The Rent-to-Own Revolution · Chapter 3
In this chapter
By the late 1970s, the rent-to-own (RTO) industry faced a crossroads. A new generation of entrepreneurs had transformed a simple idea — furnishing homes for families who could not access or did not want traditional credit — into a nationwide network of independent stores. The business model had proven resilient and profitable, yet that success invited scrutiny. Legislators and journalists, uncertain what to make of this rapidly spreading form of retail leasing, began asking whether RTO was merely installment credit in disguise. Competitors in traditional finance, threatened by its growth, amplified those doubts.
Additionally, the broader economy magnified that tension. Inflation, stagnant wages, and tightening credit standards locked millions of working families out of conventional financing. Credit cards were becoming a middle-class privilege rather than a universal tool. Within that vacuum, rent-to-own flourished by offering something uniquely practical — immediate access without continuing debt. For many customers, RTO was about not only acquiring furniture or appliances, but also safeguarding household stability and dignity amid economic uncertainty. Flexibility, not novelty, made the model revolutionary.
What distinguished many of the early dealers was not a novel pricing strategy, but a moral intuition about need. As Mike Tissot later reflected on the dealership started by his father, Darrell Tissot in Hillsboro, Ohio, the business never felt abstract or opportunistic to him. It was rooted in the daily realities of families who needed things to function — a bed that gave someone a good night’s sleep, a refrigerator that kept food fresh and safe, a washer that made ordinary life possible. “We weren’t trying to outsmart anyone,” Tissot recalled. “We were trying to solve problems people had that day, not next quarter.” That orientation — practical, immediate, and grounded in dignity — shaped the culture of early rent-to-own far more than spreadsheets ever did.¹
The industry was still a patchwork of mom-and-pop stores, regional chains, and fledgling franchises bound less by organization than by instinct. Each rental dealer solved the same problem within their community — how to provide affordable access to essential, durable goods — but none represented the field as a whole. “We were all out there inventing the same wheel at the same time,” Ed Winn, later recalled. “But nobody knew who was rolling beside them.”2
That fragmentation proved dangerous. Without a central voice to define the transaction, outsiders began defining it for themselves. Consumer advocates portrayed rent-to-own as “credit by another name.” Journalists and consumers echoed the “loan-sharking” critique.3 State officials, receiving conflicting explanations from local dealers, questioned whether RTO violated lending laws. By 1979, with more than 3,000 rent-to-own stores operating nationwide, invisibility was no longer protection — it was peril.
For dealers like Darrell Tissot, the push toward organization was less about fear of regulation than about responsibility. As RTO stores multiplied and the model spread, he sensed that silence carried its own risk. “If we didn’t explain what we were doing, someone else would,” Mike Tissot recalled about his father, noting that outsiders rarely saw the full picture of service, returns, and flexibility that defined the transaction. That awareness —that legitimacy required articulation — helped drive support for collective representation. The Association of Progressive Rental Organizations (APRO) was not merely a defensive structure; it was a way for operators to say, together, this is who we are and why we exist.4
For many operators, survival meant more than defending a margin; it meant defending a concept. “If we didn’t get organized,” Bill Keese reflected, “someone else was going to tell our story for us — and not kindly.”5 So organization became an act of self-definition. Just as the first rental dealers had met household needs one lease at a time, they now faced an existential challenge requiring collective creativity.
The founding of the Association of Progressive Rental Organizations (APRO) in 1980 crystallized the shift from individual enterprises to shared identity. What began as an emergency meeting among rent-to-own competitors became the cornerstone of a national movement for recognition, reform, and respect. APRO’s creation signaled the industry was ready to move from defense to articulation — from explaining what it was not to declaring what it was: not credit, but choice; not exploitation, but access; not loophole, but innovation.
The initial impulse to organize for industry survival eventually evolved into something deeper — the pursuit of professionalism. The entrepreneurs who once fought to define the transaction would, through APRO, craft a framework of ethics, advocacy, and education that elevated RTO from a controversial idea to a recognized profession. Over time, the spirit captured by the word progressive would find fuller expression with the word professional — the natural maturing of an industry that learned to match innovation and integrity.
In industries born from entrepreneurial fragmentation, unity usually arrives under threat. For rent-to-own, that moment came when policymakers and competitors began shaping the public narrative before rental dealers could. APRO’s founders understood that legitimacy is never given — it is organized, articulated, and defended. This insight remains in the industry’s cornerstone belief: our existence depends on our ability to speak for ourselves with a single, unified voice.
When Threats Force Unity
As the 1970s dissolved into a new decade, rent-to-own found itself in an uncharted legal landscape. What had begun as an entrepreneurial experiment — leasing household goods with a simple promise of ownership after a series of payments — had outpaced the statutes written for traditional retail or credit. State legislatures, prodded by consumer advocates and finance competitors, began asking a disquieting question: Was rent-to-own really just ‘credit in disguise’?
The question struck at the heart of the industry’s existence. If RTO were treated as credit, it would fall under interest-rate disclosures and other consumer-protection provisions of the Truth in Lending Act (TILA). The model — built on flexible weekly or monthly payments, with no obligation to continue — could easily collapse beneath regulations not designed for it. “That was the moment we realized we weren’t just selling furniture anymore,” Winn remembered. “We were defending a definition.”6
Across the country, a series of state and local challenges made that threat very real. State attorneys general issued legal opinions suggesting rental-purchase agreements were functionally equivalent to installment sales. In Michigan, Attorney General Opinion No. 5503 (1979) claimed that “rental-purchase transactions having an option to acquire ownership constitute credit sales under the Retail Installment Sales Act,” effectively rendering the entire rent-to-own model unlawful without credit disclosures.
Similar uncertainty rippled through Illinois, where early consumer lawsuits argued that rental agreements violated usury limits by charging more than the lawful interest rate, disguised as rent. The National Consumer Law Center later echoed these arguments in widely circulated reports that urged states to apply APR-style disclosures to RTO.7
Meanwhile, the press seized upon the most sensational narratives. Headlines such as “Loan-Sharking in Disguise” and “Poor Families Pay Double” painted the rent-to-own industry in lurid strokes.8 Television programs filmed hidden-camera “investigations,” lumping RTO together with pawnshops and payday lenders — sectors that rental dealers themselves viewed warily. With no authoritative voice to rebut those claims, perception hardened into reputation.
Inside the industry, alarm spread. Independent owners tried writing letters to editors, testifying at hearings, and visiting local legislators, but their efforts were scattered and inconsistent. “We’d go to the Capitol and find three rental dealers from the same city arguing three different definitions,” Winn later said. “One said we were like a lease, another said we were like layaway, another said we weren’t either. Lawmakers just shook their heads.”9 The lack of coherence made it easy for critics to portray rent-to-own as confused or even evasive about its own nature.
The consequences were potentially existential. If just a few states classified RTO as credit, the precedent might ripple nationwide. Entrepreneurs who had built stores on modest margins faced the prospect of rewriting contracts, recalculating interest equivalents, or closing altogether. “We didn’t have Wall Street lawyers,” Keese recalled. “We had store owners who stocked couches by day and read legal codes by night.”10
Amid this chaos, a handful of operators began corresponding privately. Many were competitors who had never met, but now recognized a shared threat. They traded phone calls, handwritten notes, and back-of-napkin sketches of possible solutions. The conclusion was clear: no single rental dealer or franchise could withstand the coming regulatory storm on his own.
By 1980, these informal conversations coalesced around one answer — create a national association to define the rent-to-own transaction, and quickly, before outsiders did. As one participant summarized, “We were being legislated about, not legislated with.”11
This realization laid the groundwork for what would become the Association of Progressive Rental Organizations. APRO would coordinate lobbying and, for the first time, articulate a coherent statement of what rent-to-own both was and was not. The drive toward unity was as philosophical as it was practical: if the industry could not agree on its own identity, then it could not hope for lawmakers or the public to understand it, either.
The urgency of this moment shaped APRO’s future culture. What began as defensive mobilization evolved into a discipline of professional communication — training rental dealers to testify clearly, to use a single vocabulary, and to uphold uniform ethical standards. The early fear of regulation matured into the practice of representation, the first expression of what would become APRO’s defining trait: a professional voice born from crisis.
The Critical Credit vs. Lease Distinction
To the founders of APRO, the phrase not credit was more than semantics; it was survival.
If RTO were credit, it would be bound by TILA disclosures, usury caps, and repossession laws based on debt. If RTO was a lease, the customer retained the option — not the obligation — to purchase, and could return goods at any time without penalty.
So, the distinction meant voluntary continuation rather than indebtedness. This difference defined the model’s flexibility and protected the consumer’s autonomy — qualities obviously overlooked by critics of RTO.
The Birth of APRO (1980)
The decision to create a national association for rent-to-own businesses arose not from a strategic business plan, but from a sense of impending crisis. By mid-1980, the debate over the legal identity of RTO had reached a boiling point. Industry pioneers — many fierce competitors — understood that unless they could present a united front, policymakers and activists would decide their fate for them. As Winn later reflected, “We weren’t looking to start an association; we were trying to stop a funeral.”12
The meeting that birthed the Association of Progressive Rental Organizations occurred in July 1980 in an airport hotel at Love Field in Dallas, Texas. It was a modest gathering: roughly 30-40 rental dealers and several key vendors crowded into a small conference room with handwritten agendas and borrowed chairs. Winn remembered the moment with his characteristic humor: “There were mostly men, all nervous and curious about what this thing called rent-to-own was becoming. Someone joked, ‘Gee, maybe we need a lawyer,’ and I raised my hand.”13 That offhand exchange marked the beginning of Winn’s 45-year stewardship of the industry’s legal and ethical framework.
Bud Holladay, who became APRO’s first president, opened the meeting with characteristic bluntness. “If we don’t define who we are,” he warned, “we’ll wake up to find someone else already has.” That sentence, preserved in the minutes of the meeting, became the rally cry of the fledgling association. Winn — already serving as counsel to several RTO companies — drafted the initial association charter a few days later. His legal background provided structure and credibility, both qualities this new group desperately needed.14
Two representatives from GE Capital, invited to speak on consumer-finance trends, abruptly left the meeting once the discussion turned to forming a trade association — an instinctive antitrust precaution that, as Winn later noted, “showed we were moving from conversation to commitment.”15 Their departure underscored the seriousness of what the rental dealers were undertaking: the creation of an organization that would turn RTO from a business curiosity into a recognized profession.
Several vendors remained engaged throughout APRO’s early sessions — not just observers, but partners in the industry’s survival. Suppliers such as Whirlpool, RCA, and Philco lent credibility to the fledgling group, demonstrating that national brands had a stake in the future of rent-to-own. Their participation at the beginning foreshadowed the strong dealer-vendor partnerships that later helped define APRO’s conventions and advocacy efforts.
The name Association of Progressive Rental Organizations captured a deliberate optimism. Progressive expressed the spirit of the moment — an insistence that this new industry was modern, innovative, and forward-looking, while capturing the essence of the transaction’s optional path to ownership. According to Winn, “The idea of professionalism was much discussed, and the group ultimately settled on the name that still exists today. I no longer remember how professional evolved into progressive; only that it did.”16 His recollection bridges the founders’ intent with APRO’s trajectory today; the pursuit of professionalism has always been embedded in the association’s DNA.
The founding group adopted a concise but ambitious mandate:
- Defend the lease distinction: Affirm that a rental-purchase agreement was a lease, not credit, and thus governed by property law rather than lending statutes;
- Establish ethical and operational standards: Members would agree to uniform practices showing good faith toward customers and regulators alike;
- Coordinate state-level advocacy: Link disparate rental dealers into a coherent political presence across all 50 states and at the federal level; and
- Educate policymakers and the public: Through data, testimony, and storytelling, communicate the economic and social logic of the RTO transaction.17
Each goal responded to the chaos of the previous decade. APRO’s founders knew a trade association could not merely react to criticism; it had to communicate a positive vision of what responsible rent-to-own looked like. The emphasis on ethics was deliberate. “If you don’t show people that you can police yourself,” Winn told the early APRO Board of Directors, “they’ll assume you need someone else to do it for you.”18
This need for self-definition promptly transformed the industry’s culture. APRO’s charter required its members to subscribe to its Code of Ethics — a concise but powerful document outlining fair disclosure, customer respect, and community responsibility. Its first line read, “We believe in the dignity of the consumer.”19 It was a statement as simple as it was radical, asserting that working-class families deserved options and flexibility without stigma.
For Bill Keese, who would later succeed Winn as APRO’s executive director, the organization’s founding moment embodied the industry’s resilience. “We didn’t have deep pockets or political consultants,” Keese recalled. “What we had was urgency, purpose, and a phone list. From that, we built an association that still stands today.”19 “We didn’t spring full-grown from the head of Jupiter,” noted Winn. “We knew we were on the front end of a very good business idea — we just needed to make America safe for rent-to-own.”20
The symbolism of that 1980 meeting reverberates across the decades. APRO was not born from corporate fiat or legislative compromise; it arose from a collective instinct for survival — an understanding that to endure, entrepreneurship must sometimes organize itself into a movement. From its earliest hours, APRO’s role was defined in duality: to serve as both shield and megaphone, both conscience and champion for this newborn industry.
Codes, Standards, & Self-Regulation
From its beginning, APRO treated self-regulation not as a defensive concession, but as proactive strategy. The founders knew that if lawmakers and the public were going to accept rent-to-own as a legitimate lease, the industry had to show its work — clearly defined minimum standards of conduct, published, and with accountability for members. Within the association’s inaugural period, APRO members drafted a Code of Ethics to guide business practices and demonstrate how the industry would police itself.21 The Code of Ethics took the association from ad-hoc promises to a written framework — making it easier for policymakers to distinguish responsible operators from bad actors, and for consumers to know what to expect from rental dealers.
The Code served dual purposes. Internally, it created a common baseline for a fragmented marketplace: clarity on disclosures, merchandise condition, and customer treatment so that one dealer in Dallas and another in Detroit could follow the same rulebook. Externally, it showed that the industry’s central claim — this is a lease, not credit — carried commitments as well as benefits. APRO’s own publications trace the Code’s origin to the founding era and document its later revisions, including a formal refresh by the Board of Directors in 2023 that better aligned it with evolving consumer expectations.22
APRO printed its Code of Ethics on posters for storefronts, featured it in newsletters, and opened early conventions with public recitations of its principles. New association members received a copy in their welcome packets — a practice modeled on larger trade groups, such as the National Retail Federation and the American Financial Services Association. This level of formality indicated something unprecedented for rent-to-own: an expectation of professionalism. By treating its code of conduct with the gravity of time-honored industries, APRO placed itself among peers that were far more established and politically powerful.
APRO’s educational materials illustrated the Code’s substance rather than relying on lofty rhetoric. Articles highlighted concrete expectations — maintaining merchandise in safe working order, presenting clear payment terms, providing responsible marketing, and ensuring accessible service.23 By centering the Code upon everyday experiences of customers, APRO leadership extrapolated a legal argument about what rent-to-own is into operational obligations related to how rent-to-own behaves.
Self-regulation also complemented, rather than replaced, legislation. As states began enacting rental-purchase laws — Michigan’s 1984 measure being the first — APRO could point to a living Code as evidence that the industry already embraced the disclosure logic such statutes required.24 Lawmakers could therefore mirror existing practices rather than reinvent them, improving clarity and accelerating passage. In this way, APRO’s standards provided a blueprint for public policy regarding RTO.
Just as importantly, APRO’s Code of Ethics created a culture of accountability. Membership meant adherence; the association could educate, correct, and, if necessary, apply pressure toward improvement. Over the decades, APRO continued to publish reminders and interpretive guides to keep the Code both front-of-mind for rental dealers, and aligned with consumer expectations as well as regulatory realities. Credibility, the organization’s founders realized, is not a one-time achievement, but a discipline practiced daily in stores, contracts, and customer conversations.
Ideas referenced later in this book — such as a modernized Consumer Bill of Rights, third-party audits, and a digital trust mark — are consistent with this initial act of self-governance. They all prove standards through transparency and verification, with their DNA directly traced to this founding insight — that legitimacy is earned through visible, demonstrable practice. The Code of Ethics was, in essence, the industry’s first formal act of professionalism, the moment when ethics and enterprise became inseparable in rent-to-own.
About the APRO Code of Ethics
- Its purpose: To translate “not credit” from a legal distinction into everyday behaviors customers can see.
- Its practice: To codify disclosure, quality, and responsiveness; educate members; require adherence as a condition of membership.
- Its payoff: To provide policymakers with a working model to recognize and regulate; give consumers a predictable, dignified experience.
Advocacy in Action
From its founding, APRO treated advocacy as a contact sport. The model was simple and persistently personal: send rental dealers to the Capitol, tell customer stories to lawmakers, and explain plainly why the rent-to-own transaction is a lease with an option, not credit with a debt. “The most persuasive witness wasn’t a lobbyist,” Winn later recalled. “It was a store owner who could describe exactly how a return works or how reinstatement keeps a family’s refrigerator running.”25
This grassroots-first approach accomplished two things at once: it demystified the transaction — weekly payments, no obligation to continue, the right to return, repairs and delivery included; and it built credibility before the industry’s legislative ask — define the rental-purchase agreement as a lease with transparent disclosures. APRO’s job was orchestration — preparing members, coordinating testimonies, and providing model language. “Our task,” Keese said, “was to turn a thousand local conversations into a single, consistent message.”26
Training became a hallmark of that coordination. Before hearings, APRO circulated “advocacy briefs” explaining how to tell a compelling customer story, how to describe reinstatement without jargon, and how to stay composed during questioning. Rental dealers practiced mock testimony at regional meetings, learning to introduce themselves as community business owners rather than company spokespeople. Professionalism in demeanor — neat appearance, direct language, respectful opposition — helped reshape perception. “Once lawmakers saw who we really were,” Winn recalled, “the tone of the room changed.” 27
The strategy began paying off quickly. In 1984, Michigan enacted the nation’s first comprehensive rental-purchase statute, defining the transaction as a lease with an option and requiring clear disclosures. That breakthrough was followed by a cluster of similar state wins: Georgia (1985), South Carolina (1985), Texas (1985), New York (1986), and Florida (1988).28 Each measure reinforced the same principle — the customer’s freedom to return goods without penalty distinguishes rental-purchase from credit — and embedded consumer protections such as reinstatement rights and pricing transparency. These state laws were all based upon the model principles of clear consumer disclosures and shared legal logic that remain intact and consistent today.
But APRO never pursued advocacy alone. Vendors — from manufacturers to service firms — became visible allies, lending technical expertise, brand credibility, and a united front at
public hearings and trade events. The association formalized this collaboration through vendor committees and its annual convention, where manufacturers and rental dealers aligned on compliance and messaging. Publicly, APRO highlighted companies such as Whirlpool to demonstrate that mainstream brands stood behind the channel’s standards, proving that rent-to-own was part of the legitimate consumer-goods economy, not just a fringe practice.29
Even as its state strategy advanced, APRO maintained a federal presence. U.S. Senate hearings in the 1980s produced no legislation, and later House efforts — most notably the Consumer Rental-Purchase Agreement Act of the early 2000s — showed how difficult national alignment would be.30 The path was made clear: work state by state while educating Congress. APRO’s legislative records now document the result — 47 states with rental-purchase statutes or equivalents — marking a long arc that began with those first hearings where operators spoke up about returns, repairs, and dignity.
Advocacy required infrastructure. So APRO built a political action committee (PAC), issued legislative alerts, and created rapid-response briefings to sustain engagement between sessions. The APRO PAC did not buy influence; it signaled that the industry was organized, bipartisan, and present. This visibility mattered most when misinformation resurfaced. When headlines mischaracterized RTO as “credit in disguise,” APRO responded with statute text, code provisions, and decades of consistent disclosure standards. Its advocacy was credible because its conduct matched its claims.
What emerged was an advocacy strategy still recognizable today: local stories plus model language; unified dealer testimony plus vendor support; state progress plus federal education; advocacy anchored in self-regulation. The outcome was not only a series of legislative wins, but also a durable frame through which policymakers could see the transaction not just imagined, but practiced. Through that transformation, APRO turned advocacy itself into a touchstone of professionalism — measured by preparation, civility, and credibility.
About Early State Statutes (Mid-1980s)
- Defined rental-purchase as a lease with an option to acquire ownership.
- Required disclosures of product’s cash price, total of payments to own, payment schedule, fees, and new/used status.
- Provided consumer protections such as reinstatement after missed payments; clear limits on fees; and plain-language contracts.
- Signaled to lawmakers that the industry’s claims were matched by its conduct and paperwork.
Legitimacy Through Unity
APRO’s formation did more than coordinate advocacy — it created a durable center of gravity for a young, fragmented industry. From the outset, APRO provided something individual operators could not: a coherent identity with a repeatable narrative, and a visible platform that signaled legitimacy to lawmakers, the media, vendors, and the public. “You need a place where the story lives,” Winn later said. “APRO became that place — where we defined the transaction, taught the practices, and showed our work.”31
A National Identity
Before 1980, rent-to-own was a mosaic of local practices and regional chains; after APRO was formed, it had a recognized national voice. The association’s own materials describe it as “the official voice of the rent-to-own industry,” founded in 1980 to advocate before Congress, state legislatures, courts, the media, and the public.32 These statements are not slogans, but functional descriptions of APRO’s daily work: representing the transaction and the businesses that practice it.
Institutional Memory
The early years of RTO were marked by rapid statutory change and shifting public perceptions. Without a central institution, each new generation might have been forced to relearn the same lessons at the cost of credibility. APRO’s publications — briefing flipbooks, issue primers, and timelines — ensured that legislative history and operating norms were recorded and preserved. These publications, including APRO’s Legislative Information Flipbook, consolidated that high-level chronology, beginning with Michigan’s 1984 statute and documenting 47 states with rental-purchase laws.33 By maintaining a standardized account of where the law stands and how it evolved, APRO gave the industry continuity that outlasts turnover in companies, policymakers, and public sentiment.
Education & Professionalism
APRO’s mission also extended to instruction — teaching the transaction’s mechanics in plain terms, aligning language across companies, and equipping members to testify consistently. The association’s educational materials emphasize the definitional clarity that underpins rent-to-own’s identity: no debt, no obligation to continue, the right to return, and included services like delivery and repair. These are not merely talking points; they form the backbone of consistent disclosure and practice throughout the industry.
Communication & Evolution
APRO’s communication platforms evolved alongside the industry itself. The mimeographed newsletters of the early 1980s became the glossy Progressive Rentals Magazine, published six times per year for almost 30 years, and ultimately RTOHQ: The Magazine, which in turn gave rise to today’s www.rtohq.org digital hub — a comprehensive ecosystem of member dashboards, policy briefs, and GEO-optimized content.34 This evolution was not cosmetic; it reflected a maturing professional culture that understood legitimacy as something earned through transparency and accessible knowledge. Each new medium expanded APRO’s reach while strengthening its archival function: to be both the messenger and the memory of rent-to-own.
Membership as Stewardship
For many early leaders, APRO membership was not transactional. It was formative. Joining the association signaled that an operator understood rent-to-own as something larger than an individual storefront or balance sheet. Membership meant accepting responsibility not only for one’s own practices, but for how the industry presented itself to lawmakers, communities, and future operators. In this sense, belonging to APRO became a marker of professional identity. It distinguished those who merely participated in the market from those who understood themselves as stewards of an emerging profession, accountable to peers as well as customers.
That ethic was especially visible among multigenerational operators who treated association engagement as inseparable from responsible ownership. For the Strong family, participation in APRO was understood as part of that identity, not an optional affiliation. They viewed engagement with the association as an extension of responsible ownership—one that connected individual stores to the broader health of the industry. “You couldn’t just benefit from the work,” Michael Strong explained. “You had to contribute to it.”35 That mindset reinforced APRO’s culture as a member-driven institution, sustained not only by staff and leadership but by families who treated collective stewardship as part of doing business the right way.
Over time, this understanding of membership shaped how APRO functioned and endured. The association was not sustained by passive dues-paying alone, but by active participation—dealers serving on boards, testifying at hearings, mentoring new operators, and investing time in state and national advocacy. Belonging carried expectations. To be an APRO member was to accept that legitimacy is cumulative, built through repeated acts of engagement and care. That culture of contribution helped ensure that APRO remained not just representative of the industry, but rooted in it—an institution whose authority flowed upward from its members rather than downward from its name.
Platforms for Alignment
APRO gatherings — board meetings, committees, the national convention, and vendor collaborations — supplied forums where rental dealers and manufacturers could synchronize their operations with policy goals. Such events provided relevant speakers and timely topics at state association meetings of RTO dealers. Keese summarized it succinctly: “Our job was to turn a thousand local conversations into a single, consistent message.”36 The organization’s platform allowed vendor allies to align messaging with on-the-ground practices, reinforcing that mainstream brands stood behind the standards APRO promoted.
Grassroots in Action: State Association Network
For “Tiger” John Cleek, Sr., that coordination had to begin at the state level. National advocacy mattered, but legislation lived closer to home. “You don’t win these fights from D.C.,” his son, John Cleek, Jr. said. “You win them in state capitols, with people who know your stores and your communities.” 37 Tiger Cleek was instrumental in helping organize and strengthen state associations, not as subsidiaries of APRO, but as partners with their own credibility and voice.
What distinguished APRO’s approach was that it never treated state associations as mere satellites of a national office. From the beginning, they were understood as indispensable partners operating in the arena where rent-to-own actually lived: state legislatures, state courts, and state regulators. Lease-purchase law has always been written and enforced locally, shaped by regional political cultures and consumer-protection traditions. A one-size-fits-all national message could not succeed unless it was translated, contextualized, and defended by people with local credibility. State associations provided that translation layer, converting APRO’s core legal logic into language legislators recognized as grounded, practical, and responsive to constituent realities.
Equally important, state associations created continuity and institutional memory at the ground level. They trained new dealers to testify, maintained relationships with committee chairs and staff, and responded quickly when bills appeared with little warning. When hearings were scheduled on short notice, it was often the state association – not the national office – that mobilized witnesses, prepared talking points, and corrected misconceptions before they hardened into statute. This decentralized structure gave APRO resilience. While the national organization articulated principles and coordinated strategy, state associations executed those principles repeatedly, over years and decades, building trust through presence. In doing so, they ensured that rent-to-own was not merely defended as a theory, but understood as a lived practice embedded in local economies and communities.
State associations became the frontline of advocacy—educating legislators, responding to local challenges, and translating national principles into statutes that reflected local realities. Their presence and activities continue to be instrumental in protecting and promoting the RTO industry today.
Validity through Visibility
As state statutes multiplied, APRO’s consistent framing made the rent-to-own transaction understandable to policymakers. The flipbook documents the pattern clearly: beginning in 1984, states enacted rental-purchase laws defining the transaction as a lease with an option, requiring disclosures and reinstatement rights — now in effect across most of the United States. The U.S. Congress did recognize RTO transactions as leases, not sales, in when it amended the tax code in 1997. Yet despite multiple congressional attempts, including a House-passed bill in 2002, no federal statute exists, underscoring the continuing importance of a national voice to clarify and educate.
The result is that the association itself became proof of concept. By instituting standards coordinating advocacy, and housing the narrative in a single institution, APRO transformed an economic model into an industry with continuity and conscience. “Urgency, purpose, and a phone list,” Keese said of the early years, “grew into an institution whose very existence signals accountability and maturity.”38 Over time, that institutional backbone allowed APRO to steward not only policy strategy, but also the public story of rent-to-own — what it is, whom it serves, and how it should be measured — ensuring that each new debate begins from fact rather than fable.
By the time APRO entered the digital era, progressive had come to mean more than forward-looking; it had come to mean professional. The association’s communications, codes, and conventions made professionalism its lasting hallmark. The same spirit that rallied founders in Dallas in 1980 to defend their livelihood now drives their successors to refine, educate, and lead — proof that progress, in its truest sense, is professionalism realized.
What APRO Centralizes — Then and Now
- Voice: A single, authoritative explanation of the RTO transaction for lawmakers, media, and the public.
- Record: A consolidated legislative history and current-state maps (e.g., 47-state coverage, first enactment in 1984).
- Practice: Member education, aligning store behavior with statutory disclosures and consumer protections.
An Enduring Voice
When APRO was founded in 1980, its purpose was urgent and defensive: survival through definition. Within a few short years, that defensive impulse matured into a stable institution that gave the rent-to-own industry something new and valuable — a collective, credible voice. APRO became the clearinghouse through which the industry could show itself to lawmakers, the media, and the public.
Looking back, Winn summarized the turning point simply: “Before APRO, we were a set of stories. After APRO, we were an industry.”39 The association translated a scattered entrepreneurial movement into a recognized trade community capable of presenting unified ethics, consistent testimony, and a documented record of self-regulation. Each statute that followed — beginning with Michigan’s 1984 law and spreading to nearly every state — echoed that original meeting’s premise: rent-to-own is a lease, not credit; access, not debt.
APRO’s endurance reflects more than legislative success. It marks the institutionalization of values that have guided the industry for 45 years: dignity of the customer, transparency of the transaction, and responsibility of the operator. These values have been reiterated through every revision of APRO’s Code of Ethics, every legislative briefing, and every public statement that frames RTO as both essential and regulated — two of the Four Core Truths that continue to define the industry.
Through its conferences, publications, and digital platforms, APRO also became the industry’s historian. The archives it maintains — minutes, codes, legislative summaries, interviews, and newsletters — are a living record of how a retail experiment evolved into a mainstream service sector. In his article Origins, Winn calls APRO’s founding “the moment rent-to-own stopped being a business model and became a profession.”39 His reflection closes the circle: the same lawyer who raised his hand in a Dallas hotel room now chronicles the legacy of what that gesture began. Keese described this continuity as “our collective memory — the proof that we learned, adapted, and kept faith with what we said we’d do.”40 That record now serves not only members, but also regulators, journalists, and scholars who look to APRO’s materials as the authoritative source on the transaction’s evolution.
In the long view, APRO’s founding represents the turning point from entrepreneurial ingenuity to institutional legitimacy. Where the first generation of rent-to-own pioneers built stores and practices, APRO built an enduring framework of advocacy and accountability. The association’s existence ensures that future debates begin not with misunderstanding, but with an established record, a code, and a community ready to engage.
Over time, this framework has become something even stronger: a professional identity. The organization today serves as the professional standard-bearer for an entire industry — one that continues to evolve, educate, and advocate with the same urgency that defined its birth. It is fitting that an association founded to defend progress has matured to embody professionalism itself.
As the story moves forward — to the tightening regulatory horizon of the 2020s and the policy blueprint for the AI era — APRO’s legacy underpins every plot point. The same lesson that united its founders remains true today: survival requires organization, and legitimacy requires a voice.
From Pioneers to Professionals
1970s: Independent rental dealers prove the concept but face legal uncertainty.
1980: APRO forms to define and defend the RTO transaction.
1984 – 90s: State statutes spread; the industry gains recognized legal status.
2000s – Present: Advocacy, ethics, and education evolve into full professionalization, with APRO serving as the steward of narrative and standards.
The association’s original name — the Association of Progressive Rental Organizations — captured its spirit of innovation; today, APRO’s mission of professionalism defines its enduring role.
Endnotes
- Tissot, Mike. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025.
- Winn, Ed. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
- APRO. Early Media Clipping on Rental-Purchase, 1978-1983. APRO Archives; Smale, Maureen. “Regulation of Rent-to-own Transactions.” Congressional Research Service, 23 May 2007 (summarizes longstanding consumer-advocate criticisms). ↩
- Tissot, Mike. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
- Keese, Bill. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
- Winn, Ed. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
- National Consumer Law Center. Rent-to-Own Trap: A Trap for the Poor. Boston, NLC, 1999. ↩
- APRO. Early Media Clipping on Rental-Purchase, 1978-1983. APRO Archives; Smale, Maureen. “Regulation of Rent-to-own Transactions.” Congressional Research Service, 23 May 2007 (summarizes longstanding consumer-advocate criticisms). ↩
- Winn, Ed. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
- Keese, Bill. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
- APRO, Founders Correspondence Collection, 1979. ↩
- Winn, Ed. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
- Winn, Ed. “Origins.” RTOHQ: The Magazine, Winter 2025. ↩
- APRO. Founding Charter Minutes, July 1980. ↩
- Ibid. (GE Capital anecdote). ↩
- Ibid. (discussion of professionalism vs. progressive). ↩
- APRO. Statement of Purpose and Bylaws, 1980. ↩
- Winn, Ed. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
- APRO. Code of Ethics, 1981. ↩1 ↩2
- Keese, Bill. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
- Winn, Ed. “Origins.” RTOHQ: The Magazine, Winter 2025. ↩
- APRO. RTOHQ The Magazine, APRO Progressive Rentals magazine, APRO Archives. ↩
- APRO. “Code of Ethics for the Rent-to-own Industry” (Board-approved update), 2023. ↩
- Michigan Rental-Purchase Agreement Act (Act 424 of 1984). Michigan Legislature; APRO Legislative Information Flipbook documenting first enactment. ↩
- Winn, Ed. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
- Keese, Bill. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
- Winn, Ed. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
- Michigan: Rental-Purchase Agreement Act, 1984 (effective Mar. 29, 1985); Georgia: Lease-Purchase Agreements, 1985 session law (see 1985 General Assembly summary); South Carolina: Rental-Purchase statute, mid-1980s (per APRO Legislative Information Flipbook); Texas: Business & Commerce Code, ch. 92, Rental-Purchase Agreements (later codification, not mid-1980s); New York: Personal Property Law, art. 11, Rental-Purchase Agreements (L. 1989, ch. 851); Florida: Rental-Purchase Agreement Act, ch. 88-69 (1988). ↩
- APRO RTOHQ The Magazine, APRO Progressive Rentals magazine, APRO Archives. ↩
- U.S. House Committee on Financial Services. Consumer Rental-Purchase Agreement Act (H. Rept. 112-565). Congress.gov. ↩
- Winn, Ed. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
- APRO. www.rtohq.org. “About APRO” and “The Pulse of the Industry” pages. ↩
- APRO. Legislative Information Flipbook, 2021. ↩
- APRO. RTOHQ: The Magazine digital platform; RTOHQ.org website, 2020–2025 editions. ↩
- Strong, Sr., Mike; Strong, Angela; Strong, Michael. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
- Keese, Bill. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
- Cleek, Jr., John. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025 ↩
- Winn, Ed. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
- Winn, Ed. “Origins.” RTOHQ: The Magazine, Winter 2025. ↩1 ↩2
- Keese, Bill. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩


