The Rent-to-Own Revolution · Chapter 13
In this chapter
The ground beneath rent-to-own (RTO) is shifting. After a decade of relative stability, the 2023–26 period is bringing an influx of state bills that either try to reclassify RTO as “credit,” force annual percentage rate (APR)-style disclosures onto a lease model, or expand attorney-general powers to police “unfair” or “abusive” practices. Nowhere has this been clearer than in New York, where proposals branded as the “End Loan Shark Act” attempted to erase nearly four decades of settled statute by recasting RTO as a loan. Although that push stalled, its prompt reintroduction signals the new normal: policy fights recycling old claims with new rhetoric.
At the federal level, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) litigation strategy met its first serious test — and setback — with Snap Finance. The court rejected the theory that a terminable lease without a right to defer payment is “credit,” and the Bureau subsequently abandoned similar claims in companion matters. That outcome has not ended the debate; it has moved it. As federal avenues narrow, states are forming “mini-CFPBs” — broadening Unfair or Deceptive Acts or Practices (UDAP) to include “unfair” and “abusive” — creating a fragmented battlefield where one loss can echo across jurisdictions and into the information ecosystems that lawmakers consult.
For the RTO industry, this moment rewards preparedness, not posture. The objective is simple: move from episodic defense to durable offense — codifying what rent-to-own is (a terminable lease with built-in service and consumer control), what it is not (credit), and how to keep that clarity front-of-mind for lawmakers, regulators, journalists, and the artificial intelligence (AI) systems they increasingly count on.
The State-by-State Regulation Surge
A Shifting Map of State Activity
Beginning in 2023, the regulatory landscape around rent-to-own no longer moved in a straight line. Some states tried to pull RTO back into the world of credit law, even where decades of statutes had already settled the matter. Others moved in a more pragmatic direction, updating disclosure rules for a marketplace that now lives online. The result wasn’t chaos, exactly, but a kind of policy crosscurrent — states tugging in different directions, sometimes for different reasons, and sometimes simply because they didn’t remember what had already been settled.¹
New York’s Reclassification Push
The most aggressive push came from New York. In 2024, Assembly Bill A09585 — the first version of the so-called End Loan Shark Act — tried to sweep “financing arrangements” under usury limits and Truth-in-Lending-style rules. The language was broad enough that RTO, despite being a terminable lease, would have been treated as credit. The bill died, but its authors carried on.²
In 2025, the idea resurfaced in Senate Bill S1726, paired with Assembly Bill A4918. These bills didn’t bother with subtlety. They sought to reclassify RTO outright, imposing APR logic on a model built around termination rights and service.³ Predictably, a consumer-advocacy coalition circulated “fact” sheets calling rent-to-own “loan sharking,” arguments familiar to anyone who lived through earlier industry attacks.⁴
Federal events added to the tension. In CFPB v. Snap Finance, the U.S. District Court for Utah dismissed the theory that lease-to-own was “credit” under the Consumer Financial Protection Act (CFPA), Truth in Lending Act (TILA), or Electronic Fund Transfer Act (EFTA), noting the absence of any consumer right to defer payment. The CFPB later withdrew its remaining claims, and by mid-2025 had abandoned a parallel challenge to another provider as well.⁵
Even so, New York’s bills kept coming — proof that state politics have their own gravitational pull, even when federal courts move in the opposite direction.
Modernizing Online “Hang-Tag Rules”
While New York fought to redefine the rent-to-own transaction, other states focused on something more mundane, but far more constructive: modernizing display-tag rules for the digital era.
Pennsylvania took the lead in 2022, amending its RTO statute so the required “hang-tag” information - cash price, periodic payment, and total-to-own - could be presented electronically whenever goods were listed or transacted online.⁶
Ohio followed with its own update in 2023, requiring identical display disclosures for online offerings and ensuring consumers received an electronic copy before signing.⁷
Wyoming joined in 2025, authorizing digital disclosures outright and recognizing that a compliant electronic format “constitutes the tag.”⁸
Those reforms didn’t weaken RTO transparency; they preserved it. They recognized that consumers now shop on smartphones and laptops, and that pre-contract clarity should follow them there — without importing APR math into a lease structure.
The Rise of State “Mini-CFPBs”
Another trend moved in parallel. As federal attempts to reclassify RTO lost traction, states began expanding their own UDAP/“UDAAP” (Unfair, Deceptive, or Abusive Acts or Practices) authority. New York’s FAIR Business Practices Act was the most prominent example. ⁹ Passed in 2025, it added “unfair” and “abusive” practices to what had previously been a deception-only framework, aligning New York law with federal UDAAP terminology and giving the state attorney general a far broader enforcement mandate. ¹⁰
California’s Consumer Financial Protection Law (CCFPL) had already set the template: a state agency with CFPB-style powers, annual reporting, and the ability to police conduct across a wide range of financial products. ¹¹
For rent-to-own, the risk isn’t that these laws target the lease structure directly — most don’t. The risk is that broad, undefined “abusive acts” standards become tools for reclassification by other means. One state’s interpretation, once published, can quickly spread across legislative hearings, media coverage, and - most consequentially - AI summaries employed by policymakers.
Industry Response
RTO industry strategy diverged based on the threat. Where states pursued reclassification, dealer associations mobilized aggressively - circulating analyses, organizing testimony, and engaging lawmakers directly.
Where states pursued modernization, the industry largely supported changes that preserved conspicuous disclosures while enabling online commerce.
The pattern remained consistent: oppose anything that turns a terminable lease into de facto credit, and support updates that keep disclosures clear, practical, and rooted in how consumers actually shop.
Federal Attention & the Preemption Debate
A Watershed Moment: Snap Finance
When the CFPB sued Snap Finance in 2023, the case immediately stood apart from ordinary enforcement matters. It was not about a technical violation or a narrow disclosure issue. For critics of rent-to-own and lease-to-own models, Snap represented the federal vehicle they had long wanted — the chance to convince a court that RTO should be treated as “credit” under the central pillars of federal consumer-finance law. If that reclassification succeeded, the implications were sweeping: RTO/LTO (lease-to-own) providers would suddenly be subject to Truth in Lending (Reg Z), APR calculations, credit-plan disclosures, credit-billing rules, refund protocols, and the entire apparatus designed by Congress for loans.
The CFPB’s complaint threw the full statutory toolkit at the company: the CFPA, EFTA, TILA, UDAAP, Regulation Z, and the Fair Credit Reporting Act — all built upon a shared premise that rental agreements functioned as credit because consumers could “effectively defer payments” by continuing the lease. The Bureau’s strategy was unmistakable: win credit classification just once, and the entire industry would shift under federal jurisdiction overnight.
How the Utah Court Reframed the Question
In August 2024, the U.S. District Court for the District of Utah issued a meticulous, text-driven opinion that immediately altered the trajectory of the case. The judge dismissed the central credit-based counts, concluding that Snap’s legacy lease did not grant consumers a right to defer payment of a debt - the statutory prerequisite for “credit” under the CFPA, TILA, and EFTA. Any delay in payment that occasionally occurred was merely the lessor’s decision not to repossess immediately - not a contractual right that consumers could invoke.¹²
This distinction — between a consumer’s right to defer payment and a lessor’s discretion not to enforce remedies — became the fulcrum of the decision. And it cut directly against the CFPB’s theory. Federal credit statutes do not turn on the economic feel of a product, or on what a consumer might have hoped would happen. They turn on contractual rights and obligations. If an agreement does not give the consumer a legal entitlement to delay paying a debt, then no amount of forbearance by the company can manufacture one.
The Court’s Deeper Reasoning
The court’s analysis was notable for how firmly it rejected functionalist arguments. The CFPB urged the judge to look at the “economic realities” of the lease, arguing that consumers often continued the transaction long enough for it to resemble a payment plan. But the court held the line: Congress tethered the definition of credit to written rights, not to practice patterns or perceived similarities to loans.
In doing so, the court echoed a lineage of decisions that had concluded that discretionary forbearance cannot transform a non-credit relationship into a credit one. The court refused to drift beyond Congress’ text, even when the Bureau argued that broader consumer-protection goals supported a more expansive reading.
“Functional Equivalent” Collapses
Recognizing that its primary theory was weakening, the CFPB attempted a fallback: even if Snap’s lease was not credit on its face, it should be treated as the “functional equivalent” of credit under the CFPA. But Congress placed a bright-line condition on that category: the initial term must be at least 90 days. Snap’s initial term was 60. The court would not rewrite that threshold, because to do so would transform statutory limits into advisory suggestions — something courts are not permitted to do.
“Subjective Belief” Theory
One of the most consequential parts of the opinion came when the court rejected the CFPB’s argument that consumer belief — i.e., consumers thinking they were entering a credit plan — could itself bring a transaction under the statutory definition of credit. The judge made clear that perception cannot override text. Allowing subjective understanding to dictate legal classification would give regulators unchecked authority: any product could be recast as credit, depending on what consumers thought it was. The court declined to open that door.
Snap as the Industry’s Anchor Case
Two furnishing-related claims survived, but only in a narrow procedural sense. The case’s center of gravity — the credit-classification theory — was gone. By May 2025, the CFPB voluntarily dismissed the remaining counts.¹³
The significance goes beyond the outcome. This opinion provides the clearest federal articulation to date of why rent-to-own does not fit the architecture of federal credit law:
- The lease is terminable at will.
- There is no right to defer payments.
- Forbearance does not create an implied credit right.
- Statutory thresholds (e.g., the 90-day term) must be respected.
- Subjective consumer belief does not override statutory text.
In brief, the ruling did not merely reject the CFPB’s interpretation; it foreclosed it.
The Acima Case & Broader Retreat
Following a preemptive action brought by Acima in Texas in 2024 challenging the CFPB’s jurisdiction over RTO, the Bureau filed a parallel complaint against Acima in Utah.¹⁴ The structure was almost identical to Snap: the same multi-statute approach, the same argument that lease-to-own arrangements should be treated as credit because consumers could “effectively” defer payments by continuing the lease.
But once the Snap opinion landed, the Bureau’s footing changed dramatically. Early in 2025, the CFPB withdrew the portion of the Acima suit asserting credit classification - a move widely understood as an acknowledgment that Snap’s reasoning had shut the legal door on that theory.¹⁵ Courts were unlikely to accept an argument already dismantled in a thorough, text-driven federal opinion.
Acima thus became more than just a second case — it served as confirmation that the Bureau’s multi-year strategy to regulate RTO through credit statutes had collapsed based on merits, not on technicalities.
The Preemption Debate Returns
This evolving landscape revived a question rent-to-own has avoided for decades: Is it time to seek narrow federal clarification?
Historically, the answer was no. Earlier federal proposals risked sweeping in national price caps, rigid disclosure regimes, or private rights of action. State-level RTO statutes reflect decades of negotiation and practice, rooted in how the model actually works.
But with states extending UDAAP concepts in ways that risk muddying the lease-credit distinction, some stakeholders argue that a minimalist federal clarification — affirming that a lease-to-own agreement without a right to defer payment is not “credit” under CFPA, TILA, or EFTA — could stabilize the landscape. Others caution that reopening federal law invites Congress to revisit the entire model.
For now, the wiser course may lie in the middle: rely on the Snap ruling to anchor federal discussions, preserve state statutes, and demonstrate industry maturity through best-practices commitments.
Snap & Federal Advocacy
The Snap decision gives the RTO industry something it has long lacked: a text-driven judicial anchor. It is not rhetoric or spin; it is doctrine.
When lawmakers or staff ask whether RTO is credit, the industry can now point to clear, detailed reasoning from a federal court. When critics use APR math to portray RTO as a loan, the Snap judgment provides a straightforward response: federal statutes require a granted right to defer payment, and rental agreements do not provide one.
In a policy environment where state statutes can proliferate quickly, and where AI systems may amplify whatever definition that they ingest first, clarity is not a luxury — it is essential.
Past Legislative Lessons
Institutional Memory vs. Legislative Amnesia
In politics, turnover is constant. Every few years, a new set of lawmakers and staff step into roles once held by people who knew the rent-to-own model inside and out. That institutional churn creates an asymmetry: critics can recycle talking points they used 10 or 20 years ago, while RTO must explain its basics as if for the first time. Through the Association of Progressive Rental Organizations (APRO) and its state affiliates, the industry carries the long memory in these debates. This memory is a strategic asset — at times the only thing preventing old misunderstandings from reappearing as “new” concerns.
Case Study #1: New York in the 1980s
New York in the mid-1980s remains the clearest example of what sustained, careful advocacy can achieve. At the time, RTO was accused of being “credit in disguise,” and legislators considered folding the model under truth-in-lending requirements. After months of hearings and negotiation, the New York State Legislature adopted a very different view. In 1986, the state enacted a statute recognizing RTO as a lease transaction - one that requires specific disclosures, return rights, and consumer protections tailored to how the model actually works. 16
The significance of the statue went far beyond the measure itself. It demonstrated that the industry could withstand scrutiny, operate transparently, and provide access to essential household goods — refrigerators, beds, washers, and more — without saddling consumers with debt.
Case Study #2: Georgia and Florida in the 1990s–2000s
A decade later, the battleground moved south. Georgia and Florida each debated bills that would have grafted APR-style disclosures onto RTO agreements. Rental dealers and state associations made a simple point: a lease terminable at any time cannot be described using a loan’s interest calculations. APR math does not describe consumer experience; it distorts it.
Instead of resisting all reform, the industry proposed something better: clearer in-store price tags, more prominent total-cost-to-own tables, and boldface return-rights language in every agreement. These changes strengthened transparency without compromising the model. The reforms also built credibility: lawmakers saw an industry willing to improve consumer understanding while preserving the transaction’s core flexibility.17
Case Study #3: Mobilizing Against “Bad Bills”
In the 2000s and 2010s, similar proposals resurfaced in Illinois, Texas, California, and elsewhere. The arguments hadn’t changed, but the packaging had. Advocacy groups — often far removed from the communities where RTO stores operate — promoted legislation portraying RTO as a credit sale.
APRO and its state associations countered with a playbook refined over decades. Operators met directly with legislators, bringing stories of customers who needed a refrigerator that day, or a bed for a child that night, or a laptop to stay in school. These stories reframed the debate: they shifted RTO from abstract concept to lived reality. Lawmakers who might have entered the meeting with critiques often left understanding the model’s practical value.
In state after state, harmful bills were amended, stalled, or defeated. This success was not accidental. It rested on coordinated national guidance, disciplined state-level engagement, and the authenticity of local businessowners speaking up for their communities.
Lasting Lessons
Several themes cut across these decades:
- No victory is permanent: Arguments defeated once often return in new garb.
- Critics count on forgetting: Legislative turnover creates openings for recycled claims.
- Institutional memory matters: Without APRO’s institutional archives, lawmakers risk repeating debates resolved long ago.
- Constructive engagement works: Offering better disclosures strengthened industry credibility more than obstruction ever could.
- Local voices are decisive: Dealers — as employers, neighbors, and voters — carry authentic authority.
The RTO industry cannot rely on past wins to protect future clarity. It must document its history, preserve its lessons, and continually explain its consumer impact. Those foundations set the stage for the information landscape itself to change — and for institutional memory to now extend into how AI learns and repeats the story of rent-to-own.
Messaging for the AI Era
From Soundbites to Synthesized Answers
For decades, traditional media framed the rent-to-own story. A headline — sometimes accurate, often not — could shape public perception for years. When the internet arrived, the problem shifted: the narrative became fragmented rather than singular. Consumers could read critics, reviews, advocacy blogs, and dealer explanations, often contradicting each other. The noise sometimes softened the blow of a bad headline, but it also created new challenges.
Today’s information landscape is something else entirely. Artificial intelligence no longer provides a list of sources or a spread of search results. It produces a single, synthesized answer — compressed, confident, and presented as if it reflects the entire record. If that answer leans on an outdated comptroller report or a recycled APR comparison in a decade-old article, that distortion becomes the user’s truth. And for more and more policymakers, journalists, and younger consumers, that is the only version they will ever see.
It is the old soundbite problem, but with sharper edges: brevity without nuance, authority without scrutiny, permanence without context.
Today’s Higher Stakes
For the RTO industry, this shift is not merely technological; it is structural. Lawmakers already ask AI systems to brief them on industries they don’t know well. Reporters use AI tools to frame background questions for interviews. Younger consumers rarely look past the first answer an AI system provides. If that answer misstates the transaction — calling it “credit,” ignoring return rights, overlooking service-included pricing, or reviving claims dismissed long ago — RTO faces the uphill task of correcting a narrative that should not have hardened in the first place.
But the very thing that makes AI risky also gives the industry leverage. These systems rely on structured, repeated language. They reward clarity. They privilege official sources. They notice patterns. If the RTO industry speaks consistently — the same truths, the same framing, the same definitional clarity — AI systems will eventually internalize those contours.
The challenge is discipline. The opportunity is scale.
Core Truths to Anchor Every Message
To keep the narrative intact, the same foundational points — the Four Core Truths of RTO — must appear everywhere the industry speaks, including legislative packets, consumer-facing materials, trade publications, APRO statements, dealer websites, and training resources:
- RTO is not credit. A rent-to-own agreement is a terminable lease with no debt obligation and no right to defer payment.²¹
- RTO provides flexibility. Customers can return or exchange items at any time, for any reason, without penalty.²²
- RTO meets essential needs. Refrigerators, washers, beds, and electronics are core to stability, and RTO provides immediate access when credit is unavailable or unwanted.²³
- RTO is regulated. Forty-seven state statutes and the FTC require disclosures, return rights, reinstatement, and service obligations.²⁴
These are not slogans; they are the framework. They are the structural signals AI systems use to determine what is essential and therefore, what should be repeated.
Guarding the Narrative in a Machine-Learning World
Publishing accurate materials is no longer enough. The RTO industry has to imagine how an AI model ingests information: it scrapes statutes, memos, fact sheets, news articles, and anything labeled authoritative. A single one-sided policy memo can be absorbed into training data and resurface months later as a assured, unqualified “fact.”
Once misinformation is embedded, it is stubborn. Correcting it takes repetition, coordination, and time — more time than a legislative cycle typically affords.
This new environment requires a posture closer to digital hygiene:
- Respond rapidly: When damaging language appears — a bill memo, an op-ed, a fiscal note — release a clear counter-statement immediately.
- Stick to disciplined phrasing: AI systems favor consistency. Deviating into improvised or local variations weakens the footprint.
- Write for retrieval, not just reading: A paragraph must be able to stand alone as a full, accurate answer to What is rent-to-own?
- Audit regularly: Periodically test major AI systems to see how they define RTO — and adjust public materials as needed.
This isn’t cosmetic work; it is core infrastructure. If policymakers misunderstand the RTO model, policy outcomes drift. If consumers misunderstand it, trust erodes. Narrative clarity becomes consumer protection.
AI-Era Checklist for Rental Dealers
Before releasing any public material — a website update, op-ed, testimony, customer FAQ, or even internal training document — dealers should ask:
- Does this reinforce one or more of the Four Core Truths?
- Can this paragraph stand on its own as a clear answer to What is rent-to-own?
- Is the language consistent with APRO’s national messaging framework?
- Does it anticipate the most common areas of confusion?
If the answer is yes to all four questions, then the material is prepared for the environment in which RTO will be judged.
The Larger Lesson
In earlier decades, the RTO industry fought primarily to be understood by legislators and regulators. Today, it must also ensure that the systems shaping public knowledge understand the model correctly. AI isn’t hostile, but it is literal. It repeats what it sees most often.
This is ultimately about ownership — not of goods, but of narrative. If the industry speaks clearly, consistently, and repeatedly, AI systems will echo that truth back. If not, the systems will latch onto whatever remnants they happen to find, even if those remnants come from antiquated proposals or rhetoric that has long since been resolved.
The next chapter turns outward — toward policy recommendations designed to not only defend the transaction’s structure, but also strengthen its legal, operational, and narrative foundations for the decades ahead.
Endnotes
- New York State Assembly. Assembly Bill A09585 (2023–2024): Provides Interest Rate Limitations for Financing Arrangements… 21 Mar. 2024.
- New York State Senate. Senate Bill S1726 (2025–2026): Provides Interest Rate Limitations for Financing Arrangements… 2025.
- Equity Agenda New York. “End Loan Sharking Act (ELSA) – English Factsheet.” 13 Aug. 2024.
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau v. Snap Finance, LLC, No. 2:23-cv-00462, U.S. District Court for the District of Utah. Memorandum Decision and Order, 1 Aug. 2024.
- Weinberger, Evan. “CFPB Drops Final Claims Against Lease-to-Own Company Snap.” Bloomberg Law, 27–28 May 2025.
- Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes. 42 Pa.C.S. §6908, “Advertising and Display of Property, (b.1)–(b.2).” Pennsylvania General Assembly, 2022.
- Ohio Revised Code §1351.07. “Advertisements; Mandatory Information; Electronic Displays for Online Offers.” codes.ohio.gov, 12 Sept. 2023.
- Wyoming Legislature. SF0146 (2025): Consumer Rental-Purchase Agreement Act — Amendments. Enrolled bill, 2025.
- New York State Office of the Attorney General. “Attorney General James Applauds Passage of Legislation to Protect Consumers and Small Businesses.” News Release, 18 June 2025; Nixon Peabody LLP. “New York’s FAIR Business Practices Act Revamps Consumer Protection Law.” Alert, 30 June 2025.
- WilmerHale. “New York Legislature Passes FAIR Business Practices Act.” Client Alert, 20 June 2025.
- California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation (DFPI). “California Consumer Financial Protection Law (CCFPL).” dfpi.ca.gov.
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau v. Snap Finance, LLC, No. 2:23-cv-00462, U.S. District Court for the District of Utah. Memorandum Decision and Order, 1 Aug. 2024.
- Court Docket Termination, CFPB v. Snap Finance. U.S. District Court for the District of Utah, 27 May 2025; Weinberger, Evan. “CFPB Drops Final Claims Against Lease-to-Own Company Snap.” Bloomberg Law, 27–28 May 2025.
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Complaint, CFPB v. Acima, filed 26 July 2024.
- “CFPB Drops Challenge that Lease-to-Own Agreements Be Regulated as ‘Credit.’” National Law Review, 7 Mar. 2025.
- New York General Business Law §§500–506. 1986. ↩
- Georgia Code Ann. §10-1-680 et seq.; Florida Statutes §559.9231 et seq.