Association of Professional Rental Organizations (APRO)

The Fintech Gauntlet: Competing on Convenience & Trust

Skip to endnotes

The consumer finance landscape has always evolved in response to household needs. In the mid-twentieth century, credit cards introduced a new form of purchasing power, offering convenience and flexibility while embedding revolving debt into the daily lives of millions. The premise was seductive in its simplicity: just flash a card, or later, send your information by email or phone, and the transaction was complete.

However, this “plastic revolution” was not the beginning of consumer finance; it was merely a technology shift in a much longer narrative about access. In the 1930s and 40s, before the ubiquity of revolving credit, households navigated an “Age of Insecurity” where the desire for modern goods — radios, refrigerators, and washing machines — often outpaced cash on hand. During this period, the primary mechanism for access was the installment contract, a rigid instrument where a single missed payment often meant repossession and lingering debt.

As the economy shifted post-World War II, layaway emerged as the bridge for the risk-averse. By the mid-1970s, discount and department stores had made layaway a staple of retail. It offered access in theory, but only after months of waiting. Payments were predictable, but the product stayed in the stockroom until the final dollar was collected. While it functioned well as a budgeting tool for Christmas, it failed to provide the immediacy that modern families increasingly needed.

The arrival of the credit card promised to solve this friction. When the first national charge cards appeared in 1950, they saw roughly $2 million in revenues. By end of year 2025, total volume is expected to reach nearly $8.5 trillion, a roughly 400,000-fold increase over 75 years. Yet even this massive expansion left gaps. Department stores and national banks built their systems around the middle class, leaving those with irregular incomes or blemished spending histories to seek alternatives.

Today, we find ourselves in a new version of this old, shared reality. In the early decades of the twenty-first century, a new entrant emerged: Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL). Though packaged in sleek mobile applications, the core concept is familiar. Hundreds of local businesses once offered a similar “four-pay” plan informally, but it never scaled nationally. Modern technology has simply digitized the installment book.

BNPL is more than a payment tool; it is a cultural phenomenon intertwined with e-commerce. With players like Affirm and Klarna capturing headlines, and PayPal’s “Pay in 4” signaling mainstream adoption, the industry has circled back to the installment model, but with a speed that matches the digital age. For rent-to-own (RTO) operators, this is the new gauntlet. The consumer finance landscape has shifted again, not by inventing a new need, but by using technology to satisfy the oldest one: the desire to possess the future today, on terms that fit the present.

The Allure of Convenience

BNPL’s meteoric rise is rooted in user experience and behavioral science. Consider a consumer making a $600 laptop purchase online. The checkout creates a friction point where the “pain of paying” is acute. BNPL mitigates this by framing the cost, not as a lump sum, but as four manageable payments of $150.

The application process is lightweight, requesting minimal information with approval arriving in seconds. The consumer feels they have avoided the weight of debt and paperwork burdens while still securing the product. This frictionless process contrasts sharply with traditional financing, which often requires full credit checks, or historical RTO models that required in-store paperwork and references.

While Virtual Rent-to-Own (VRTO) has largely matched these digital expectations through mobile apps and open banking decisions, it was BNPL that conditioned the modern consumer to this standard of speed.¹ Empirical work finds that BNPL availability at checkout increases order values and overall spend, because it leverages the psychological preference for installment framing.²

However, this convenience comes with a caveat. BNPL’s growth initially outpaced regulation, becoming ubiquitous before standardized disclosure frameworks emerged. While regulators are catching up, BNPL has already established itself as a default option alongside cards and digital wallets.³ For RTO, the path forward must acknowledge the appeal of BNPL, while matching its digital ease and demonstrating the superior protection RTO’s structure offers consumers.

The Structural Divide

Consumers today navigate three dominant non-cash payment models, each with distinct architectures:

  • Credit Cards: Offer universal acceptance and rewards, but create revolving debt with compounding interest;
  • BNPL: Provides installment clarity and digital ease, often interest-free, yet remains a loan with a fixed contractual obligation to repay; and
  • RTO: Provides access without debt, with delivery and service included, and a unique right to return.

The contract is the dividing line. Credit cards and BNPL bind consumers until repayment is complete. RTO agreements can be ended without penalty at any time. For households with income volatility, that exit ramp is the difference between financial resilience and financial crisis. Furthermore, RTO features often replace other hidden consumer costs, such as delivery fees, extended warranties, and the inability to return a defective product.

A Tale of Two Sofas

To understand the difference, we must look beyond the checkout screen and into the living room. Consider Mia and Jordan, a couple furnishing their first apartment, who find a sectional sofa for $1,200 online.

The BNPL Path: They select “Pay in 12 monthly payments of $100.” Approval is instant, but the warranty is limited to the manufacturer’s one-year coverage. Two months later, a cushion frame sags. Under BNPL, the retailer directs them to the manufacturer, who requests photos and authorizes a part that is on backorder. Meanwhile, the BNPL payments continue. If the issue persists, the couple may have to ship the component for inspection at their own cost. If Jordan’s work hours are cut and they miss a payment, they face late fees or account restrictions, all while owing a balance on a broken sofa.⁴

The RTO Path: The couple chooses a rent-to-own option for $30 per week. Delivery and setup are included by the local store. When the frame sags, they call the store, and a technician replaces it the same week under the included service provision. More importantly, when Jordan’s hours are cut, they can schedule a pickup. The agreement ends that day. There is no balance, no collections, and no credit damage.

The checkout experience for both paths was identical, but the outcomes differed wildly when life happened. RTO offered a safety valve — fix it quickly or return it quickly — that BNPL did not.

This comparison repeats across every core category. Whether it is a washer with a failed control board or a television with intermittent lines, the BNPL consumer is locked into a loan while navigating manufacturer warranties. The RTO consumer is supported by a service guarantee and a cancelable agreement. The product is guaranteed to work or made to work for as long as payments are current.

The Digital Decision Engine

All three models — credit cards, BNPL, and RTO — now rely on sophisticated decision engines to grant access. While credit cards anchor on FICO scores, BNPL platforms rely on linked bank accounts and purchase histories to approve consumers in seconds.⁵ RTO has evolved similarly, increasingly employing predictive analytics using alternative indicators such as income volatility and past lease performance to generate instant approvals.⁶

However, ethics matter in automation. Algorithms can reproduce bias if trained on biased data, a risk the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) has flagged regarding automated underwriting.⁷ RTO has an opportunity to lead by embedding fairness testing and maintaining human review — a local fail-safe that purely digital lenders lack. The sector has long served households excluded from traditional credit; in the digital age, it must prove that commitment through its systems.

Model Audiences

It is tempting to categorize automated financial engines as tools for the affluent and RTO as a tool for the unbanked, but the data suggests a sharper framing. The national unbanked rate is currently at a historic low, near 4.2%.⁸ Most RTO customers have bank accounts; they are simply credit-constrained or income-volatile.

Similarly, BNPL use is common among lower-score consumers and often coexists with credit cards rather than replacing them.⁹ Legal scholars note that a meaningful share of RTO customers also possess credit cards, but select RTO for bundled delivery and service, as well as the right to return.¹⁰

Regulation as Trust

One of the most significant differentiators in the current fintech landscape is regulatory maturity. BNPL’s growth preceded comprehensive rules, leading to concerns regarding late fees, overextension, and inconsistent credit reporting.¹¹ While the European Union has moved toward standardized disclosures, BNPL remains a regulatory patchwork in the United States.

RTO is the opposite. It is heavily regulated at the state level, with clear disclosure requirements, repossession rules, and consumer rights. Just as credit cards sit inside mature federal frameworks, RTO’s oversight is a competitive strength that signals maturity and accountability.

RTO as the Ethical Fintech

BNPL has successfully co-opted the narrative of “fintech,” but RTO is positioned to occupy a more durable lane: the “Ethical Fintech.”

To compete, RTO must achieve digital parity. The experience must be seamless, with mobile-first applications and instant decisions. However, once the digital friction is removed, the structural differentiators must take center stage. The sales culture must shift from persuasion to guidance, helping households compare payment structures and choose what fits their financial reality.

The message must be simple and repeated: “This is not a loan.” BNPL and credit cards stop at financing; RTO includes delivery, setup, service, and the right to return. For households facing uncertainty, RTO provides immediate access and an immediate exit, without penalties.

RTO’s Digital Spot

Modern consumers face abundant options. Credit cards, BNPL, and RTO each promise seamless access, and BNPL’s rise has made alternative financing familiar to the masses. Yet only RTO blends fintech convenience with safeguards that debt-based models cannot replicate.

The future will be a marketplace of options, not a single winner. When compared side by side, RTO stands out in both immediacy at purchase and compassion when life changes. It is fintech’s equal in convenience, but stands alone in offering the safety net of a debt-free exit.

Endnotes

  1. Floyd, Elizabeth. “Virtual Rent-to-Own: Fintech Disruption in the Lease-to-Own Market,” 2024.
  2. Akçay, Y. et al. Consumer Behavior in Buy Now, Pay Later Markets, 2024. See also Federal Reserve Bank of Boston, Consumer Payment Choice and Strategy, 2024; Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Buy Now, Pay Later: Market Trends and Consumer Risks, 2022; and Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Supervisory Highlights, 2025.
  3. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Buy Now, Pay Later: Market Trends and Consumer Risks, 2022; Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Supervisory Highlights, 2025.
  4. Ibid.
  5. Federal Reserve Bank of Boston. Consumer Payment Choice and Strategy, 2024; Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Supervisory Highlights, 2025.
  6. Demir. Algorithmic Fairness in Fintech Lending, 2024; Floyd, Elizabeth. “Virtual Rent-to-Own: Fintech Disruption in the Lease-to-Own Market,” 2024.
  7. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Buy Now, Pay Later: Market Trends and Consumer Risks, 2022.
  8. Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. National Survey of Unbanked and Underbanked Households, 2024.
  9. Federal Reserve Bank of Boston. Consumer Payment Choice and Strategy, 2024; Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Supervisory Highlights, 2025.
  10. Floyd, Elizabeth. “Virtual Rent-to-Own: Fintech Disruption in the Lease-to-Own Market,” 2024.
  11. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Buy Now, Pay Later: Market Trends and Consumer Risks, 2022; Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Supervisory Highlights, 2025.
↑ Top

Upcoming Events



Mike Lewis

Mike Lewis is a Premier Rental Purchase franchisee with multiple stores and currently serves as Vice President of Operations. With 33 years of experience in the rent-to-own industry, he has spent the past 20 years working closely with franchisee owners and previously spent 12 years in Corporate RTO, gaining a strong foundation in the business.

For the past five years, Mike has been sharing his knowledge by teaching managers and franchisees at the company’s Training Center.

Outside of work, he enjoys time with his family, kids, and grandkids, and appreciates the simple things in life – especially riding his Harley Davidson with the sun on his face. If you know, you know!

Lauren Talicska

Arona Corporation dba Arona Home Essentials

Lauren Talicska is an experienced multi-channel marketing specialist and the Vice President of Marketing & Communications at Arona Home Essentials. She has found her home in the RTO community, supporting stores in branding, growth, and increasing traffic.

You may recognize Lauren as a former RTO vendor, including her time as a partner for Nationwide RentDirect, or her previous participation in the APRO Vendor Advisory Committee. Lauren calls Columbus, Ohio, home and spends her workday crafting and executing marketing promotions from inception to realization, all while supporting the branding and social media needs of all the Arona stores in 12 states (plus Puerto Rico!).

Charles Smitherman

APRO

Charles Smitherman, JD, PhD, CAE, became CEO of APRO in 2023, bringing years of legal and executive experience in the rent-to-own industry. 

Prior to joining the association, Charles served as COO, General Counsel, and Vice President of PTS Financial Services, where he played an active role in the rent-to-own industry by representing his company through PTS’s club program offering with APRO member dealers. Charles is an attorney with two decades of experience across a wide variety of areas, including RTO, consumer financial services, antitrust, corporate law, mergers and acquisitions, litigation, franchise law, and privacy law. Following law school at the University of Georgia, Charles earned a Master of Legal Studies and PhD in Law from the University of Oxford in England.

Charles is credentialed as a Certified Association Executive (CAE) with the American Society of Association Executives, a Certified Franchise Executive (CFE) with the International Franchise Association, and a Certified Information Privacy Professional (CIPP/US) and Certified Information Privacy Manager (CIPM) through the International Association of Privacy Professionals. As APRO’s sixth CEO in its 45-year history, he brings a collaborative, member-focused approach to association leadership, emphasizing transparency, advocacy, and value creation. Outside of work, Charles is an active ultra runner and open water swimmer.

Mike Kays

Ashley Furniture Industries

As VP of Rental Sales for Ashley Furniture Industries, Mike thrives on building relationships with our RTO industry veterans, and helping businesses grow through new product, new marketing, and new supply chain options.

Mike works to leverage a wide breadth of relationships and influence, intimate knowledge of market trends, and unique knowledge of what RTO dealers need from a supplier to be successful.

The saying goes that a high tide raises all boats, and our goal is to leverage the world’s largest furniture manufacturer to drive the continued growth of the RTO industry and all the suppliers.

Mike Tissot

Countryside Rentals Inc., dba Rent-2-Own

Mike grew up in the rent-to-own industry under the guidance of his father, former APRO President and RTO legend Darrell Tissot. For nearly 25 years, Mike’s innovative leadership has helped expand the family business to more than 40 stores across Ohio and Kentucky while also shaping the industry as a whole.

He has served as President of the Ohio Rental Dealers Association, an APRO board member and Treasurer, and President and Treasurer of the TRIB Group. His contributions have earned him the APRO President’s Award of Excellence and the title of APRO Rental Dealer of the Year.

Outside of RTO, Mike enjoys time at the lake house or in Orange Beach, Alabama, with his girlfriend, Angela Strong McCool. A passionate Cincinnati Reds fan, he rarely misses a game, whether watching or listening alongside his parents. He also takes every opportunity to visit Arizona, where his daughter is currently attending Arizona State University.