Association of Professional Rental Organizations (APRO)

From Scrutiny to Standards: The Evolving Landscape of Policy, Perception, & Strategy

The Rent-to-Own Revolution · Closing essay

Skip to endnotes

By the turn of the 1990s, rent-to-own (RTO) found itself operating in a strange kind of visibility. Legislators now knew the model existed, courts had begun wrestling with it, and advocates had strong opinions about it. Yet public understanding remained shallow, shaped more by headlines than by personal experience. As former APRO Board President Michael Bennett of Florida-based Buddy’s Home Furnishings put it, “We had to grow up fast.”¹ The scrutiny wasn’t localized anymore; it was ambient — woven into the background of how policymakers, journalists, and advocacy groups talked about consumer finance.

This scrutiny did not necessarily stem from hostility; much of it came from unfamiliarity. Most policymakers had never visited an RTO store. Many had never seen a rental-purchase agreement. Without context, observers filled gaps with analogies to credit, subprime lending, or installment sales — the wrong framework, but the one everyone had. As Ed Winn explained, “You can’t meet scrutiny with confusion.”² The industry’s challenge was not only to comply with new expectations, but also to articulate its identity clearly at a moment when misunderstanding could calcify into narrative.

Bill Keese saw the shift coming earlier than most. “I told my people: scrutiny doesn’t go away — it just changes shape.”³ The legal battles of the 1980s and 90s had given the RTO industry statutory clarity, but statutes alone did not shape perception. The struggle for understanding would require discipline, consistency, and a cultural shift — one that moved rent-to-own from reactive posturing to professional standard-setting.

Rental dealers felt the shift first. Long before journalists published national exposés, local reporters, attorney-general staffers, and civic groups were asking questions about cost, service, and demographics. Many of those questions were fair, some were based on incomplete information, and others reflected assumptions borrowed from debates about payday lending, pawn, or traditional credit products. As several early operators put it in interviews preserved in the RTO Legends Archive, “If you don’t tell your own story, somebody else will.”⁴

RTO industry leaders — Winn, Chris Korst, Keese, and others — knew the post-statutory era required a different kind of advocacy. This wasn’t about persuading lawmakers to pass a bill. It was about ensuring that the public, regulators, and the media understood what the model actually was. As Korst reflected, “We weren’t dealing with critics; we were dealing with people who didn’t know what box to put us in.”⁵ That ambiguity cut both ways: it created risk, but it also created opportunity. If the industry could articulate its standards clearly and consistently, it could define its terms of engagement for decades to come.

Media Narratives & Public Skepticism

Even after rent-to-own secured legislative recognition across many states, the industry found itself facing a different kind of scrutiny — one that came not from courts or committees, but from the everyday public conversation. This pressure wasn’t rooted in investigative analysis or ideological campaigns. It came from something far simpler: unfamiliarity. Most people — including many journalists, policymakers, and staffers — had never personally entered an RTO store or handled a rental-purchase agreement. They approached the model using frameworks they already understood — credit, installment sales, layaway plans — and the mismatch between those assumptions and the actual mechanics of RTO created confusion that echoed far beyond newsrooms.

For rental dealers, this dynamic was as predictable as it was frustrating. As Lyn Leach later noted, reporters and commentators often arrived with the same baseline misunderstanding: “They kept looking for a payoff amount,” he said, “and I’d tell them, ‘There isn’t one.’”⁶ The repetition of that exchange across different states revealed something deeper than a single misconception — it showed how hard it was to explain a product that didn’t fit the dominant vocabulary of consumer finance.

This wasn’t hostility; it was more often than not the path of least resistance. When a reporter had to summarize rent-to-own for an audience unfamiliar with the model, the “installment-credit shortcut” was an easy narrative — easy to grasp, easy to package, and easy to misapply. But that simplification carried consequences, and put pressure on the industry not only to clarify the transaction, but also to professionalize how it explained itself.

Korst saw this pattern repeatedly. “A misunderstanding in one state became the script for the next,” he recalled.⁷ Even when a news story wasn’t overtly critical, the framing often leaned on analogies that did not match the structure of the model. If weekly payments looked like installments, the public assumed they were. If total-to-own resembled a balance, audiences assumed customers were obligated to reach it. Rent-to-own’s flexibility — its defining feature — was the part most coverage missed, because it had no clear counterpart in traditional credit.

This environment forced the RTO industry to think seriously about communication — not as a defensive act, but as a structural responsibility. As Winn often warned, “If you start from the premise that RTO is credit, you will misunderstand everything that follows.”8 Larry Sutton of Florida-based RNR Tire Express saw the same dynamic in dozens of meetings and hearings. “People don’t come to us because they want debt,” he said. “They come because they need something today, and they know exactly what it will cost them each week.”9 The problem wasn’t ill intent; it was an interpretive framework that obscured the transaction’s actual design.

For many rental dealers, the scrutiny became a catalyst. Bennett described it as a turning point when the industry began “telling the story the way customers lived it — not the way outsiders assumed it worked.”10 This narrative emphasized practical realities: short-term needs, service, the right to return, and the absence of debt. It was not spin; it was simply the part of the story that most public conversations had been missing.

Brad Denison of Texas-based Benefit Marketing Solutions echoed the same theme. Reporters sometimes arrived expecting controversy, but once they saw the day-to-day model, many realized their assumptions didn’t hold. As Denison put it, journalists would “come in looking for a story that wasn’t there,” and the best response was transparency — showing how customers actually used RTO and why the model worked for communities with uncertain income patterns.11

The Association of Progressive Rental Organizations (APRO), watching these interactions unfold, understood a more unified communication strategy was needed. Legislators and journalists were working from incomplete information, and disconnected explanations across stores created opportunities for misunderstanding to spread. That realization led APRO to invest more heavily in member tools, education, and consistent language — an early step toward the standards and structures explored later in this chapter.

The rent-to-own industry did not try to refute every headline or critique. Instead, it learned to meet scrutiny with clarity: simple explanations grounded in actual customer experience. Those conversations became bridges to policy discussions, consumer advocacy dialogues, and ultimately, to the professionalization of the entire sector.

Consumer Advocacy Pressure

By the late 1980s and early 1990s, rent-to-own had become a familiar topic for consumer organizations, legal aid offices, and state attorneys general — though not always for reasons the industry recognized. Many of these groups evaluated RTO through frameworks developed to combat abuses in payday lending, pawn, auto title lending, and subprime credit markets. In that regulatory ecosystem, rent-to-own was often lumped in not because of its structure, but because it served many of the same financially strained households. The result was a persistent — and deeply consequential — category error.

Consumer advocates typically approached the rental-purchase agreement as if it were an installment loan with unusually high effective interest rates. They focused on total cost-to-own and compared it to retail price, assuming that any gap represented a hidden finance charge. That analytic lens was understandable; it was the toolset they used to identify predatory lending. But when applied to RTO, it pushed evaluators toward conclusions that didn’t fit the transaction’s core mechanics.

These assumptions surfaced in hearings again and again. As Korst later explained, advocates and attorneys general often evaluated the model “with the tools of credit — it was the wrong instrument for the job.”12 Many believed customers were locked into long-term obligations. Others assumed reinstatement functioned like a revolving line of credit. And because many of these organizations shared talking points across states, misunderstandings spread quickly.

Winn encountered the same pattern. In meetings with consumer advocates, he would walk line by line through the agreement, starting with the principle that framed everything else: “RTO is not credit.”13 But many of the staffers he met had never seen a lease that could be terminated weekly without penalty. They were used to credit structures, where a customer’s failure to pay escalated obligations rather than extinguish them.

For RTO operators on the ground, these exchanges were more than intellectual disagreements. They shaped real policy proposals that could affect customers and stores across entire states. Leach remembered testifying in a Midwestern hearing where a legal aid attorney insisted customers were “on the hook for the full balance” once they left the store with the merchandise. Leach responded in plain language: they weren’t on the hook for anything — they were leasing, not borrowing.14

Wayland Russell experienced similar debates. In one proceeding, an advocate argued that reinstatement was proof the agreement functioned like credit. Russell explained the opposite: reinstatement was designed so people didn’t lose everything after a missed payment. “It’s how people catch their breath without falling behind,” he told them.15 Lawmakers understood that immediately; advocates, steeped in creditor-debtor frameworks, often did not.

Sometimes the conversations were adversarial, but often they were simply mismatched. Advocates used credit metrics — APR, amortization tables, default triggers — because they had no equivalent metrics for a lease that reset weekly and carried no long-term obligation. In that vacuum, misunderstandings hardened into position papers, testimony packets, and model legislation that mischaracterized the rent-to-own transaction’s nature.

Rental dealers saw the impact firsthand. Bennett recalled participating in a meeting where an attorney-general staffer used a predatory lending checklist to evaluate RTO. Bennett explained that the checklist simply didn’t apply. “People assume we’re selling debt,” he said, “but we’re offering time, flexibility, and service.” 16 Once the staffer understood the role of terminability and the absence of a payoff balance, the tone of the meeting changed. But not every conversation ended that way.

APRO recognized early that these exchanges revealed more than disagreement; they highlighted a structural communication problem. Advocates weren’t ignoring the model; they were mis-framing it. So APRO began creating materials that explained the transaction with a clarity matching its legal structure: a lease, not a loan; terminable; service-inclusive; non-debt; designed for volatility; and governed by its own statutes.

This period marked a turning point. Scrutiny from consumer advocacy groups forced the industry to articulate not only what the model was, but what it was not. It pushed APRO to refine its messaging, strengthened operators’ confidence in explaining the agreement, and laid the groundwork for standards and professionalization.

Industry Standards & Self-Regulation

The pressure the rent-to-own industry faced during the 1980s and 90s did more than force rental dealers to defend the rental-purchase model. It compelled them to clarify who they were, what they stood for, and how they wanted to be understood in the marketplace. This was the period when RTO began shifting from a defensive posture to one grounded in proactive professionalism. The story is often told through statutes and legal battles, but the deeper transformation happened within the industry itself — store by store, operator by operator, and ultimately through APRO’s leadership.

Long before “professional standards” became a formal priority, many dealers had already adopted practices that reflected the spirit of what would become the APRO Code of Ethics. They explained agreements clearly, emphasized service, and treated customers with respect, because they saw themselves as part of their communities. But there was no national framework, no consistent language, and no structure to reinforce best practices across thousands of independently operated stores. Sutton put it bluntly: “If you had ten stores, you probably had ten different ways of explaining the agreement.” 17

APRO recognized that gap early. As the association grew, so did its conviction that the industry needed shared expectations — not only to respond to critics, but to define its own future. The APRO Code of Ethics emerged from that conviction. It was more than a symbolic statement; it represented a collective decision to formalize values that had long existed in practice. The Code emphasized honesty in advertising, accurate disclosures, respectful collections, and a commitment to service that stood at the heart of the rental-purchase model.

Keese described this evolution plainly: “Good operators were already doing the right things — we just helped put a framework around it.” 18 The Code gave language to what operators believed. It also gave RTO a tool to correct practices that were out of alignment with the model’s identity. For the first time, rent-to-own could point to a shared ethical standard — one rooted not in regulatory compliance, but in the profession’s own commitment.

Training matured alongside ethics. In earlier years, much of the industry’s knowledge had been passed along informally: new employees learned from managers; managers learned from owners; and owners relied on experience, intuition, and community norms. But scrutiny revealed the limits of that approach. When operators across different regions explained the agreement differently — or when inconsistent terminology confused customers — those gaps fed negative external narratives about complexity or opacity.

APRO stepped into that space deliberately. The association developed training guides, customer-facing materials, and best-practice recommendations that aligned with its emerging ethical framework. Stores began reviewing disclosures verbally with customers, adopting clearer scripts for explaining reinstatement, and documenting service exchanges. This not only improved customer understanding; it strengthened internal cohesion.

Kevin Quinn of Washington-based KLQ Enterprises noted that the shift “closed the gap between what the industry believed and what customers actually experienced.” 19 Quinn was pointing to a critical insight: professionalism wasn’t about presentation; it was about aligning operational reality with the industry’s core values — flexibility, clarity, service, and dignity.

This movement toward self-regulation also included peer accountability. Dealers who remembered the fragility of the early years understood the stakes. A single poorly run store could reinforce negative narratives across entire states. As scrutiny mounted, operators became more willing to speak openly about quality, identify practices that didn’t align with the model’s values, and support one another in strengthening standards. These candid conversations often happened at APRO events, where workshops and education sessions became forums for shared problem-solving rather than merely information exchange.

Service — the consistently overlooked dimension in public debates — became central to the industry’s internal identity. Leaders like Denison emphasized that service was not a peripheral feature; it was the backbone of the RTO model. When refrigerators failed, when washers leaked, when televisions needed replacement, operators made it right quickly because the agreement made them — not the customer — responsible. Denison’s message was simple but powerful: service was not a cost of doing business; it was the reason customers trusted RTO at all. 20

This professionalizing movement also laid the groundwork for the industry’s later embrace of transparency as a strategic identity. When rental dealers adopted clearer disclosures, reinforced training, and held peers accountable, they weren’t merely complying with statutes — they were creating a base of credibility that matched the values customers experienced in their day-to-day interactions.

By the late 1990s, rent-to-own had become a more cohesive and self-aware profession. The industry was no longer defined by scattered practices across independent operators. It was increasingly unified by a shared ethical framework, strengthened training, and a clearer narrative about what made the model legitimate and necessary.

This evolution didn’t end scrutiny. But it meant RTO could meet scrutiny from a position of strength, grounded in standards of its own making. These standards, in turn, shaped how the industry learned to communicate, turning transparency and consistency into strategic tools rather than obligations.

Turning Critique into Framework

By the mid-1990s, rent-to-own had realized that scrutiny — especially the kind shaped by misunderstandings — was not going away. Legal clarity mattered, but it did not guarantee comprehension. Media explanations helped, but not enough. And consumer advocacy dialogues, even when constructive, demonstrated how easily misclassification could reappear. What RTO needed was not just better arguments; it needed a better framework — a way of presenting itself that would make its core identity unmistakable.

This realization marked a turning point. Instead of responding defensively to criticism, the industry began turning that scrutiny into structure: clearer disclosures, more consistent training, intentional communication strategies, and standardized ways to explain the rental agreement. The transformation was not a rebranding — it was a deeper alignment between what the industry said it was and how customers already experienced it.

Nowhere was this shift more visible than in the realm of disclosure. Hang tags, initially born from legislative compromise, became a defining symbol of the industry’s commitment to transparency. At first, rental dealers saw them as an external requirement — something imposed by lawmakers who wanted to ensure customers had full information. Over time, however, operators recognized that hang tags did more than check a compliance box. They told the story of the transaction plainly: weekly price, cash price, total-to-own, and the absence of long-term obligation. They made the whole agreement intelligible at a glance.

Denison articulated this shift well when he said RTO began “teaching the transaction the way customers actually experienced it.” 21 Clarity wasn’t a regulatory burden — it was a functional truth. Customers who lived paycheck to paycheck understood the weekly price, the ability to return at any time, and the service guarantee. What critics often missed, customers lived every day. Bringing that clarity to disclosures helped fill the gap between perception and reality.

This reframing also changed how the industry trained its teams. Instead of relying on ad hoc explanations, stores began using structured scripts to walk through key terms:

  • the right to return
  • reinstatement and how it protected customers
  • service obligations
  • total-to-own as a transparency tool, not a payoff figure
  • ownership transfer as an option, not an obligation

Dealers understood the more consistently these ideas were explained, the more confident customers felt — and the less room there was for misunderstanding from the outside. Employees who explained the rental agreement with clarity reinforced the RTO model’s legitimacy. Those who did not — often inadvertently — created the very misunderstandings critics relied upon.

Transparency also began shaping relationships with policymakers. When operators could walk into a committee room and show clean, simple disclosures — hang tags, agreement summaries, service records — it changed the tenor of the conversation. Legislators saw the industry was not hiding behind technicalities; it was demonstrating how customers interacted with the transaction in real life. This shift did not eliminate skepticism, but it changed its framework.

Dan Fisher of Pennsylvania-based Majik Rent-to-Own framed the point from the customer’s side: “Most companies in our industry help customers have options, help them get products they couldn’t otherwise have, and give them choices in how to pay for them.”22

Importantly, the strategic shift toward transparency was not driven by a marketing instinct. It was driven by a deeper philosophical recognition: that transparency aligned with who the industry already was. Rental dealers were not granting a new right — they were surfacing one that had always been there. Customers always had the option to return at any time. Reinstatement always existed to keep people from falling behind. Service had always been part of the agreement. Transparency simply made those features visible.

Bennett captured that insight when he observed that embracing transparency helped the industry “stop playing defense and start telling its story.”23 RTO no longer waited for critics to set the terms of debate. The industry took ownership of its narrative — not with slogans, but with clear, consistent information.

This shift also laid the groundwork for modernization. The same instinct that made hang tags a symbol of transparency eventually shaped digital disclosures. As stores moved online, as pricing tools went virtual, and as customer onboarding shifted onto screens, the principles forged in the 1990s guided the transition: clarity, consistency, and respect for how customers actually used the transaction.

By the end of the decade, scrutiny had become a teacher. It pushed rent-to-own to articulate its identity with confidence, align its practices with its principles, and build a customer experience that reflected the dignity and flexibility at the heart of the RTO model. What began as a defensive response matured into a strategic posture — one that positioned the industry not merely to survive scrutiny, but to shape the standards by which it would be judged.

Building Policy Muscle Through APRO

By the late 1990s, rent-to-own had learned, often the hard way, that clarity required not only good statutes and ethical practices, but also a unified, disciplined policy presence capable of sustaining that clarity over time. Scrutiny would recur. Misunderstandings would persist. Legislatures turned over. Staffers cycled in and out. And in that churn, any vacuum of information would quickly fill with old assumptions. APRO emerged as the institution capable of preventing that vacuum.

This role did not develop overnight. In its earliest years, APRO was primarily a legislative organizer — an entity that helped rental dealers mobilize when a policy crisis appeared. But as RTO confronted repeated misinterpretations in statehouses, attorney general offices, and federal committees, APRO began building the internal infrastructure of a true policy organization: staff expertise, coordinated messaging, briefing materials, research capacity, and institutional memory.

Winn provided the foundation. His doctrinal clarity — terminability, no long-term obligation, no debt, merchant ownership, reinstatement rights — gave the industry a stable intellectual core. But principles alone were not enough. They had to be translated into tools and processes that operators could use effectively. APRO created standardized talking points, issue briefs, statutory summaries, and visual aids that helped dealers explain the model in rooms where legislators had minutes, not hours, to grasp its fundamentals. Fisher noted that much of the association’s early work was simply giving operators the language they lacked. “When you explain the agreement clearly,” he said, “most people realize it’s not what they assumed it was.” Winn later noted, “Clarity isn’t just a legal standard — it’s a communication standard.”24 APRO operationalized that insight.

This was also the period when APRO began institutionalizing memory. Rent-to-own had learned through painful experience that every turnover in a legislature meant starting over from zero. So APRO maintained archives of legislation, testimony, legal decisions, and explanatory materials that could be deployed instantly when new bills or misunderstandings arose. Early policy staffers became navigators who understood which arguments resonated in which states, which committees held historical skepticism, and where dealers had built longstanding credibility.

The practical work of advocacy still fell heavily on the dealers themselves. As Korst explained, “Once the industry spoke with one voice, everything changed.”25 Operators became not only witnesses to the model, but also its most effective ambassadors. They explained the agreement in human terms, illustrated reinstatement with real stories, and demonstrated how flexibility mattered in communities where income was episodic. APRO’s job was to prepare rental dealers — to ensure that testimony in Mississippi matched testimony in Oregon, that messaging aligned with statutory definitions, and that every operator walked into a hearing with the confidence that someone had their back.

Keese saw this role as essential. “Policy moved when operators showed up and told the truth about what we do,” he later said.26 APRO helped those operators show up prepared — with structured talking points, coaching, logistical support, and follow-up materials lawmakers could reference after the hearing ended. This coordination was crucial. A hearing rarely resolved an issue on its own; it opened a conversation that had to be reinforced through meetings, letters, case examples, and consistent presence.

Denison, who frequently engaged in legislative efforts during this era, described the change as shifting between “fighting 50 battles and fighting one.”27 The work didn’t become smaller; it became coherent. APRO provided a central organizing force that translated individual stories into collective advocacy. The message was no longer scattered or reactive; it was deliberate, disciplined, and cumulative.

APRO also developed what could be called “policy muscle memory.” After years of facing similar misunderstandings in different states, the organization learned to predict where confusion would arise. Staffers anticipated problematic bill language, prepared preemptive clarifications, and equipped dealers with the materials needed to correct misconceptions early — before they hardened into legislative proposals. In many states, APRO’s approach shifted the dynamic from defense to prevention.

Legislative days became a key component of this strategy. APRO organized coordinated visits to state capitols, ensuring policymakers met not just national representatives, but local operators whose businesses served their communities. These rental dealers were coached on how to tell their stories succinctly, how to frame RTO as a lease, and how to distinguish the RTO model from credit products with completely different risk structures. The presence of delivery managers, service technicians, and long-term store employees added a credibility no written brief could replicate.

This deepened advocacy posture also prepared the industry for federal engagement. When new agencies like the CFPB emerged — with broad mandates and intense early scrutiny — APRO’s infrastructure allowed the industry to present itself clearly, consistently, and confidently. Staffers understood how to articulate the boundaries of the Bureau’s jurisdiction. Dealers demonstrated that rent-to-own served households that traditional credit ignored. And Winn’s doctrinal framing provided a vocabulary regulators could adopt without misunderstanding the transaction’s essence.

What emerged by the early 2000s was something rare: a grassroots movement with professional polish, a national association with local credibility, and an industry that could explain itself to not only its customers, but also lawmakers, regulators, and journalists with equal clarity.

Rent-to-own had learned to carry itself with confidence. The industry no longer waited for critics to define it; it defined itself. And that self-definition — structured, coherent, and grounded in both lived experience and statutory clarity — positioned RTO not merely to survive scrutiny, but to set standards in response to it.

From Target to Standard-Setter

By the end of the 1990s, the rent-to-own industry had traveled a long distance from where it began. What started as a misunderstood, often-dismissed corner of the retail landscape had weathered legal battles, regulatory scrutiny, public misinterpretation, and shifting economic pressures, and had emerged not just intact, but transformed. RTO had grown into a profession. It had moved from reacting to others’ definitions to articulating its own. And at the center of that journey stood APRO, the rental dealers, and the leaders whose clarity and persistence reshaped the model from the inside out.

The scrutiny itself had been a catalyst, forcing the industry to articulate the logic of the rental-purchase agreement in ways that courts, policymakers, and consumers could understand. It revealed the weaknesses of inconsistent communication and uneven practices. And it pushed store operators to embrace standards that matched the dignity and transparency they already knew the model delivered.

The shift was not cosmetic; it was structural. Dealers who had once relied on improvisation in explaining agreements began using clear, unified language. Training matured. Disclosures sharpened. Service was recognized as not just an obligation, but as the heartbeat of the model. The APRO Code of Ethics, once a forward-looking document, became an anchor for the entire industry. And the voices that shaped public understanding were no longer scattered — they became coherent, intentional, and grounded in the lived experiences of the people who knew the transaction best.

The leaders of the era regarded this evolution not as a transition from “informal” to “professional,” but as the industry becoming more fully itself. Operators carried a moral authority that no academic analysis or legislative memo could match. They spoke about real households, real families, real needs, and real moments when flexibility, service, and dignity made a difference in people’s lives.

Korst saw a different dimension of the transformation — how unity changed the industry’s footing in legislative and regulatory arenas. That unity allowed RTO to meet scrutiny not as a fragmented network of stores, but as a cohesive profession. It meant misunderstandings could be corrected quickly, consistently, and persuasively. And it meant lawmakers began to see the model not through the lens of credit and debt, but through the reality of a lease designed for volatility and real life.

Winn’s role highlighted yet another side of the transition. His insistence on doctrinal clarity — terminability, no long-term obligation, reinstatement, merchant ownership — gave the industry a vocabulary that could withstand misinterpretation. RTO learned to treat that line as both a legal principle and a communication strategy.

Alongside industry leaders stood the thousands of rental dealers, managers, and employees who formed the backbone of the movement. Their contributions were not footnotes; they were the story itself. They traveled to hearings. They told their customers’ stories. They opened their stores to critics. They explained reinstatement for the thousandth time. They lived the RTO model, and in doing so, they gave it credibility that no statute or brief could fully capture.

This period also marked a cultural shift. The industry stopped viewing scrutiny as an external threat and began seeing it as a mirror — an opportunity to refine the practices that defined the transaction. Criticism prompted introspection. Questions prompted clarity. Misunderstandings prompted consistency. And over time, scrutiny became the forge in which standards were strengthened rather than merely defended.

By the late 1990s and early 2000s, rent-to-own had become one of the most self-regulated industries in the consumer retail space — not because it lacked statutory guidance, but because it chose to build a culture where professionalism, transparency, and customer understanding carried the highest value. The industry’s internal standards, its policy posture, and its service commitment laid the groundwork for the next era of growth.

The narrative that emerges is not one of survival alone; it is one of identity. Rent-to-own became a sector defined by clarity rather than confusion, by professionalism rather than improvisation, and by standards rather than stereotypes. The scrutiny that once threatened the industry ultimately revealed its strengths and solidified its foundation.

Endnotes

  1. Bennett, Michael. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025.
  2. Winn, Ed. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025.
  3. Keese, Bill. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025.
  4. Multiple Independent Operator Interviews. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025.
  5. Korst, Chris. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025.
  6. Leach, Lyn. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025.
  7. Korst, Chris. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025.
  8. Winn, Ed. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  9. Sutton, Larry. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  10. Bennett, Michael. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  11. Denison, Brad. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  12. Korst, Chris. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  13. Winn, Ed. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  14. Leach, Lyn. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  15. Russell, Wayland. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  16. Bennett, Michael. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  17. Quinn, Kevin. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  18. Keese, Bill. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  19. Quinn, Kevin. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  20. Denison, Brad. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  21. Ibid. ↩
  22. Fisher, Dan. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  23. Bennett, Michael. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  24. Winn, Ed. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  25. Korst, Chris. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  26. Keese, Bill. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
  27. Denison, Brad. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Archive, 2025. ↩
↑ Top

Upcoming Events



Mike Lewis

Mike Lewis is a Premier Rental Purchase franchisee with multiple stores and currently serves as Vice President of Operations. With 33 years of experience in the rent-to-own industry, he has spent the past 20 years working closely with franchisee owners and previously spent 12 years in Corporate RTO, gaining a strong foundation in the business.

For the past five years, Mike has been sharing his knowledge by teaching managers and franchisees at the company’s Training Center.

Outside of work, he enjoys time with his family, kids, and grandkids, and appreciates the simple things in life – especially riding his Harley Davidson with the sun on his face. If you know, you know!

Lauren Talicska

Arona Corporation dba Arona Home Essentials

Lauren Talicska is an experienced multi-channel marketing specialist and the Vice President of Marketing & Communications at Arona Home Essentials. She has found her home in the RTO community, supporting stores in branding, growth, and increasing traffic.

You may recognize Lauren as a former RTO vendor, including her time as a partner for Nationwide RentDirect, or her previous participation in the APRO Vendor Advisory Committee. Lauren calls Columbus, Ohio, home and spends her workday crafting and executing marketing promotions from inception to realization, all while supporting the branding and social media needs of all the Arona stores in 12 states (plus Puerto Rico!).

Charles Smitherman

APRO

Charles Smitherman, JD, PhD, CAE, became CEO of APRO in 2023, bringing years of legal and executive experience in the rent-to-own industry. 

Prior to joining the association, Charles served as COO, General Counsel, and Vice President of PTS Financial Services, where he played an active role in the rent-to-own industry by representing his company through PTS’s club program offering with APRO member dealers. Charles is an attorney with two decades of experience across a wide variety of areas, including RTO, consumer financial services, antitrust, corporate law, mergers and acquisitions, litigation, franchise law, and privacy law. Following law school at the University of Georgia, Charles earned a Master of Legal Studies and PhD in Law from the University of Oxford in England.

Charles is credentialed as a Certified Association Executive (CAE) with the American Society of Association Executives, a Certified Franchise Executive (CFE) with the International Franchise Association, and a Certified Information Privacy Professional (CIPP/US) and Certified Information Privacy Manager (CIPM) through the International Association of Privacy Professionals. As APRO’s sixth CEO in its 45-year history, he brings a collaborative, member-focused approach to association leadership, emphasizing transparency, advocacy, and value creation. Outside of work, Charles is an active ultra runner and open water swimmer.

Mike Kays

Ashley Furniture Industries

As VP of Rental Sales for Ashley Furniture Industries, Mike thrives on building relationships with our RTO industry veterans, and helping businesses grow through new product, new marketing, and new supply chain options.

Mike works to leverage a wide breadth of relationships and influence, intimate knowledge of market trends, and unique knowledge of what RTO dealers need from a supplier to be successful.

The saying goes that a high tide raises all boats, and our goal is to leverage the world’s largest furniture manufacturer to drive the continued growth of the RTO industry and all the suppliers.

Mike Tissot

Countryside Rentals Inc., dba Rent-2-Own

Mike grew up in the rent-to-own industry under the guidance of his father, former APRO President and RTO legend Darrell Tissot. For nearly 25 years, Mike’s innovative leadership has helped expand the family business to more than 40 stores across Ohio and Kentucky while also shaping the industry as a whole.

He has served as President of the Ohio Rental Dealers Association, an APRO board member and Treasurer, and President and Treasurer of the TRIB Group. His contributions have earned him the APRO President’s Award of Excellence and the title of APRO Rental Dealer of the Year.

Outside of RTO, Mike enjoys time at the lake house or in Orange Beach, Alabama, with his girlfriend, Angela Strong McCool. A passionate Cincinnati Reds fan, he rarely misses a game, whether watching or listening alongside his parents. He also takes every opportunity to visit Arizona, where his daughter is currently attending Arizona State University.