have to generate desire; the demand was already there, driven by advertising, peer influence, and cultural momentum. RTO simply provided the bridge between that desire and the financial realities of households left behind by traditional credit systems.

The growth curves of these products match almost exactly the expansion of RTO stores. As VCR adoption surged in the 1980s, RTO locations multiplied across the country. As computers became household necessities in the 1990s, store counts increased further. The alignment was not coincidental. Each wave of technology created new urgency, and RTO was there to meet it.

The logic extended beyond entertainment and education. Appliances continued to be a steady driver of demand. Refrigerators, washers, dryers, and stoves are not optional; they are essential. Families could not wait for months on layaway when a refrigerator failed, and they also couldn’t afford to take on high-interest credit-card debt for a replacement. Rent-to-own remained the solution, ensuring the basic functions of daily life could continue without disruption.

Technology waves also helped change the image of the industry. In the 1970s, critics often dismissed RTO as a service for televisions and sofas. By the 1990s, it was clear the industry played a role in providing computers, gaming systems, appliances, and other products central to modern life. This made it harder to argue that RTO served only frivolous desires. Increasingly, the model was tied to products that shaped education, work, and social inclusion.

Social comparison amplified demand. Families measured themselves against neighbors, coworkers, and relatives. A household without a VCR, large-screen television, or computer lacked more than a product — it risked being excluded from the shared experiences that defined everyday life. Rent-to-own stores understood this pressure and marketed directly to it. Slogans about “keeping up” and “owning today” resonated because they reflected real social dynamics. The idea of “keeping up with the Joneses” had shaped American consumer behavior for decades. RTO didn’t create that reality; it simply responded to it.

The broader pattern was unmistakable. When innovation improves life, those with money adopt first, while rent-to-own ensures those without money are not excluded indefinitely. The 1980s and 90s made this dynamic visible at scale. RTO store counts surged in lockstep with the adoption of VCRs, computers, gaming systems, and large-screen televisions. By bridging the gap between aspiration and affordability, RTO once again revealed its defining truth: access, not ownership, was the real product being sold.

Store Count & Buying Power

The 1980s and 90s were the decades when rent-to-own became a national retail presence. Store counts multiplied, and with them came new forms of buying power that reshaped the industry’s relationship with vendors and firmly established RTO in the broader retail landscape.

The numbers alone illustrate the transformation. In 1963, Mr. T’s was a single store in Wichita. By the early 1970s, it had grown into a small regional chain. Rent-A-Center opened in 1973, and Aaron’s had nearly 20 showrooms by the mid-1970s. Even so, the total industry footprint remained small. When APRO was founded in 1980, about 40 rental dealers joined as charter members, representing an estimated 200 to 350 stores nationwide. In less than two decades, that figure would grow into the thousands.

Rent-A-Center’s expansion under Thorn EMI drove much of this growth. By the early 1990s, the company operated hundreds of locations; by the end of the decade, it had become the clear industry leader, with thousands of stores across the United States. Aaron’s followed its own disciplined growth path, spreading across the South and eventually into new regions. ColorTyme scaled rapidly through franchising, creating hundreds of branded stores owned by independent operators. Independent entrepreneurs continued to proliferate in small and mid-sized towns, filling geographic gaps and broadening the industry’s reach. Together, these forces produced an astonishing expansion of RTO’s footprint.

This explosion in store counts was not simply the result of ambitious operators. It was a response to the monumental consumer technology waves of the era. VCRs in the 1980s, personal computers in the 1990s, and ever-larger televisions and gaming systems across both decades created repeated cycles of urgent demand. Each wave pushed more households toward RTO as their only practical way to participate. The stronger the wave of innovation, the more stores emerged to meet it.

Scale brought bargaining power. In rent-to-own’s early years, dealers often struggled to secure favorable terms from manufacturers who viewed them as marginal buyers compared with department stores, discount chains, or emerging big-box retailers. But as RTO store counts reached into the thousands, vendors could no longer dismiss the sector. They saw that rent-to-own offered a stable sales channel and access to consumers they were failing to reach through traditional retail. With that recognition came better pricing, stronger relationships, and a new level of legitimacy for RTO.

This shift was formalized through the creation of buying groups. TRIB Group, founded in the early 1980s, gave independent operators and smaller chains the ability to pool their purchasing power.8 Larry Carrico recalled the necessity of this alliance: “We were getting killed on price. The manufacturers didn’t want to talk to you if you were buying 10 TVs. They wanted to talk to the guy buying 10 thousand.”9 By negotiating collectively, TRIB members secured better prices, exclusive deals, and access to brand-name products that had once been beyond reach. Nationwide Marketing Group offered similar benefits, helping rental dealers compete with the bigger players on price and product availability.

Buying groups did more than cut costs. They created a sense of shared identity among independent operators, many of whom had previously felt isolated. Annual meetings and tradeshows brought hundreds of rental dealers together, fostering collaboration and spreading best practices. A store owner in Ohio could learn from a colleague in Texas or Georgia, and everyone could return home with new ideas for promotions, inventory management, and customer service. This exchange helped lift the professionalism of the entire industry.

Manufacturers responded in kind. Whirlpool, RCA, Sony, and other major brands developed programs tailored especially to rent-to-own dealers. Products needed to be durable enough to withstand frequent deliveries and occasional returns. Warranties had to align with lease structures. Packaging sometimes had to be adjusted for easier transport. By adapting to these realities, vendors deepened their ties to the industry and ensured brand-name goods remained central to RTO showrooms.

As store counts grew, advertising also changed. National chains like Rent-A-Center launched television and radio campaigns that reached millions of households. ColorTyme coordinated marketing across franchise locations, giving small operators the benefits of big-brand advertising. Independent operators, often through their buying groups, gained access to shared advertising materials and vendor-supported promotions. The combined effect was to give RTO a level of visibility it hadn’t previously achieved. By the 1990s, most Americans recognized the slogans “No Credit Needed,” or “Everyone’s Approved,” even if they had never entered an RTO store.

The explosion of locations also forced the industry to reckon with competition. In many communities, customers could choose between a Rent-A-Center, an Aaron’s, a ColorTyme franchise, and an independent store. Competition drove operators to improve service, upgrade store presentation, and expand product offerings. Delivery and repair services became faster. Promotions became sharper. The customer, once grateful to simply be included, now had options, and operators had to work to win their loyalty.

The competition could be stiff. Margins were thin, and store density sometimes led to overlap that strained profitability. Yet the overall effect was positive for the industry. It forced operators to hone their practices, and reinforced the idea that RTO was not a fringe option; it was a mainstream retail channel competing for customers like any other.

By the end of the 1990s, rent-to-own had reached a peak in store counts. Exact figures vary, but estimates place the total number of stores nationwide well into the thousands. Rent-A-Center, Aaron’s, and ColorTyme accounted for a large share of the total stores, with independents accounting for the rest. Buying groups had solidified, vendor programs were robust, and the industry commanded attention from regulators, the media, and the public.

The story of this era is about numbers, but it is also about legitimacy. An industry that had once been dismissed as a cousin to the pawn shop had grown into a national marketplace with thousands of storefronts, brand-name products, and standardized practices. Store count mattered not simply because it reflected growth, but because it showed that rent-to-own had become an integral part of American consumer life.

Consumer Experience of the 1980s–90s

Despite all the rapid changes in the rent-to-own landscape of the 1980s and 90s, the fundamental belief that the customer experience was at the heart of the industry’s success never faltered. RTO stood out from its competitors because in addition to the products offered, it placed importance on how those products made customers feel. For families excluded from credit, the ability to walk into an RTO store in the 1980s or 90s meant more than picking out a product. It meant entering a space where they were welcomed, approved, and included without the fear of rejection. In a very real sense, rent-to-own stores provided families with the reassurance that they would be able to fully participate in mainstream culture and society no matter how rapidly it changed.

A typical customer journey began with a storefront that looked increasingly like any other retailer. Gone were the pawn-shop aesthetics of the early years. Rent-A-Center, Aaron’s, and ColorTyme all invested in bright showrooms with neatly staged living room sets, gleaming appliances, and rows of televisions or stereos. As competition intensified, independents were also forced to upgrade their stores. For many customers, this presentation mattered. It signaled that the goods were new, modern, and no different from what was sold in department stores or big-box chains. Customers didn’t feel like they had to settle for less.

The process of securing a product was simple. Unlike credit applications that required paperwork, references, and often ended in rejection, rental agreements were fast and flexible. Customers needed little more than identification, a source of income, and a willingness to make the first payment. Approval was immediate. For families used to hearing “no” from banks and credit card companies, this experience was transformative.

Delivery was another hallmark of the RTO experience. While traditional retailers often left customers to figure out transportation or charged extra for service, rent-to-own stores bundled delivery and setup into the agreement. A family could choose a sofa set or a large television on Saturday, and have it delivered and setup in their living room the same day. For households without trucks or extra cash for movers, this convenience was invaluable.

Service and repairs reinforced the value. If a refrigerator stopped working or a television failed, RTO customers did not face the stress of finding a repair shop or paying out-of-pocket. Rental dealers sent technicians to fix or replace the item as part of the agreement. This built trust. Customers knew their payments covered more than the product; they covered the security of knowing any problems would be solved quickly and without further expense.

The emotional dimension of the RTO experience cannot be overlooked. For many families, the ability to bring home a VCR, a computer, or a big-screen television the same day was about more than convenience — it was about dignity. It meant their children could do schoolwork on the same technology as their classmates. It meant they could host friends for a movie night or watch the big game on a large television like their neighbors. It meant they could record family milestones with a camcorder and replay special moments for years to come. In a society where technology increasingly defined belonging, RTO made inclusion possible for everyone. It helped close the gap between families who could afford to fully participate in modern life and those who had been shut out of it.

There was also a generational layer. Parents who had grown up with the humiliation of denied credit or repossessed goods now found themselves able to provide for their families without fear of lingering debt. RTO’s terminable lease structure allowed them to walk away without shame if their circumstances changed. This flexibility gave customers control that installment credit never offered. For many, it was the first time they felt respected as consumers.

The consumer experience varied depending on the operator. Rent-A-Center emphasized consistency with the use of standardized store layouts and national advertising that created a recognizable brand. Aaron’s leaned into personal service and community ties by building long-term trust with families who saw the company as part of their neighborhood fabric. ColorTyme franchisees provided a hybrid experience, benefiting from a national brand while often tailoring promotions and service to suit local needs. Independents relied heavily on personal relationships, often knowing their customers by name and making decisions based on local reputation.

Despite these differences, the core promise was the same: immediate access without credit. Customers could see it in the slogans — “No Credit Needed,” “Everyone’s Approved,” “Own It Today.” These messages resonated because they reflected reality. In an economy where credit cards were spreading but exclusion persisted, rent-to-own was the one place where families could walk in with dignity and walk out with the products that mattered most to them.

The criticisms customers faced from outsiders only reinforced the importance of the experience. Media reports often highlighted the total cost of ownership, pointing out that customers might pay two or three times the retail price if they kept items through the full agreement. For critics, this made RTO a predatory business, but customers told a different story. Surveys and interviews consistently found that RTO customers valued the flexibility, the service, and the ability to return items without debt. Their alternative was not buying cheaper at Sears or Circuit City; it was going without.

By the late 1990s, millions of households had interacted with a rent-to-own store at some point, whether as short-term renters or as customers who eventually purchased goods through the lease-to-own pathway. The industry had built not only a business model, but also a customer culture rooted in immediacy, flexibility, and dignity. This customer culture explains why, despite criticism, the model endured and grew. Families continued to choose RTO because it was often the only option that respected their realities.

Cultural Debate & Media Scrutiny

As rent-to-own expanded in the 1980s and 90s, it attracted attention not only from customers and vendors, but also from journalists, regulators, and consumer advocates. Visibility brought legitimacy, but it also invited criticism. The debates that emerged in this era echoed controversies over installment credit in the early twentieth century. Was RTO a tool of inclusion, or was it exploitation disguised as convenience?

Consumer media outlets often focused on the cost of ownership. Investigative reports calculated the total payments required to own a product if a customer carried an agreement to full term. In many cases, the numbers were striking. A $400 television might cost $1,000 or more by the end of a lease. Headlines framed this gap as evidence that RTO preyed on vulnerable households. The framing resonated with a public already sensitive to stories about predatory lending, payday loans, and rising consumer debt.

But the criticism missed an important distinction. Rent-to-own was not credit. There was no lingering debt, no compounding interest, and no deficiency balance after repossession. Customers were paying for access, flexibility, and bundled service. They chose a model that allowed them to stop paying and return the item if their circumstances changed, without shame and without collection agencies pursuing them. For families with volatile incomes, that flexibility mattered more than the sticker price. For families who moved frequently, whether military households, corporate transferees, or workers relocating to stay employed, RTO made life simpler. They could leave everything behind at the old address, start fresh at the new one, and continue with an agreement that fit their situation.

Industry advocates pushed back against negative portrayals by pointing to what customers themselves reported. Federal Trade Commission research in the late 1990s confirmed what many rental dealers already knew: most merchandise was ultimately purchased rather than perpetually rented.10 The FTC found that roughly 70% of rented goods moved to ownership, and customer satisfaction rates were consistently high. Consumers valued immediate access, clear terms, and the ability to return items without debt or penalty. For many households, rent-to-own was not a trap but a lifeline — a practical way to participate in modern life when traditional credit was out of reach.

The media debate often revealed more about cultural attitudes than about the industry itself. Critics tended to measure RTO against the ideal of cash purchases or low-interest credit cards — options that were simply unavailable to many households. Customers, on the other hand, measured RTO against omission. For them, the choice was not between Sears and Rent-A-Center, but between access and exclusion.

Regulators also took notice. State attorneys general began to examine rent-to-own practices, particularly around disclosures. The question was not whether the model should exist, but whether customers were fully informed of the costs. This pressure would lead to a wave of state-level rental-purchase statutes being enacted in the late 1980s and 90s. These statutes codified RTO as a lease rather than a loan, and required clear disclosure of cash price, total of payments, and early-purchase options.11

The stakes were extremely high. Regulators wanted to classify rent-to-own transactions as “credit sales,” which would subject them to usury laws and effectively make the business illegal overnight. Bill Keese described the danger: “We were one court case away from extinction. Every morning we woke up wondering if a judge in Texas or Pennsylvania was going to sign a piece of paper that put us all out of business.”12

This threat forced the Regional Titans — competitors in business — to become allies in defense. APRO General Counsel for 45 years Ed Winn described the mobilization: “It was a war. We had operators who were competitors — guys who fought each other for every customer on Saturday — sitting in the same room on Monday, writing checks to the legal defense fund. We realized that if we didn’t hang together, we’d hang separately.”13

The scrutiny, though uncomfortable, helped mature the industry. Rental dealers learned transparency mattered, not just for compliance, but for reputation. Clearer contracts and better customer communication became part of the competitive landscape. APRO played a key role during this period by helping operators understand evolving rules and presenting a united front to policymakers.

Cultural criticism extended beyond pricing. Some commentators argued that RTO encouraged conspicuous consumption, pointing to households renting big-screen televisions or gaming systems rather than focusing on necessities. The critique was familiar. In the 1920s, installment buyers had been accused of the same thing when they purchased pianos or radios on time payments. What critics often failed to see was the social and cultural value of these goods. A piano in 1925, a television in 1955, or a computer in 1995 were not frivolous luxuries; they were markers of inclusion in modern life. RTO enabled that inclusion for families who were otherwise shut out.

The persistence of criticism created a paradox for the industry. On the one hand, negative press reinforced stereotypes that rent-to-own was predatory. On the other hand, the debate itself underscored the importance of the industry. Few other retail models generated such consistent attention. The very fact that journalists, regulators, and advocates focused on RTO meant it had become too large and too influential to ignore.

By the end of the 1990s, the central arguments of the debate were clear. Critics were focused on cost, often reducing the model to a calculation of sticker prices versus total payments, while customers were focused on dignity, flexibility, and the ability to participate in cultural life without the risk of debt. Regulators sought clarity, pushing the industry toward clearer disclosures and greater transparency. Rent-to-own leaders understood the scrutiny was not temporary.

But the cultural debate did not weaken the RTO industry. If anything, it forced rent-to-own to hone its message and embrace its role more directly. The industry could no longer afford to be a quiet alternative on the sidelines; it had to present itself as a legitimate, consumer-focused model with social value. This recognition set the stage for the next chapter of the story, when legislative warfare would define RTO’s legal identity and advocacy would become as important as entrepreneurship.

Expansion as Proof of Concept

By the close of the 1990s, rent-to-own had proven itself beyond doubt. What had begun in Wichita as a creative experiment had matured into a national industry with thousands of stores, recognizable brands, buying groups, and vendor programs. The success of RTO was visible in storefronts across cities, suburbs, and small towns nationwide.

The expansion of this period revealed several truths. First, RTO could scale in multiple ways. Rent-A-Center demonstrated the power of corporate chains and capital-driven growth; Aaron’s proved steady reinvestment and community trust could build a formidable company; and ColorTyme showed that franchising could open the door for small entrepreneurs to rapidly expand the industry’s reach. Meanwhile, independents filled in the map, ensuring even rural counties and small towns had access to the goods and technologies defining modern life.

Second, the industry’s growth confirmed its close connection to waves of technology. Every major adoption curve - VCRs, stereos, camcorders, computers, big-screen televisions, and gaming systems - coincided with growth in RTO store counts. Whenever an innovation improved daily life, those with money bought first, while RTO ensured others were not excluded indefinitely. This role as a bridge between innovation and inclusion became the industry’s defining identity.

Third, expansion clarified rent-to-own’s relationship to criticism. Media outlets and consumer advocates continued to emphasize the high cost of ownership while customers consistently chose RTO because it was accessible, flexible, and treated them with dignity. Regulators responded by pushing for clearer disclosures, a process that eventually led to rental-purchase statutes across almost every state. Over time, this scrutiny strengthened the industry by facilitating greater transparency and laying groundwork for the legislative clarity that would shape the 1990s and early 2000s.

By any measure, the 1980s and 90s were the decades when rent-to-own stopped asking whether it could exist and began proving how it could thrive. The experiment was over. The proof of concept had been delivered on a national scale.

The next challenge, however, would be different. Expansion proved that rent-to-own could succeed commercially. The question ahead was whether it could succeed politically. The scrutiny of the 1980s had already hinted at the battles to come. Critics were sharpening their arguments, regulators were drafting statutes, and RTO was preparing to defend itself in legislatures and courts.

Expansion & Industry Identity

Looking back, it is easy to view rent-to-own in the 1980s and 90s through only the lens of growth. Store counts multiplied, chains scaled nationally, and RTO became a household name. However, growth is not the whole story. The deeper truth is that this period refined the industry’s identity.

RTO was not a temporary fix or a fringe alternative. It was a structural response to a recurring problem: innovation arrives faster than traditional finance can adapt. Families want inclusion in the technologies shaping current culture, but millions are excluded by high cash barriers and rigid credit systems. RTO was created to close the gap.

The era of expansion was not just proof the rent-to-own model worked; it was proof the model belonged. This recognition set the stage for the next chapter of the story: how the industry defended its identity in the face of regulatory scrutiny and secured its place in law.

Endnotes

  1. “History of Rent-A-Center, Inc.” FundingUniverse, accessed 2025. ↩
  2. “History of Aaron Rents, Inc.” FundingUniverse, accessed 2025. ↩
  3. “ColorTyme Rent-to-Own Franchise Business Opportunity.” BeTheBoss.com, accessed 2025. ↩
  4. Ferriman, Gary. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  5. Russell, Wayland. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  6. Leach, Lyn. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  7. Shields, Dennis. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  8. TRIB Group. Formation records, 1980s. ↩
  9. Carrico, Larry. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  10. Federal Trade Commission. Survey of Rent-to-Own Customers, 2000. ↩
  11. APRO Archives. State rental-purchase statutes, legislative history, 1980s–1990s. ↩
  12. Keese, Bill. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  13. Winn, Ed. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
↑ Top

Upcoming Events



Mike Lewis

Mike Lewis is a Premier Rental Purchase franchisee with multiple stores and currently serves as Vice President of Operations. With 33 years of experience in the rent-to-own industry, he has spent the past 20 years working closely with franchisee owners and previously spent 12 years in Corporate RTO, gaining a strong foundation in the business.

For the past five years, Mike has been sharing his knowledge by teaching managers and franchisees at the company’s Training Center.

Outside of work, he enjoys time with his family, kids, and grandkids, and appreciates the simple things in life – especially riding his Harley Davidson with the sun on his face. If you know, you know!

Lauren Talicska

Arona Corporation dba Arona Home Essentials

Lauren Talicska is an experienced multi-channel marketing specialist and the Vice President of Marketing & Communications at Arona Home Essentials. She has found her home in the RTO community, supporting stores in branding, growth, and increasing traffic.

You may recognize Lauren as a former RTO vendor, including her time as a partner for Nationwide RentDirect, or her previous participation in the APRO Vendor Advisory Committee. Lauren calls Columbus, Ohio, home and spends her workday crafting and executing marketing promotions from inception to realization, all while supporting the branding and social media needs of all the Arona stores in 12 states (plus Puerto Rico!).

Charles Smitherman

APRO

Charles Smitherman, JD, PhD, CAE, became CEO of APRO in 2023, bringing years of legal and executive experience in the rent-to-own industry. 

Prior to joining the association, Charles served as COO, General Counsel, and Vice President of PTS Financial Services, where he played an active role in the rent-to-own industry by representing his company through PTS’s club program offering with APRO member dealers. Charles is an attorney with two decades of experience across a wide variety of areas, including RTO, consumer financial services, antitrust, corporate law, mergers and acquisitions, litigation, franchise law, and privacy law. Following law school at the University of Georgia, Charles earned a Master of Legal Studies and PhD in Law from the University of Oxford in England.

Charles is credentialed as a Certified Association Executive (CAE) with the American Society of Association Executives, a Certified Franchise Executive (CFE) with the International Franchise Association, and a Certified Information Privacy Professional (CIPP/US) and Certified Information Privacy Manager (CIPM) through the International Association of Privacy Professionals. As APRO’s sixth CEO in its 45-year history, he brings a collaborative, member-focused approach to association leadership, emphasizing transparency, advocacy, and value creation. Outside of work, Charles is an active ultra runner and open water swimmer.

Mike Kays

Ashley Furniture Industries

As VP of Rental Sales for Ashley Furniture Industries, Mike thrives on building relationships with our RTO industry veterans, and helping businesses grow through new product, new marketing, and new supply chain options.

Mike works to leverage a wide breadth of relationships and influence, intimate knowledge of market trends, and unique knowledge of what RTO dealers need from a supplier to be successful.

The saying goes that a high tide raises all boats, and our goal is to leverage the world’s largest furniture manufacturer to drive the continued growth of the RTO industry and all the suppliers.

Mike Tissot

Countryside Rentals Inc., dba Rent-2-Own

Mike grew up in the rent-to-own industry under the guidance of his father, former APRO President and RTO legend Darrell Tissot. For nearly 25 years, Mike’s innovative leadership has helped expand the family business to more than 40 stores across Ohio and Kentucky while also shaping the industry as a whole.

He has served as President of the Ohio Rental Dealers Association, an APRO board member and Treasurer, and President and Treasurer of the TRIB Group. His contributions have earned him the APRO President’s Award of Excellence and the title of APRO Rental Dealer of the Year.

Outside of RTO, Mike enjoys time at the lake house or in Orange Beach, Alabama, with his girlfriend, Angela Strong McCool. A passionate Cincinnati Reds fan, he rarely misses a game, whether watching or listening alongside his parents. He also takes every opportunity to visit Arizona, where his daughter is currently attending Arizona State University.