The Rent-to-Own Revolution · Chapter 2
In this chapter
The rise of rent-to-own (RTO) in the 1960s and 70s was not accidental, but rather a product of the tension that had been mounting within the industry for decades. Consumers were under pressure to keep pace with new products that defined modern living (and to a lesser degree, keep up with the Joneses), while maintaining their dignity within a retail system that had once democratized access, but was now either excluding them or punishing them financially.
Each wave of new technology carried cultural significance. In the 1920s, it was radios and refrigerators. By the 1950s, televisions had become the centerpiece of the American living room. In the 1960s and 70s, color televisions, stereo systems, and microwaves set the new standard. In a very real sense, these products became tangible representations of who was — and who was not — a success. People compared themselves with their neighbors, coworkers, and relatives, and the absence of these products was felt as not just an inconvenience, but an embarrassment.
Department stores and finance companies constructed their credit systems around the middle class. For those with irregular incomes or blemished histories, it was almost impossible to obtain financing through traditional methods. Mainstream retailers were not designed to serve such households. Installment contracts remained unforgiving, and a single missed payment often meant product repossession and lingering debt. Credit cards (beginning nationally only in the late 1970s) might have provided some flexibility, but were still concentrated in higher income brackets.
Traditional retail lacked a proper solution for this financially imperfect consumer base. Layaway policies postponed delivery until every dollar was paid, which meant the sofa or TV stayed in the stockroom while the family waited on the sidelines. Installment credit created the opposite problem: immediate delivery, but unyielding obligations. Saving toward big-ticket items was no better, because prices often outpaced paychecks. Families who tried to wait for purchases frequently discovered that the goalposts had moved. The very act of prudence left them even further behind.
Rent-to-own emerged within this gap. RTO was not simply about acquiring televisions or sofas; it was about immediacy, flexibility, and inclusion. Families could take home the products that signaled success in modern life, pay in increments aligned with their paychecks, and return items without lasting penalty. Entrepreneurs like Ernie Talley and Charlie Loudermilk saw what traditional retailers ignored: the barrier was not desire, it was access. By reframing the transaction as a renewable lease rather than rigid credit, they created a system that included households in society’s technological progress.
What distinguished many of the early operators was not a novel pricing strategy but a moral intuition about need. As Mike Tissot later reflected on the dealership started by his father, Darrel Tissot in Hillsboro, Ohio, the business never felt abstract or opportunistic to him. It was rooted in the daily realities of families who needed things to function – a bed that allowed someone to sleep before work, a refrigerator that kept food safe, a washer that made ordinary life possible. “We weren’t trying to outsmart anyone,” Tissot recalled. “We were trying to solve problems people had that day, not next quarter.” That orientation – practical, immediate, and grounded in dignity – shaped the culture of early rent-to-own far more than spreadsheets ever did.¹
The Age of Insecurity
The 1960s and 70s were years of deep contradictions. At the surface, America celebrated suburban prosperity, household convenience, and the promise of new technologies. Advertisements showed families gathered around color televisions, living rooms filled with modern furniture, and kitchens equipped with the latest appliances. Yet for millions of households, the financial tools needed to obtain such durable goods were beyond their grasp.
The demand for these products was clear. A color television or a refrigerator was no longer considered a luxury, but an essential component of what defined a modern household. But for many American households, how to get the products was less obvious. Credit was restricted, interest rates were high, and wages were volatile. For many families, the available choices were unacceptable: either go without or risk the punitive terms of an installment contract.
The gap between desire and access gave rent-to-own its opening. RTO simply needed to remove the barriers preventing consumers from fulfilling their durable-goods desires. The rent-to-own model solved three problems at once: it delivered immediacy by letting families take home products the same day, it offered flexibility by letting consumers return at any time without continuing debt, and it created inclusion by giving households access to the same technologies defining American life.
When the cost of waiting is higher than the cost of access, people will choose access. That dynamic shaped the conditions of the 1970s and explains why RTO progressed from scattered experiments into a distinguishable industry.
Layaway & the RTO Reversal
By the 1960s and 70s, the American household was once again being reshaped by technology. Products like color televisions, stereos, and microwaves were no longer luxuries; they were part of the cultural fabric — how families entertained, experienced major events, and kept pace with the world around them.
Yet the problem that had haunted middle-class households for decades remained. Most families could not pay cash, and traditional credit remained limited or unforgiving. Layaway filled part of that gap, and by the mid-1970s, discount and department stores had turned layaway into a fixture of retail life. It provided structure and predictability, but offered inclusion in theory only. The product did not come home until every payment was made, which meant families stayed on the sidelines of the very experiences driving demand.
Waiting meant missing out. Layaway payments might fit the budget, but the goods came (too) much later. And in a world where new technologies set the tone of everyday life, delay could feel like exclusion.
Rent-to-own reversed that equation. It kept the regular payment structure that made layaway workable and delivered the product immediately. Ownership could come over time, but participation commenced on day one. RTO aligned the payment with the paycheck and the goods with families’ moment of need.
When technological change moves faster than traditional financing, households seek solutions that match their reality. Layaway told them to wait, while rent-to-own welcomed them in.
The Wichita Genesis: Ernie Talley & Mr. T’s Rental
The rent-to-own industry has no single founder, but if there is a moment that captures its genesis, it belongs to Ernie Talley in Wichita, Kansas. Talley ran an appliance store, and observed a recurring pattern: families wanted refrigerators, washers, and televisions, but were denied credit or feared the harshness of installment contracts. Some tried renting as a stopgap — paying week-to-week — but over time, Talley noticed many of these families paying more in rent for products than the actual retail value of them.
The conventional logic of retail said to keep collecting. Talley took a different view. He recognized the real issue was not a lack of willingness from customers, but a credit structure that set them up to fail. His response was simple and bold. When a customer had effectively paid the value of the product through their rental, he considered it theirs.
This moment reframed the transaction. What Talley saw was that access was more valuable than ownership at the start, but ownership still mattered if the household proved able to sustain the payments. The answer was not a strict contract that trapped families in debt; the answer was flexibility that created inclusion.
By 1963, Talley had turned this insight into a formal business: Mr. T’s Rental. The model was straightforward: families could take home appliances or furniture immediately, pay in small weekly or monthly increments, and return the product if necessary. If the household kept paying long enough, ownership transferred. No credit checks. No deficiency balances.
Word spread quickly, and Mr. T’s grew into a regional chain with more than a dozen stores across Kansas, Missouri, and Oklahoma by the early 1970s. 2
The First Followers
Talley was the first to shape rent-to-own into a workable model, but he was not the only one to recognize its potential. In the 1960s and 70s, a wave of entrepreneurs saw what Talley had built and adapted the idea to their own communities. Some were direct protégés who learned the business inside Mr. T’s stores. Chuck Sims learned from Talley, launched Remco in Texas in 1974, and purchased Mr. T’s when Talley left the business later that year — giving Remco 14 stores and a springboard for expansion across the Southwest U.S.3 Others were local furniture or appliance dealers who watched customers struggle with credit and began offering rentals as an option.
The transaction was simple, the barrier to entry was low, and the consumer need already existed. Technology was evolving quickly, and every new product generated fresh demand. Families wanted inclusion in modern living, whether that meant watching television in color, playing music on a stereo system, or cooking with a microwave oven. Yet the cost of these goods was high, and access via credit was limited. That unmet need pulled entrepreneurs into the market and made RTO not just viable, but necessary.
Rent-to-own companies were not yet connected by formal networks, but they were bound by the same logic: rent-to-own worked because it corresponded with customer reality. Where banks said no, RTO stores said yes. Where department stores demanded credit, RTO demanded only your weekly payment. By the end of the 1970s, scattered operators were doing business across the Midwest, South, and parts of the West. Many worked in isolation, unaware that similar businesses were using the same model successfully all around the country. Tradeshows and furniture markets helped accelerate the spread, as word of rent-to-own traveled through retailers’ informal conversations.
By 1980, the seeds had taken root and were flourishing. When the Association of Progressive Rental Organizations (APRO) was founded that year, roughly 40 companies joined as charter members. Their presence confirmed that rent-to-own was no longer the experiment of a single Wichita merchant; it had become a movement, carried forward by the first followers who saw an unmet consumer need and stepped up to fulfill it.
Scaling the Model: Tom Devlin, W. Frank Barton, & Rent-A-Center
If Ernie Talley proved that rent-to-own could work, Tom Devlin and W. Frank Barton proved it could scale. Their story begins, like Talley’s, in Wichita. Devlin started as a store manager for Mr. T’s and quickly embraced the logic of the model. But Devlin also saw the next frontier: if rent-to-own was to become more than a local experiment, it had to shed its pawnshop image and embrace professional retailing.
In 1973, Devlin partnered with Barton, a seasoned businessman who had built a successful appliance and electronics distribution company. Barton brought two essential assets to this new venture: capital and vendor relationships. Devlin brought an instinct for customers and a clear vision of what the RTO storefront should look like. Together, they opened the first Rent-A-Center in Wichita.
What distinguished Rent-A-Center was not the lease structure; Talley had already pioneered that. The difference was in presentation and consistency. Devlin had a sharp sense of what customers needed and a clear idea of how the stores should feel. Merchandise was new rather than secondhand. Barton made sure RCA televisions, Whirlpool appliances, and other national name brands populated the showroom floor. Promotions like “No Credit Needed” and “$1 Pays Your First Week” helped deliver the message directly.
The model worked. Rent-A-Center grew rapidly in the late 1970s, moving beyond the borders of Kansas into surrounding states. By the end of the decade, it had established a multi-state footprint and proven that rent-to-own could be standardized and replicated. It was a turning point for the industry.
When Rent-A-Center was acquired by Thorn EMI in 1987, it had expanded to approximately 469 locations.4 An exact store count for 1979–80 is not available in reliable sources, but company histories confirm that Rent-A-Center expanded across multiple states during the late 1970s and was viewed as a rising national chain.5
A Southern Vision: Charlie Loudermilk & Aaron’s
While Talley and Devlin were building Rent-A-Center in Wichita, another chapter of the rent-to-own story was unfolding in Atlanta, Georgia. R. Charles “Charlie” Loudermilk launched Aaron Rents in 1955 with a $500 loan and a simple, effective idea: renting 300 Army-surplus folding chairs to auction houses and community events.
From those early chair rentals, Loudermilk gradually expanded into furniture and appliances. By 1964, he had opened his first furniture-only rental store. His growth strategy was deliberate; Loudermilk reinvested profits carefully and avoided debt whenever possible.
By the mid-1970s, Aaron Rents had nearly 20 showrooms, was generating close to $10 million in annual revenue, and had become the largest furniture rental business in the country.6 Loudermilk’s success came not from chasing aggressive volume, but from a relentless focus on customer service and capital efficiency. His stores carried sofas, refrigerators, televisions, and other household staples, and in 1971, he had launched an in-house manufacturing division to keep up with demand.7
Aaron Rents differed from the pure RTO model emerging in Wichita. It operated as a hybrid, combining traditional furniture rentals with an option to buy. Many customers rented indefinitely, while others purchased items outright at a depreciated price. But the underlying logic was the same: retail finance excluded too many households, and rental provided a way in.
Loudermilk understood that inclusion in consumer culture was about more than products; it was also about being present in the community “his stores served.” He famously rented tents to Martin Luther King, Jr.’s team for the 1965 Selma to Montgomery civil-rights march, a gesture that linked his business to a defining moment in American history.8 Loudermilk’s main contribution was showing that furniture and appliance rentals could scale through disciplined business management and strong community trust.
By 1980, Aaron Rents was poised for even greater expansion. Loudermilk had proven the business could sustain itself regionally, and prepared to go national. His company gave the rent-to-own industry a second anchor, rooted in the South.
Replication & Franchising: Willie Talley & ColorTyme
By the late 1970s, rent-to-own had proven itself on multiple fronts. Ernie Talley had shown it could succeed regionally, Tom Devlin and W. Frank Barton had demonstrated it could be scaled into a multi-state retail chain, and Charlie Loudermilk had built the largest furniture rental business in the South.
The next challenge faced by the burgeoning industry was how far and how fast the RTO concept could spread. In some spots, the response was straightforward replication. Independent entrepreneurs opened their own RTO shops after hearing about the success of Mr. T’s or Rent-A-Center. By the end of the 1970s, small rent-to-own businesses dotted towns across the Midwest, South, and parts of the West.
But by the 1980s, another idea emerged that would define the decade: franchising. Willie Talley, Ernie’s brother, recognized the demand from would-be operators who wanted to enter the business but lacked a clear playbook. Willie founded ColorTyme in 1979 in Texas with the goal of turning rent-to-own into a replicable franchise model.9
ColorTyme’s timing was deliberate. By the late 1970s, the basic RTO transaction had been proven, but the industry was still fragmented and inconsistent. A franchise system offered local entrepreneurs the benefits of shared branding, purchasing power, and operational know-how, while giving the industry a more professional and standardized face. While ColorTyme would not expand aggressively until the 1980s, its founding signaled that rent-to-own had arrived at a new stage.
Other Early Operators
While big RTO company names shaped the industry’s broad narrative, the 1960s and 70s also produced dozens of smaller operators who helped make rent-to-own a truly national phenomenon. Most of these businesses stayed local, operating one or two stores in their communities. Some were furniture dealers who shifted into rentals after seeing customers struggle with installment contracts; others were appliance shops experimenting with weekly payment plans.
Mike Strong, Sr., an early operator of Mike’s Rent To Own in Kansas, described those early years less as entrepreneurship than endurance. “Everybody did everything,” Mike Strong, Sr. recalled. “If something broke, you fixed it. If a customer needed help, you handled it yourself. There wasn’t a department for anything.” 10 That hands-on reality defined the era. Rent-to-own stores did not emerge from business plans or playbooks. They were built through trial, family labor, and an almost stubborn willingness to solve problems as they appeared.
These independent operators accepted the risk for all the reasons RTO appealed to begin with, with one additional advantage: they personally knew their customers. Risk was judged on relationships, not just numbers. Rent-to-own began as a human business, and it has generally retained that humanity, building it into a core strength of the model.
Tradeshows and furniture markets helped spread the idea. By the mid-1970s, word of rent-to-own was circulating in places like High Point, North Carolina, and Tupelo, Mississippi, where retailers gathered to exchange ideas. By the end of the decade, operators in states such as Georgia, Ohio, and Pennsylvania were running stores that mirrored what Talley and Devlin had originated.
For the Strong family, the business was learned face-to-face. “You figured it out by listening,” Mike Strong, Sr. explained. “Customers told you what worked and what didn’t.” Early rent-to-own stores became informal classrooms, shaped by repeated interaction rather than fixed rules. That closeness to customers influenced how terms were explained, how flexibility was applied, and how trust was earned—long before those practices were described as best practices or policy. 10
When APRO launched in 1980, its charter members collectively represented an estimated 200 - 350 stores nationwide. What had started as one Wichita store in 1963 had become a network of companies serving communities and consumers nationwide.
From a single store in Wichita in 1963 to hundreds across the United States by 1980, the trajectory of rent-to-own mirrored the technologies it helped distribute: rapid, transformative, and driven by a demand for access.
Timeline: From Layaway to Access
1960s–70s
- Color televisions, stereo systems, microwave ovens reshape home life
- Layaway spreads through discount chains, but delays inclusion
- RTO emerges, offering immediate access
1980s–90s
- VCRs, home computers, and larger televisions accelerate demand
- RTO scales nationally through chains and franchising
2000s–2010s
- Laptops and smartphones become essential to work and school
- RTO bridges the digital affordability gap
2020s
- Gaming systems, connected entertainment, and flexible technology ecosystems
- RTO continues as a practical access model for essential goods
Endnotes
- Dreiling, Geri L. “Where the Boys Are.” Dallas Observer, 7 Mar. 2002. “Rent-to-Own Store.” Encyclopedia.com, accessed 14 Sept. 2025. “Rent-A-Center, Inc. History.” FundingUniverse, accessed 2025.
- Dreiling, Geri L. “Where the Boys Are.” Dallas Observer, 7 Mar. 2002. “Rent-to-Own Store.” Encyclopedia.com, accessed 14 Sept. 2025. “Rent-A-Center, Inc. History.” FundingUniverse, accessed 2025. ↩
- “Rent-to-Own, APRO Founding, Charter Membership.” Wikipedia.com, last modified 2025. ↩
- “Rent-A-Center, Inc. History, Thorn EMI Acquisition.” FundingUniverse, accessed 2025. ↩
- Ibid. ↩
- “Aaron Rents, Inc. History.” FundingUniverse, accessed 2025. ↩
- “Aaron Rents, Inc. History.” FundingUniverse, accessed 2025. ↩
- Ruch, John. “Charlie Loudermilk, Buckhead’s Iconic Business and Civic Leader, Dies at 95.” Buckhead.com, 4 Aug. 2022. ↩
- “ColorTyme Rent-to-Own Franchise Business Opportunity.” BeTheBoss.com, accessed 2025. ↩
- Strong, Sr., Mike; Strong, Angela; Strong, Michael. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩1 ↩2
- Ibid.


