Association of Professional Rental Organizations (APRO)

A Transactional Alternative: The Long Tail of Installment Retail

The Rent-to-Own Revolution · Chapter 1

Skip to endnotes

Rent-to-own (RTO) is often mischaracterized as a late-twentieth-century gimmick — a legal trick to dodge credit laws. That caricature is not only superficial, but also factually wrong. RTO is not a loophole. It is the continuation of a much longer American story, with roots in British common law, of how households have historically secured access to essential goods when cash was scarce and wages were uncertain.

This lineage stretches from nineteenth-century hire-purchase agreements in Britain, to Singer sewing machines in early- to mid-century America, expanding to televisions, furniture, appliances, and eventually laptops, smartphones, and e-bikes. Families have always needed access now — in the present, not years later. Milk spoils, clothes do not clean themselves, and a good night’s sleep is not a given.

Durable goods meeting these needs were costly, incomes were uneven, and life did not wait for savings accounts to grow. Enduring models respected this reality: access and use today, pay as you go, return when you must, and eventually own, if you so choose.

From Hire-Purchase to Singer’s Installments

The story begins in Victorian Britain. Hire-purchase agreements allowed working families to lease pianos and furniture on weekly payments, with ownership possible only after steady installments.¹ These were not loans. If wages faltered, then the goods could be surrendered without lingering debt. The principle was simple: provide access immediately, and let families decide how long they could sustain it.

By the 1850s, the idea had crossed the Atlantic. The Singer Sewing Machine Company became the pioneer of American installment retail. Singer’s product was transformative — a machine that could clothe a household and generate income — but it cost more than $100, far beyond a typical family’s reach.² Singer solved the problem with door-to-door salesmen offering installments: $5 down, $5 a month.³

The sales methods were as innovative as the contracts. Salesmen carried demonstration machines into kitchens and parlors, stitching seams as they explained how families could afford their own in increments.⁴ What Singer sold was not just a tool, but time — the ability to enjoy the product’s benefits today while paying tomorrow. This formula, aligning access with pay cycles, would ripple through American retail for generations.

Beyond Sewing Machines: Furniture, Pianos, & Radios

The installment idea did not stay confined to sewing machines for long. By the early twentieth century, the same approach had transformed how Americans furnished their homes. Pianos — once a luxury of the well-to-do — became fixtures of the working- and middle-class parlor, small monuments to refinement and aspiration.⁵ Furniture stores and department houses followed the trend, inviting families to “furnish now and pay later,” a phrase that appeared in newspaper pages and storefront windows across the country. Radios and refrigerators arrived through the same channel in the 1920s, carrying the promise of modern convenience into households that could not pay cash upfront. By decade’s end, as research shows, most durable goods were no longer bought outright, but through installment agreements.⁶

Supporters saw this as progress: an opening of cultural and economic doors that had once been firmly shut. Installments allowed families to participate in the comforts of modern life rather than just observe them from the outside. Critics, on the other hand, worried that the ease of weekly payments tempted people into commitments they could not sustain. That tension — between dignity through access and the fear of overextension — shadowed installment retail from its beginnings.

The Long Tail of Installment Retail

In statistics, the “long tail” describes a curve that extends far beyond the peak. In commerce, it refers to enduring consumer demand that stretches across generations and product lines. 7 Installment purchasing has a very long tail. Its history captures an unbroken tradition of families needing practical ways to gain access to essential goods when income and savings do not line up neatly.

Seen in that light, rent-to-own is not a departure from the American story, but a continuation of it. The through-line runs from Singer’s sewing machines to pianos, to radios and refrigerators, to other appliances and furniture and, today, to computers and electronics. The goods evolve, but the household realities they respond to remain. RTO is simply the latest expression of that lineage — the structural descendant of two centuries of adaptation to consumer need.

The Roots of Installment Purchasing in America

America did not invent installment purchasing, but it transformed the model into a defining feature of household life. By the late nineteenth century, “easy terms” had become the on-ramp to modern living.

Innovation & Adaptation

The rise of installment retail in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries was not only a financial innovation, but also a social adaptation. Families needed ways to furnish homes, clothe children, and embrace modern life in the face of irregular wages, volatile employment, and the uncertainty of urban migration. Access mattered more than perfection; immediacy mattered more than savings.

For most American households, income came in fits and starts. Industrial workers faced layoffs during downturns. Seasonal employees in farming, construction, and retail lived by the calendar, not the clock. Immigrants arriving in cities often worked multiple unstable jobs before finding steady footing.8 Income volatility was a defining feature decades before anyone coined the term “gig economy.”

Installment contracts gave families a way to smooth the bumps. Goods could be used immediately while payments tracked to payday. Scholars have shown how installment plans were deliberately structured to align with wage cycles, making them workable for working-class families.9

Sewing machines, pianos, furniture, and later radios and refrigerators entered homes not because families had piles of cash, but because merchants found ways to match payments to the rhythms of wages. Durable goods were essential, but expensive. Paychecks came in uneven streams. Installment plans stitched the two together.

Goods carried cultural significance as well. A sewing machine meant a household could clothe itself and even generate income. A piano in the parlor was a symbol of refinement and aspiration.10 After World War II, televisions and refrigerators became icons of the American Dream — proof that a family belonged in the middle class.11 For generations, ownership equaled respectability. Installment contracts were not indulgences; they were pathways into the American mainstream, one payment at a time.12

The Conditional Sale

Courts and legislatures spent decades wrestling with how to categorize these transactions. Were they sales with deferred title? Chattel mortgages? Leases? The Uniform Conditional Sales Act of 1918 attempted to impose order, defining conditional sales and setting rules for recording and repossession.¹³ Under that law, consumers acquired goods over time, but the obligation was absolute. If the buyer defaulted, then the merchant could repossess the item and still pursue a deficiency judgment.¹⁴

This history matters because it highlights what RTO later corrected. Conditional sales offered access but trapped families in rigid requirements. They democratized durable goods, but tethered households to unforgiving debt.

Access with Stringency

So the benefits of installment purchasing came with a cost. Installment contracts were merciless. Missed payments could mean repossession, deficiency judgments, and shame.15 A family could lose its piano and still owe money on it. A refrigerator could be hauled out of the house on a Saturday morning while neighbors witnessed it, and an invoice for the balance — now swollen with fees — might still arrive in the mail the following week. For many households, that humiliation was as difficult as the financial hit itself.

Merchants defended the system as necessary discipline; critics saw it as a trap disguised as opportunity. Both were partially right. Installment credit opened doors, but it did so on terms that required life to behave. A single layoff, injury, illness, or bad season in farm or construction work could instantly unravel the whole arrangement. The structure assumed stability in lives that were anything but stable.

By the mid-twentieth century, reformers were already arguing that the model punished precisely the families it was meant to help. The access was real, but so was the risk of cascading consequences if a household missed just one payment. This contradiction — access paired with punishment — became the fault line innovators would eventually exploit.

It is along that seam that rent-to-own later offered a different answer: preserve the access, eliminate the penalty.

A National Debate

From the moment installment contracts spread in the late 1800s, Americans argued about whether paying over time uplifted households or tempted them into ruin. On one side were defenders who saw time-payments as a bridge to dignity, a way for working families to create comfortable homes, keep food fresh, or learn and enjoy music without waiting years to save. On the other side were critics — journalists, reformers, clergy, and later, consumer advocates — who warned that “easy terms” bred irresponsibility, hidden costs, and humiliation when repossessions came due. That tension has never dissipated. The arguments aimed at installment plans echo almost word-for-word in modern critiques of rent-to-own.

Pianos became fixtures of working- and middle-class parlors by the early 1900s. Historians note that by the early 1900s, pianos became parlor fixtures in working- and middle-class homes, as well as badges of respectability — signs of families who valued culture and education.16 Sewing machines symbolized industriousness, and refrigerators represented modern convenience. These were not frivolous purchases, but markers of belonging in American life. Defenders of installment sales believed that time-payments dignified families by expanding access and enabling them to demonstrate discipline: budgeting carefully, paying steadily, and earning ownership over time.17

Opponents, however, saw danger. British debates in the 1930s described hire-purchase as a “growing social evil,” warning that weekly payments encouraged imprudence.18 In the United States, similar critiques emerged during the 1920s, blaming time-payments for inflation, weakened thrift, and moral decline.19 In the late twentieth century, rent-to-own faced the same script — now framed around cost-effectiveness and supposed exploitation.20 Even now, critics recycle similar arguments, often ignoring consumer data that shows high completion and high satisfaction among RTO customers, as well as the importance of flexibility for households with unpredictable incomes.

A Values Shift

The rent-to-own model continues to persevere in part because generational values have evolved. For the Greatest Generation and Baby Boomers, dignity came with ownership: a house deed, a car title, a refrigerator humming in the kitchen. Gen Z and Gen Alpha have grown up in a subscription economy. They stream rather than buy DVDs. They upgrade their smartphones every two years. They use rideshare rather than owning a car. For them, desiring flexibility is not failure; it is freedom.

The cultural debate over access and ownership may never be resolved, but history shows that criticism rarely halts consumer practices. Households adopt models that respect their budgets, their timelines, and the shifting nature of their lives. Installments thrived despite moral critique; rent-to-own persists for the same reason.

Transition to the RTO Model: From Conditional Sales to Terminable Lease

By the mid-twentieth century, the limits of installment credit were unmistakable. Families had refrigerators repossessed, pianos carried away, and televisions removed from living rooms, only to discover they still owed a deficiency balance. The model offered access, but on exacting terms. Consumers wanted a better way.

The Entrepreneurial Turn

Entrepreneurs in the 1960s and 70s saw the opportunity. If households needed access to goods but feared debt, what if merchants offered renewable leases rather than conditional sales? What if customers could use a product for as long as they wanted, with the option to own, but without the onus of obligation? That inquiry and resulting insight gave rise to the modern rent-to-own model.

The most familiar origin story comes from Wichita, Kansas, where merchant Ernie Talley realized that customers who kept appliances long enough had effectively paid the full price. Rather than repossessing, he told them they owned the goods.21 That logic inspired Tom Devlin and W. Frank Barton, who in 1973 launched Rent-A-Center, the first national chain to scale the model.22

Meanwhile, in Atlanta, R. Charles “Charlie” Loudermilk grew Aaron’s from a regional furniture rental business into a national RTO leader.23 By the 1980s, both Rent-A-Center and Aaron’s were public companies, and dozens of independent operators flourished across the Midwest and South.

Their formula was consistent:

  • Short initial terms: week-to-week or month-to-month agreements;
  • Automatic renewal: customers could keep the item as long as payments continued;
  • Early-purchase options: a discounted path to ownership; and
  • Bundled service: delivery, setup, and repairs were included in the payment.

This was more than clever retailing; it was a structural solution to a century-old problem.

The Critical Distinction

The critical distinction between rent-to-own and credit transactions was, and is, terminability. In an RTO contract, a customer can return the item at any time, ending the obligation. No credit necessary. No deficiency balance. No lingering debt. Payments covered only the period of use. If ownership was desired, renewals or an early-purchase option completed the transaction.24

The Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) sharpened the line between leases and credit. Section 1-201(37) (now §1-203) laid out tests to determine whether a transaction was a true lease or a disguised security interest, with the key question being whether the consumer had the right to terminate. If yes, it was a lease. If no, it was credit.25 This became a central tool in judicial analysis and statutory design.

The Consumer Leasing Act of 1976 (implemented by Regulation M) reinforced this distinction. The Act applied to consumer leases longer than four months, but not to short-term, renewable agreements like RTO.26 Congress placed rent-to-own outside the credit framework and into a separate legal category. By the 1980s, states began passing rental-purchase statutes that codified RTO as a lease, not a loan, with clear disclosure requirements for cash price, total of payments, and early-purchase options.27

A Long Tail, Not a Loophole

Rent-to-own is not a loophole at the edge of American law. It is the latest chapter in a tale that stretches across centuries — the long tail of installment retail. From British hire-purchase agreements in the 1800s, to Singer’s sewing machines in American homes, to department-store ads promising “easy terms” for radios and refrigerators, households have always sought ways to align access with income. RTO is the modern expression of that necessity fulfilled.

Fixing the Installment Flaw

Installment sales offered access, but tethered families to perilous debt. A missed payment might mean repossession, humiliation, and a continuing balance due.28 Conditional sales democratized goods, but at the high cost of rigidity and risk. RTO rewrote the contract. By making agreements terminable at will, rent-to-own offered consumers a clean exit: return the goods, nothing further owed.29 This was a structural innovation, correcting the issue that had plagued installment credit from the start.

The Long Tail of Consumer Access

Viewed in this light, RTO belongs to the long tail of installment retail — not a gimmick of the 1970s, but the continuation of a lineage that has developed along with every generation of technology:

  • 1850s: Singer sewing machines sold door-to-door on installments — $5 down and $5 a month.30
  • 1900s: Pianos leased on time-payments, indicating cultural aspiration in middle-class parlors.31
  • 1920s: Radios and refrigerators marketed on “easy terms,” spreading modern convenience.32
  • 1970s: Rent-A-Center and Aaron’s pioneer renewable leases, embedding flexibility into the model.33
  • 2020s: Smartphones, laptops, and e-bikes enter RTO catalogs, proving the approach still holds.

Each stage met the same household reality: durable goods were expensive, wages were volatile, and access could not wait. Critics also surfaced during every era, warning of temptation or exploitation — yet households continued to choose access, because the alternative was exclusion.

Generational Continuity & Change

For the Greatest Generation and Baby Boomers, dignity came with ownership; installments were a bridge to that dream. For Gen Z and Gen Alpha, dignity is tied to flexibility; rent-to-own provides a bridge to that necessity. 34

RTO preserves the path to ownership for those who want it while safeguarding flexibility for those who need it. That balance — access without debt — is why RTO endures.

Endnotes

  1. Carnevali, Francesca. “Pianos for the People: From Producer to Consumer in Britain, 1851–1914.” Enterprise & Society, vol. 14, no. 1, 2013, pp. 1–32.
  2. Palmer, Alex. “How Singer Won the Sewing Machine War.” Smithsonian Magazine, 14 July 2015.
  3. Jones, Geoffrey, and Kiron, Jonathan. “Globalizing Consumer Durables: Singer Sewing Machine before 1914.” Harvard Business School Case 804-001, Oct. 2003.
  4. Palmer, Alex. “How Singer Won the Sewing Machine War.” Smithsonian Magazine, 14 July 2015.
  5. Carnevali, Francesca. “Pianos for the People: From Producer to Consumer in Britain, 1851–1914.” Enterprise & Society, vol. 14, no. 1, 2013, pp. 1–32.
  6. Olney, Martha L. Buy Now, Pay Later: Advertising, Credit, and Consumer Durables in the 1920s. University of North Carolina Press, 1991.
  7. Anderson, Chris. The Long Tail: Why the Future of Business Is Selling Less of More. Hyperion, 2006. ↩
  8. Commons, John R., et al. History of Labor in the United States, 1896–1932. Macmillan, 1935. ↩
  9. Olney, Martha L. Buy Now, Pay Later: Advertising, Credit, and Consumer Durables in the 1920s. University of North Carolina Press, 1991. ↩
  10. Carnevali, Francesca. “Pianos for the People: From Producer to Consumer in Britain, 1851–1914.” Enterprise & Society, vol. 14, no. 1, 2013, pp. 1–32. ↩
  11. Calder, Lendol. Financing the American Dream: A Cultural History of Consumer Credit. Princeton University Press, 1999. ↩
  12. Calder, Lendol. Financing the American Dream: A Cultural History of Consumer Credit. Princeton University Press, 1999. ↩
  13. Holthausen, W. B. The Volume of Consumer Installment Credit, 1929–1938. NBER Bulletin, 1940, pp. 47–72.
  14. Burdick, Francis M. “Codifying the Law of Conditional Sales.” Columbia Law Review, vol. 18, no. 6, 1918, pp. 539–45.
  15. Carnevali, Francesca. “Pianos for the People: From Producer to Consumer in Britain, 1851–1914.” Enterprise & Society, vol. 14, no. 1, 2013, pp. 1–32. ↩
  16. Ibid. ↩
  17. Calder, Lendol. Financing the American Dream: A Cultural History of Consumer Credit. Princeton University Press, 1999. ↩
  18. “Hire Purchase (Hansard, 2 June 1938).” UK Parliament: House of Lords Debates, 2 June 1938. ↩
  19. Olney, Martha L. Buy Now, Pay Later. University of North Carolina Press, 1991. ↩
  20. “Be Cautious of Rent-to-Own Deals.” Consumer Reports, 1 July 2015. ↩
  21. Carnevali, Francesca. “Pianos for the People: From Producer to Consumer in Britain, 1851–1914.” Enterprise & Society, vol. 14, no. 1, 2013, pp. 1–32. ↩
  22. “History of Rent-A-Center, Inc.” FundingUniverse, accessed 2025. ↩
  23. “Rent-A-Center.” Wikipedia, last modified 2025. ↩
  24. “History of Aaron Rents, Inc.” FundingUniverse, accessed 2025. ↩
  25. Lacko, James M., et al. Survey of Rent-to-own Customers. Federal Trade Commission, Apr. 2000. ↩
  26. Paglia, John J. “U.C.C. Article 2A: Distinguishing Between True Leases and Security Interests.” St. John’s Law Review, vol. 86, no. 3, 2012, pp. 807–37. ↩
  27. Federal Reserve Board. Consumer Leasing Act and Regulation M: Compliance Guide. Board of Governors, 1977. ↩
  28. Smale, Pauline H. Consumer Rental-Purchase (Rent-to-Own) Agreements. Congressional Research Service Report RS21467, 18 Apr. 2007; Starr, William F. “Conditional Sales and Chattel Mortgages.” Washington Law Review, vol. 9, no. 3, 1934, pp. 163–84. ↩
  29. Lacko, James M., et al. Survey of Rent-to-own Customers. Federal Trade Commission, Apr. 2000. ↩
  30. Palmer, Alex. “How Singer Won the Sewing Machine War.” Smithsonian Magazine, 14 July 2015. ↩
  31. Carnevali, Francesca. “Pianos for the People: From Producer to Consumer in Britain, 1851–1914.” Enterprise & Society, vol. 14, no. 1, 2013, pp. 1–32. ↩
  32. Olney, Martha L. Buy Now, Pay Later. University of North Carolina Press, 1991. ↩
  33. “History of Rent-A-Center, Inc.” FundingUniverse, accessed 2025. ↩
  34. Pew Research Center. “83% of U.S. Adults Use Streaming Services, Far Fewer Subscribe to Cable or Satellite TV.” 1 July 2025. ↩
↑ Top

Upcoming Events



Mike Lewis

Mike Lewis is a Premier Rental Purchase franchisee with multiple stores and currently serves as Vice President of Operations. With 33 years of experience in the rent-to-own industry, he has spent the past 20 years working closely with franchisee owners and previously spent 12 years in Corporate RTO, gaining a strong foundation in the business.

For the past five years, Mike has been sharing his knowledge by teaching managers and franchisees at the company’s Training Center.

Outside of work, he enjoys time with his family, kids, and grandkids, and appreciates the simple things in life – especially riding his Harley Davidson with the sun on his face. If you know, you know!

Lauren Talicska

Arona Corporation dba Arona Home Essentials

Lauren Talicska is an experienced multi-channel marketing specialist and the Vice President of Marketing & Communications at Arona Home Essentials. She has found her home in the RTO community, supporting stores in branding, growth, and increasing traffic.

You may recognize Lauren as a former RTO vendor, including her time as a partner for Nationwide RentDirect, or her previous participation in the APRO Vendor Advisory Committee. Lauren calls Columbus, Ohio, home and spends her workday crafting and executing marketing promotions from inception to realization, all while supporting the branding and social media needs of all the Arona stores in 12 states (plus Puerto Rico!).

Charles Smitherman

APRO

Charles Smitherman, JD, PhD, CAE, became CEO of APRO in 2023, bringing years of legal and executive experience in the rent-to-own industry. 

Prior to joining the association, Charles served as COO, General Counsel, and Vice President of PTS Financial Services, where he played an active role in the rent-to-own industry by representing his company through PTS’s club program offering with APRO member dealers. Charles is an attorney with two decades of experience across a wide variety of areas, including RTO, consumer financial services, antitrust, corporate law, mergers and acquisitions, litigation, franchise law, and privacy law. Following law school at the University of Georgia, Charles earned a Master of Legal Studies and PhD in Law from the University of Oxford in England.

Charles is credentialed as a Certified Association Executive (CAE) with the American Society of Association Executives, a Certified Franchise Executive (CFE) with the International Franchise Association, and a Certified Information Privacy Professional (CIPP/US) and Certified Information Privacy Manager (CIPM) through the International Association of Privacy Professionals. As APRO’s sixth CEO in its 45-year history, he brings a collaborative, member-focused approach to association leadership, emphasizing transparency, advocacy, and value creation. Outside of work, Charles is an active ultra runner and open water swimmer.

Mike Kays

Ashley Furniture Industries

As VP of Rental Sales for Ashley Furniture Industries, Mike thrives on building relationships with our RTO industry veterans, and helping businesses grow through new product, new marketing, and new supply chain options.

Mike works to leverage a wide breadth of relationships and influence, intimate knowledge of market trends, and unique knowledge of what RTO dealers need from a supplier to be successful.

The saying goes that a high tide raises all boats, and our goal is to leverage the world’s largest furniture manufacturer to drive the continued growth of the RTO industry and all the suppliers.

Mike Tissot

Countryside Rentals Inc., dba Rent-2-Own

Mike grew up in the rent-to-own industry under the guidance of his father, former APRO President and RTO legend Darrell Tissot. For nearly 25 years, Mike’s innovative leadership has helped expand the family business to more than 40 stores across Ohio and Kentucky while also shaping the industry as a whole.

He has served as President of the Ohio Rental Dealers Association, an APRO board member and Treasurer, and President and Treasurer of the TRIB Group. His contributions have earned him the APRO President’s Award of Excellence and the title of APRO Rental Dealer of the Year.

Outside of RTO, Mike enjoys time at the lake house or in Orange Beach, Alabama, with his girlfriend, Angela Strong McCool. A passionate Cincinnati Reds fan, he rarely misses a game, whether watching or listening alongside his parents. He also takes every opportunity to visit Arizona, where his daughter is currently attending Arizona State University.