Association of Professional Rental Organizations (APRO)

Buying Groups: Power in Numbers

Skip to endnotes

For independent rent-to-own (RTO) dealers, scale has always been both the dream and the dragon. National chains negotiate national prices; independents negotiate one invoice at a time. Buying groups emerged as the RTO industry’s counterweight — grassroots coalitions that pooled demand, standardized negotiations, and redistributed leverage back to the small operators who form the core of the sector. In the 1980s, as the Association of Progressive Rental Organizations (APRO) organized a voice for advocacy, The Rental Industry Buying (TRIB) Group organized a wallet for commerce. That dual architecture — APRO for policy and public affairs; TRIB for purchasing and operational muscle — helped stabilize a fragmented marketplace, letting single-store and regional operators compete on price, access, and professionalism.¹

Buying groups are not a footnote in RTO history; they are one of its engines. They demonstrate how small businesses create scale through cooperation, how market norms become community standards, and how a scattered retail landscape can organize itself — ethically and efficiently — without surrendering independence. In that sense, TRIB and Nationwide Marketing Group’s RentDirect function much like agricultural co-ops or hardware buying alliances: economic democracy translated into better terms, better tools, and better odds.2

The Challenge of Scale

From the earliest days of modern rent-to-own, independent operators chased a paradox: they wanted to remain nimble, creative, and locally responsive — but they also needed the leverage of large-scale procurement to survive. National chains like Rent-A-Center or Aaron’s could aggregate millions of dollars in orders, negotiate favorable vendor terms, and absorb the overhead of logistics, marketing, and finance. A single mom-and-pop shop, by contrast, faced vendor price sheets, freight surcharges, and credit-term denials that threatened to turn its profit margins into risk margins.

Unequal negotiating footing

At the core of the scale problem is asymmetric bargaining power. When major appliance manufacturers or national furniture brands looked at volume, they prioritized big accounts — those that committed to minimum annual spend, multiple storerooms, and national distribution reach. Those accounts got preferred pricing, exclusive SKUs, longer payment terms, and marketing funds, while smaller accounts got leftovers — if they got served at all. Independents tried to compete directly with chains, but they were structurally disadvantaged. Their orders might be limited to a few units per month, they lacked centralized logistics, and they couldn’t promise consistent volume. That meant higher per-unit costs, poorer terms, and restricted assortments.

This dynamic is familiar across retail sectors — independent hardware stores versus Home Depot, small local grocers versus regional chains. But in RTO, the stakes were even higher because service costs (delivery, maintenance, swaps) consumed what little margin remained.

The cost penalty wasn’t just in procurement pricing. Independents absorbed freight and logistics burdens, financing strain, administrative overhead, and a lack of access to vendor-funded marketing dollars. All of these eroded margins and constrained growth.

Risk in Isolation

Despite ingenuity and persistence, independent rental dealers faced ongoing vulnerabilities: pricing wars they couldn’t sustain, inventory stagnation, vendor abandonment, exclusion from early product innovations, and the loss of institutional knowledge in operational silos. Small disruptions — shipping delays, parts shortages, misaligned promotions — could wipe out annual margins, and in severe cases, force operators to sell or close.

The Aggregation Imperative

Given these pressures, independents faced three choices: sell out or merge, niche down, or aggregate. The emergence of TRIB Group in the 1980s offered another path: pooled volume. TRIB centralized vendor contracts, rebates, exclusive SKUs, logistic efficiencies, and promotional support — allowing independent dealers to compete on near-equal footing with national chains.3

This founding logic remains the foundation of buying groups today: the leverage of many small operators equaling one large one — without surrendering autonomy.

From John Cleek, Jr.’s vantage point at Missouri-based Cleek’s Home Furnishings, TRIB worked because it respected that autonomy. Participation did not erase local judgment or impose a centralized playbook. “TRIB didn’t run my store,” Cleek explained. “It made it possible for my store to compete.” That distinction preserved the entrepreneurial character of independent rent-to-own while offering the economic advantages of collective action.4

The Birth of TRIB

The 1980s: Searching for Leverage

When the rent-to-own industry began taking shape in the late 1970s and early 1980s, the field was wild territory — fast-growing, entrepreneurial, and uncoordinated. Independent rental dealers popped up in every region of the United States, often started by former installment retailers or furniture store owners who saw the potential of flexible, no-credit transactions. Yet as national players like Rent-A-Center and ColorTyme expanded through aggressive franchising, independents soon realized the game board was tilting.

The chain stores had something that the independent operators didn’t: scale. They negotiated national vendor programs with Whirlpool, RCA, or Ashley; they financed bulk orders through corporate credit lines; and they invested heavily in marketing. Independents, meanwhile, struggled to get the same product lines or favorable pricing. The gap wasn’t about skill or service — it was structural.5

In that climate, a group of forward-thinking dealers began meeting informally at APRO gatherings and tradeshows, asking a simple question: Could smaller operators join forces without surrendering independence? The answer would become one of the industry’s most durable institutions — TRIB Group.

The Founding Moment

TRIB was officially formed in 1983, just a few years after APRO’s founding. Its founders included a handful of well-known independent rental dealers from across the country who believed they could negotiate better deals together rather than separately. Dennis Shields, who would become one of TRIB’s defining voices, later reflected that “the group was built on friendship first, business second,” underscoring that trust among competitors was the essential precondition for cooperation.6 John Blair — who became TRIB’s first executive director — later noted that when he started, “We had only 17 members,” a reminder that early credibility had to be built from almost nothing.7

The early TRIB model mirrored agricultural cooperatives and local buying clubs: members paid dues, pooled commitments, and authorized the group to negotiate with manufacturers on their behalf. Unlike a franchise, TRIB never dictated how a store operated or branded itself. Its purpose was strictly collective leverage — to reduce costs and expand access to inventory, financing, and expertise.8

The timing couldn’t have been better. The early 1980s were an inflection point for the RTO sector. Interest rates were high, consumer credit was tight, and small retailers needed a mechanism to manage risk and maintain margins. By banding together, independents could finally meet minimum order thresholds and gain pricing parity with the big chains.

Camaraderie & Collaboration

TRIB’s founding charter articulated a deceptively simple mission: to strengthen the position of the independent rent-to-own dealer through collective buying and shared knowledge. But beneath that mission was a cultural shift. In an industry often characterized as competitive to the bone, TRIB introduced a cooperative ethos — a belief that independents could be both rivals and allies.

The group’s founders insisted the organization never become purely transactional. Vendor contracts mattered, but so did camaraderie. TRIB meetings quickly evolved into social as well as strategic gatherings. Members traded war stories, compared software systems, and shared operational tricks — what kind of flooring lasted longer in a high-traffic showroom, how to refurbish returns more efficiently, how to coach drivers who were also collectors.

This community spirit became TRIB’s distinguishing feature. It transformed buying power into learning power. Over time, TRIB’s annual Meeting of the Minds event would embody that culture: part tradeshow, part reunion, part bootcamp in RTO excellence.9

Early Validation & Credibility

Within its first few years, TRIB proved its concept. By negotiating group programs with major manufacturers, the group allowed independent dealers to approach vendor tables with the collective weight of hundreds of stores. For the first time, small operators could secure the same price tiers, dating, and marketing support once reserved for national chains.10

Blair recalled the first convention he ran: “I charged like $425 a booth… I had like 30 vendors come — and we only had 17 members… Vendors were very upset.” The lesson was immediate: the group had to convert vendor interest into dealer follow-through to earn durable terms.11

Leadership discipline anchored that credibility. Under the guidance of Executive Director Blair and his successor, Shields, TRIB Group built transparent governance, vendor-selection processes, and event programming that balanced rigor with accessibility. Shields often said, “We’re not just getting better prices; we’re getting better together.”23

Parallel Growth with APRO

The birth of TRIB paralleled — and complemented — APRO’s rise as the industry’s advocacy arm. While APRO fought legislative battles in state capitols and Washington, D.C., TRIB fought for better vendor contracts and operational efficiency. The two organizations often shared members, board leaders, and conference calendars, while serving distinct missions: APRO safeguarded the industry’s legitimacy; TRIB Group fortified its competitiveness.

That dual infrastructure proved crucial. APRO educated policymakers and the public on the fairness and regulation of RTO; TRIB ensured rental dealers could deliver quality products at sustainable prices. In effect, APRO told the industry’s story while TRIB ensured there was an industry to tell it.

The Spirit of Mutuality

At its core, TRIB’s founding reflected a deeper moral philosophy: mutual aid. The RTO business model itself is built on helping customers achieve ownership through flexible pathways; TRIB applied the same principle internally, helping dealers achieve sustainability through cooperation.13

For dealers who often saw themselves as local heroes — serving working families others overlooked — TRIB offered reassurance they were not alone. They were part of a larger movement that valued dignity, fairness, and economic solidarity.

Yet the true power of TRIB’s collaboration wasn’t confined to balance sheets or vendor lists; it changed what independence meant. By pooling strength, members gained access to product lines once out of reach — furniture, bedding, and appliances that transformed the RTO store from an electronics outlet into a full-line home goods provider.

Broadening the Portfolio

In the early years, rent-to-own stores were essentially electronics shops with payment flexibility. Through most of the 1970s and early 1980s, it wasn’t unusual for a single store’s merchandise mix to be 70% electronics. Televisions, stereo systems, and VCRs dominated display floors because those were the items people wanted, and the ones rental dealers could reliably acquire. Electronics were compact, fast-turning, and easy to deliver, which made sense for smaller operators.

It worked — until it didn’t. Electronics depreciated quickly, repossessions were common, and the race to keep current models in stock drained cash. By the mid-1980s, prices on consumer electronics fell, models changed faster than most dealers could keep up with, and national chains were squeezing margins with bigger buying power. Stores that had built their whole identity around screens were suddenly standing on a shrinking island.

Furniture and appliances offered the opposite profile: slower depreciation, longer agreements, and goods that tended to stay put. The problem was access. Independents couldn’t hit the minimum orders that furniture and appliance manufacturers required. TRIB’s pooled commitments knocked down that barrier, giving independents a seat at tables that had been unavailable to them.29

For operators like the Tissots with Rent-2-Own in Ohio, buying groups were not about chasing scale for its own sake; they were about survival without surrender. TRIB offered a way to remain independent while no longer being isolated. “TRIB leveled the field,” former TRIB Board President Mike Tissot explained. “It didn’t tell you how to run your business. It just made sure you weren’t standing alone when you walked into a vendor conversation.”14 That distinction mattered. By pooling purchasing power without centralizing control, TRIB preserved the entrepreneurial character of rent-to-own while giving small and mid-sized dealers access, pricing, and credibility that would otherwise have been unreachable.

Once TRIB demonstrated that group purchasing could genuinely change prices and terms, the question became bigger than television sets. It became about the shape of the store itself. Shields later put it plainly: “Our goal was simple: make the small guy a one-stop shop. If a family could rent a television, why shouldn’t they rent the sofa it sits across from and the refrigerator in the next room?”15

The Furniture & Appliance Revolution

By 1985, TRIB had negotiated its first furniture programs with national manufacturers. Bedding came soon after. These weren’t small adjustments; they redrew the map of what a rent-to-own store could be. Blair remembered encouraging rental dealers to reimagine their physical footprint: “Get at least 4,000 square feet… so you can have the furniture.”16 He wasn’t exaggerating. Once stores added sofas, sectionals, and bedroom sets, the feel of the business changed. Customers began thinking about RTO as a way to furnish a home, not just replace a TV.

Furniture and appliances also stabilized revenue. Instead of short agreements tied to fast-moving electronics, store operators now had contracts that stretched two years or more. A 2020 RTOHQ retrospective described this moment as “the moment RTO grew up,” when independents stepped out of the electronics-only model and became full-line home retailers.33

As TRIB’s purchasing clout grew, so did the quality of the products offered to the channel. Manufacturers began making RTO-specific versions — durable fabrics, reinforced frames, service-friendly construction, and neutral colors that held up across rental cycles. Vendors increasingly relied on member feedback when planning new lines. Shields summarized the shift well: “We stopped being price-takers and started being product-makers.”17

The annual TRIB Group Meeting of the Minds soon became a working showroom where dealers evaluated prototypes, manufacturers gathered real-world input, and new programs took shape based on genuine need rather than guesswork.

Changing the Store & the Story

The shift into furniture and appliances didn’t just change the inventory — it changed customers’ first impression of a store. Instead of rows of boxed televisions, stores featured living-room and bedroom displays. Delivery trucks began moving washers, dryers, and full sets of furniture rather than a single 19-inch TV. And the story rental dealers told their customers shifted with it. RTO became less about transactions and more about helping a household function — something that aligned closely with APRO’s advocacy messaging around dignity, access, and utility.

Diversification also paid off on the balance sheet. Multi-category stores brought in steadier revenue and encouraged natural add-ons. A family that started with a washer might return for a bedroom set or a second television. Longer agreements reduced churn and smoothed operating costs. For independents accustomed to riding the highs and lows of electronics cycles, this stability felt like breathing room.

Professionalization Through Diversity

Selling furniture and appliances brought new expectations. Showrooms needed to be staged well. Delivery crews needed additional training. Bedding required sanitation protocols. TRIB’s vendor programs often came bundled with education, which pushed members — many of them single-store operators — toward more consistent professional standards.

By the early 1990s, most TRIB members were full-line home-furnishings and appliance providers. Electronics were still important, but they were no longer the engine of the business. That transformation laid the groundwork for the next generation of RTO, where inventory complexity, logistics sophistication, and customer-experience expectations would only continue to increase.

What began as a basic survival strategy — pooling purchasing power — became a structural change that reshaped the entire feel and function of the rent-to-own store.

The Mechanics of a Buying Group

Once TRIB demonstrated that pooled buying could meaningfully shift pricing, the next challenge was putting real structure behind it. Early group members quickly learned that cooperation had limits if it wasn’t backed by systems. Negotiating as a group required someone to manage relationships, track commitments, and make sure the deals actually worked once rental dealers got home.

Shields put it simply: “A buying group isn’t just about the deal — it’s about the machinery behind the deal: contracts, compliance, accountability.”18 That perspective guided TRIB from an informal alliance into a coordinated business tool.

Centralized Negotiation, Distributed Benefit

TRIB’s practical strength came from centralizing the negotiation work that individual store operators had previously done alone. Each year, the group’s vendor committee compared pricing, freight rules, rebate schedules, and service terms across categories — furniture, bedding, appliances, and electronics. They negotiated as one bloc, then published programs members could adopt immediately.

Blair recalled taking dealer leaders to High Point Market, where vendors who had once dismissed independents began offering rebates and tiered terms once the volume was presented collectively.19

The model remained lean: TRIB negotiated; dealers placed orders directly with vendors. No warehouses. No central billing. Just scale.

Membership & Accountability

TRIB membership required dues and a commitment to professional conduct with vendors. Because rental dealers purchased directly, the group’s credibility depended on members honoring agreements and paying on time. Shields often described TRIB as “a handshake organization backed by paperwork,” which captured the mix of trust and structure that defined its culture.20

TRIB relied more on peer expectations than on formal enforcement — stores that benefited from group programs but didn’t hold up their end heard from other operators long before they heard from staff.

Rebates & Program Economics

Vendor programs often included rebates or marketing-development funds tied to group volume. TRIB aggregated purchases, audited vendor reports, and distributed rebates proportional to participation, retaining a modest administrative fee to cover its own operations.

That structure gave independents a rare benefit: the chance to earn a return on inventory they were buying anyway. By the mid-2020s, TRIB reported more than 150 vendor partners and purchasing leverage that, if measured as a single entity, would place it among the top retail buyers in the home-furnishings space.21

Knowledge Sharing & Benchmarking

Beyond pricing, TRIB offered something independents rarely had access to: shared intelligence. Operators compared what products held up, which service programs worked, which vendors managed freight well, and which technologies were worth adopting.

As the industry moved deeper into digital operations, TRIB began partnering with technology providers to evaluate POS systems, delivery-routing tools, and analytics platforms designed especially for RTO — ensuring members weren’t left behind as national chains adopted more sophisticated systems.

Meeting of the Minds: TRIB’s Operating Core

TRIB’s annual Meeting of the Minds became both a buying event and an operating hub. Rental dealers walked vendor displays, placed orders, and participated in workshops on store layout, logistics, and technology adoption. The event also handled the group’s cooperative governance — board director elections, vendor committee updates, and member feedback sessions.

For many independents, the event served as an annual calibration point. Shields liked to say you could judge the health of the group by “how busy the hallway conversations were.”22

Cooperation Without Conformity

TRIB’s most durable achievement may be cultural rather than financial. It created a space where fiercely independent owners could share best practices without being told how to run their stores. Members ranged from single-store operators to multi-state chains, but the group never imposed a uniform model.

Shields described TRIB not as a franchise but as “a front porch — somewhere everybody shows up and goes home smarter.”23 That ethos made the cooperative resilient even as the industry evolved.

Business researchers often compare TRIB’s structure to other U.S. buying cooperatives — ACE Hardware, True Value, and regional grocer co-ops — where shared purchasing empowers independents to compete with larger players.

Those models validate what TRIB built: a mechanism that strengthens independent operators without erasing their autonomy. TRIB’s success became the template that Nationwide Marketing Group later used when expanding its RentDirect division, offering an even broader infrastructure while embracing the same core principle — independents survive when they act together.

Nationwide: New Ally in the Arena

By the early 2000s, TRIB Group had given independent rent-to-own dealers the purchasing strength they needed to compete with national chains. But scale in buying did not solve scale in visibility. Independent operators excelled in personal service and community trust, yet they lacked the marketing infrastructure that large competitors deployed — coordinated campaigns, digital analytics, and professional brand assets. Nationwide Marketing Group (NMG), long established as a cooperative supporting thousands of independent retailers, recognized that rental dealers faced the same structural disadvantage: their businesses had operational skill and customer insight, but not the broad-reach marketing platforms the modern marketplace demanded.

James MacAlpine & the Genesis of RentDirect

RentDirect began with James MacAlpine, an RTO veteran who understood both the strengths and vulnerabilities of independents. When MacAlpine joined Nationwide in 2005 to build its rent-to-own division, his goal was not to replace TRIB, but to pair its purchasing leverage with the professional marketing and technology infrastructure independents increasingly needed.24

MacAlpine often summed up the relationship this way: “TRIB builds the house; RentDirect makes sure the neighbors know you’re open.”45

Marketing as Competitive Leverage

RentDirect’s defining contribution was its marketing engine. Members gained access to ready-made advertising — video spots, digital banners, point-of-sale kits, and seasonal campaigns — aligned with national vendor calendars and customizable for local branding.25 Group media buying let even single-store operators participate in regional and digital advertising at rates impossible to secure alone.

The digital shift was particularly significant. Through Nationwide’s partnerships with SEO firms, search-ad specialists, and social-media consultants, rental dealers entered an era in which customers increasingly researched online before ever stepping into a store. RentDirect made that first impression competitive.26

Dual Membership: Community & Scale

Dealers quickly realized that TRIB and RentDirect served different but complementary needs. TRIB strengthened procurement and provided a peer-learning community built around RTO-specific operations. RentDirect delivered marketing horsepower, technology integration, and modern brand presence. Many successful independents joined both, adopting a two-lane strategy: TRIB for buying power; RentDirect for visibility and digital sophistication.

Nationwide’s long-standing relationships with major manufacturers — Samsung, LG, Whirlpool, GE, and others — also expanded access for rental dealers. Through RentDirect, independents entered vendor discussions backed by a cooperative with national retail presence, which strengthened both pricing and coordinated promotional support. Vendors benefited from reaching households they traditionally could not serve through credit-bound channels.

Education & Professionalization

Nationwide’s Learning Academy became a cornerstone of RentDirect’s value. The academy offered structured courses on sales psychology, product knowledge, digital analytics, and customer-experience design.50 These programs came to life at Nationwide’s PrimeTime shows — large-scale biannual expos that blended vendor exhibits with training on omnichannel retail, data-driven decision-making, and digital transformation. For many RTO operators, PrimeTime was the first place they encountered retail analytics as a strategic tool rather than a luxury reserved for big chains.

RentDirect also introduced independents to modern communication and reputation-management tools. Partnerships with firms such as Podium gave stores text-based customer engagement, automated review requests, and unified messaging dashboards.51 These integrations closed the loop between advertising and customer relationships, helping dealers track how online impressions translated into inquiries and rental agreements.

Cultural Fit & the Independent Spirit

RentDirect’s success hinged on understanding RTO culture. Dealers valued autonomy and resisted overly standardized models. Nationwide respected that, offering tools without imposing operations. Members adopted what fit their markets and left the rest. The ethos mirrored TRIB’s own cooperative spirit — support without conformity.

The Three Pillars of a Mature Ecosystem

By the 2020s, the independent RTO sector stood on a stable three-pillar foundation:

  1. APRO: the industry’s advocate, standard-setter, and public voice;
  2. TRIB Group: the cooperative engine for purchasing power and peer learning; and
  3. RentDirect/Nationwide: the marketing, technology, and modernization platform.

Together, these institutions allowed RTO independents to compete with national chains not through consolidation but through coordination — strength expressed through complementary capabilities rather than shared ownership.

TRIB & APRO: Complementing Communities

By the late 2010s, the rent-to-own ecosystem operated on a coherent, three-pillar foundation: APRO as the industry’s policy and professional association; TRIB Group as the buying group and peer-learning engine; and Nationwide’s RentDirect as the marketing and modernization platform. While TRIB and RentDirect helped smaller operators compete, APRO represented the entire industry — large and small firms, including publicly traded companies — before policymakers, media, and the public.

The distinction often blurred because both organizations served the same community, shared members, and collaborated throughout the year. But the mandates remained different: TRIB organized commerce; APRO organized credibility. Both were indispensable.

Shared Membership, Distinct Mandates

The overlap in membership between the two organizations was significant. Many rental dealers belonged to both organizations, yet the workstreams remained distinct. TRIB negotiated vendor programs, convened Meeting of the Minds, and accelerated operational innovation. APRO coordinated advocacy, produced research and legal guidance, and maintained professional standards across the industry. When dealers needed better terms or best practices, they turned to TRIB; when the industry needed a unified public voice, it turned to APRO.

Former APRO Executive Director Jill McClure captured the spirit of partnership when APRO and TRIB announced their joint national convention in 2018: “RTO World combines the strengths of both organizations… It’s the right timing for something new and innovative that will re-energize the industry.”27 During the 2020 all-virtual convention, she noted that the event “proved to convert well to virtual,” reinforcing the groups’ unity of purpose during a period of unprecedented disruption.28

RTO World: The Joint Stage

RTO World — jointly hosted by APRO and TRIB since 2018 — became the most visible expression of industry unity. From its inaugural announcement to the present, it has served as the central stage where RTO policy, education, networking, and vendor engagement converge.

The event blended APRO’s advocacy leadership with TRIB’s commercial expertise. Policy panels, legal briefings, and management sessions ran alongside vendor showcases, demos, and hands-on operational workshops. The combined convention illustrated a simple truth: the strength of the RTO industry lies in aligning public legitimacy with operational excellence.

Cultural Symbiosis & Mutual Amplification

APRO and TRIB also amplified each other’s work throughout the year. APRO highlighted TRIB vendor activity and dealer success stories; TRIB circulated APRO’s legislative alerts and compliance updates. Both organizations emphasized the same core message: RTO is essential, flexible, and regulated — an industry built around dignity and access.59

Some members still occasionally confused dues or governance responsibilities, but the distinction remained clear: TRIB was a member-owned buying cooperative; APRO was the national trade association representing the full industry. Their overlap was not redundancy; it was resilience.

APRO’s legislative voice, TRIB’s operational engine, and Nationwide’s marketing infrastructure formed a durable triad that allowed independent operators to compete with national chains not through consolidation, but through coordination.

As the RTO industry moves into an era of AI-driven search, policy shifts, and digital transformation, TRIB and APRO will remain interdependent. APRO will maintain the public narrative and defend the lease model; TRIB will keep independents efficient, competitive, and connected. Annual events — RTO World, Meeting of the Minds, PrimeTime — will continue to serve as the arenas where the industry’s identity, strategy, and community are renewed.

Proof in Partnership

By the close of the 2010s, the rent-to-own industry no longer resembled the fragmented landscape of its early years. What had once been a loose network of independent rental dealers had grown into a coordinated, data-literate, policy-savvy ecosystem. Buying groups like TRIB Group and RentDirect Nationwide had leveled the playing field once tilted toward national chains, giving smaller operators access to the same brands, technology, and marketing sophistication that defined larger retailers. The groups’ work allowed a neighborhood RTO store to project the professionalism and credibility expected of the biggest players in the market.

Yet the deeper story of this era is not efficiency — it is unity. The cooperative DNA that shaped TRIB, the strategic infrastructure behind RentDirect, and the advocacy architecture of APRO converged into a rare kind of industrial commons, one that prioritized collaboration over consolidation and shared strength over individual scale.

This unity found its fullest expression at RTO World, where APRO and TRIB brought together independent dealers, franchises, national corporations, vendors, policymakers, and educators under a single roof each year. On the exhibit floor, vendor programs were set for the year ahead; in breakout rooms, legislation and compliance concerns took center stage; and in the hallways, the spirit of mutuality that defined TRIB’s earliest meetings resurfaced in a modern key.

The lesson embedded in the buying-group era is simple and enduring: strength in numbers is not just about price — it is about presence. Presence in the market, presence in legislative and regulatory debates, and presence in the public imagination as a responsible and regulated industry serving American households with dignity, transparency, and flexibility.

The cooperative era of TRIB, RentDirect, and APRO proved that independent businesses could achieve parity with national chains through shared leverage and aligned purpose. But new forces were already rewriting the rules: economic volatility, regulatory shifts, digital competition, and the accelerating reach of artificial intelligence lay ahead.

Strength in numbers built the RTO industry; adaptability would determine its future.

Endnotes

  1. “2025 TRIB Meeting of the Minds.” APRO, www.rtohq.org/event/2025-trib-meeting-of-the-minds/, 2025
  2. “Homepage.” TRIB Group, tribgroup.com/. ↩
  3. “TRIB Group Profile.” Furniture Today, https://www.furnituretoday.com/business-news/rental-inudstry-buying-group-trib-profile/, 17 Sept. 2018. ↩
  4. Cleek, Jr., John. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Series, 2025. ↩
  5. “The Pros and Cons of Group Purchasing Organizations.” Source1Purchasing, source1purchasing.com/blog/the-pros-and-cons-of-group-purchasing-organizations/, 19 Jan. 2018; “Buying Into Buying Groups.” Sleep Savvy Magazine, sleepsavvymagazine.com. ↩
  6. Shields, Dennis. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Series, 2025. ↩
  7. Blair, John D. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Series, 2025. ↩
  8. “History.” TRIB Group, www.tribgroup.com/history.php. ↩
  9. “TRIB Group Holds Peachy Meeting of the Minds.” APRO, 2025. ↩
  10. “The Power of Partnerships.” Furniture Today, 15 Aug. 2019. ↩
  11. Blair, John D. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Series, 2025. ↩
  12. Shields, Dennis. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Series, 2025.
  13. “Cooperative Purchasing Models and Small Business Resilience.” U.S. Small Business Administration, 2018; “Independent Retail Co-ops in American Commerce.” University of Georgia Business History Series, vol. 14, 2017. ↩
  14. Tissot, Mike. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Series, 2025. ↩
  15. Shields, Dennis. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Series, 2025. ↩
  16. Blair, John D. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Series, 2025. ↩
  17. Shields, Dennis. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Series, 2025. ↩
  18. Ibid. ↩
  19. Blair, John D. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Series, 2025. ↩
  20. Shields, Dennis. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Series, 2025. ↩
  21. “TRIB Group Holds Peachy Meeting of the Minds.” APRO, 2025. ↩
  22. Shields, Dennis. Interview by Pete Shau. RTO Legends Series, 2025 ↩
  23. Ibid ↩1 ↩2
  24. “Meet Your Board: James MacAlpine.” APRO / RTOHQ, www.rtohq.org/2025/10/meet-your-board-james-macalpine/, 5 Oct. 2025. ↩
  25. “Benefits.” Nationwide Marketing Group, www.nationwidegroup.org/benefits/. ↩
  26. “Services.” Nationwide Marketing Group, www.nationwidegroup.org/services/. ↩
  27. “APRO and TRIB Group Collaborate on RTO World 2018.” APRO, www.rtohq.org/2017/08/apro-trib-group-collaborate-rto-world-2018/, 24 Aug. 2017. ↩
  28. “RTO World 2020 Delivers an Unconventional Convention.” APRO, 25 Sept. 2020. ↩
↑ Top

Upcoming Events



Mike Lewis

Mike Lewis is a Premier Rental Purchase franchisee with multiple stores and currently serves as Vice President of Operations. With 33 years of experience in the rent-to-own industry, he has spent the past 20 years working closely with franchisee owners and previously spent 12 years in Corporate RTO, gaining a strong foundation in the business.

For the past five years, Mike has been sharing his knowledge by teaching managers and franchisees at the company’s Training Center.

Outside of work, he enjoys time with his family, kids, and grandkids, and appreciates the simple things in life – especially riding his Harley Davidson with the sun on his face. If you know, you know!

Lauren Talicska

Arona Corporation dba Arona Home Essentials

Lauren Talicska is an experienced multi-channel marketing specialist and the Vice President of Marketing & Communications at Arona Home Essentials. She has found her home in the RTO community, supporting stores in branding, growth, and increasing traffic.

You may recognize Lauren as a former RTO vendor, including her time as a partner for Nationwide RentDirect, or her previous participation in the APRO Vendor Advisory Committee. Lauren calls Columbus, Ohio, home and spends her workday crafting and executing marketing promotions from inception to realization, all while supporting the branding and social media needs of all the Arona stores in 12 states (plus Puerto Rico!).

Charles Smitherman

APRO

Charles Smitherman, JD, PhD, CAE, became CEO of APRO in 2023, bringing years of legal and executive experience in the rent-to-own industry. 

Prior to joining the association, Charles served as COO, General Counsel, and Vice President of PTS Financial Services, where he played an active role in the rent-to-own industry by representing his company through PTS’s club program offering with APRO member dealers. Charles is an attorney with two decades of experience across a wide variety of areas, including RTO, consumer financial services, antitrust, corporate law, mergers and acquisitions, litigation, franchise law, and privacy law. Following law school at the University of Georgia, Charles earned a Master of Legal Studies and PhD in Law from the University of Oxford in England.

Charles is credentialed as a Certified Association Executive (CAE) with the American Society of Association Executives, a Certified Franchise Executive (CFE) with the International Franchise Association, and a Certified Information Privacy Professional (CIPP/US) and Certified Information Privacy Manager (CIPM) through the International Association of Privacy Professionals. As APRO’s sixth CEO in its 45-year history, he brings a collaborative, member-focused approach to association leadership, emphasizing transparency, advocacy, and value creation. Outside of work, Charles is an active ultra runner and open water swimmer.

Mike Kays

Ashley Furniture Industries

As VP of Rental Sales for Ashley Furniture Industries, Mike thrives on building relationships with our RTO industry veterans, and helping businesses grow through new product, new marketing, and new supply chain options.

Mike works to leverage a wide breadth of relationships and influence, intimate knowledge of market trends, and unique knowledge of what RTO dealers need from a supplier to be successful.

The saying goes that a high tide raises all boats, and our goal is to leverage the world’s largest furniture manufacturer to drive the continued growth of the RTO industry and all the suppliers.

Mike Tissot

Countryside Rentals Inc., dba Rent-2-Own

Mike grew up in the rent-to-own industry under the guidance of his father, former APRO President and RTO legend Darrell Tissot. For nearly 25 years, Mike’s innovative leadership has helped expand the family business to more than 40 stores across Ohio and Kentucky while also shaping the industry as a whole.

He has served as President of the Ohio Rental Dealers Association, an APRO board member and Treasurer, and President and Treasurer of the TRIB Group. His contributions have earned him the APRO President’s Award of Excellence and the title of APRO Rental Dealer of the Year.

Outside of RTO, Mike enjoys time at the lake house or in Orange Beach, Alabama, with his girlfriend, Angela Strong McCool. A passionate Cincinnati Reds fan, he rarely misses a game, whether watching or listening alongside his parents. He also takes every opportunity to visit Arizona, where his daughter is currently attending Arizona State University.